Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

I've turned my husband and he's turned his employer

89 replies

Umpteenthiteration · 21/05/2021 07:43

I've been banging on for the past three years or so about what is happening with gender ideology and how damaging it is to conflate sex and gender (whatever the heck 'gender' is). Husband has nodded along and make positive noises but didn't really seem to get it. But this morning he informed me that having been involved in a consultation at work about proposed plans for a diversity and inclusion day he made it clear that they needed to replace 'gender' with 'sex' as they were two completely different things. We're talking a major global organisation here and he was giving feedback at country-level. Go him!

The conversations we have with people do make a difference.
He's been radicalised by Mumsnet by proxy.

As you were Grin

OP posts:
RedDogsBeg · 21/05/2021 17:15

Fortunately my husband has always 'got it' and rages against it as much as I do. He enjoys watching and supporting women's sports - football, cricket, athletics, tennis, rugby and the very idea that TW will be taking part against women absolutely infuriates him and he is not afraid to speak out about it, he knows it will ruin women's sports and he would no longer watch or support it if it happens.

SirSamuelVimes · 21/05/2021 16:56

@Serpenta

' We also both listed ourselves on the census as superstraight.'

Why?

Because according to gender ideology (which the ONS seem to believe given what they were saying in court) as a straight woman, I am attracted to men, including transmen. DH, as a straight man, would be attracted to women, including transwomen. As that is not the case for either of us, we chose to define our sexuality as "superstraight" - attracted only to people of the opposite SEX, not including people of the same sex who identify as a different gender.

There was a good thread on here re. the superstraight idea (originally from a teen boy's til tok) if you are interested I will try to find it and link.

Nonmaquillee · 21/05/2021 16:44

I’ve not so much “turned” as opened the eyes of various family members as well as my DP who now likes to ask me what my pronouns are today etc...My younger son once mentioned some nonsense about “gender assigned at birth” for which I gave him very short shrift and he now definitely understands why...

Nonmaquillee · 21/05/2021 16:29

[quote Irishmom7]@Abhannmor Irreversible Damage is a very easy read though it was upsetting in places so I had to take breaks.

I didn’t nod along with every word and rolled my eyes once or twice. It is very American but a real eye opener. I haven’t read Helen Joyce book yet.[/quote]
I’ve read it - it’s really worthwhile

Dogman · 21/05/2021 16:26

I’d like to thank Laurel and the IOC for turning my husband. I’d been drip dripping for years. Laurel gave the final push.

MsTSwift · 21/05/2021 16:15

Dh and all my uni friends

Cagedbirdsinging · 21/05/2021 15:48

I turned the sister of our 'self ID/twaw' candidate , her boyfriend and my ndn on the evening before the election .
Puuuullll ...

Huckleberries73 · 21/05/2021 13:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Minezatea · 21/05/2021 13:01

It just seems good that there's a way to direct opposition into something that has a positive outcome for women in an organisation.

On one level I agree with you but if we take the full TWAW stance then women's rights are gone TBH and we are pissing in the ocean with things like this. If they are combined with a questioning of the whole ideology of 'gender identity' then they have real meaning.

You guys have made me very happy in reading this thread!

everybodysang · 21/05/2021 12:57

@Huckleberries73

I sadly have to write some of the bloody policies, but I write the trans ones, and then demand the same paid time off and counselling and leeway for women in the menopause policy I then demand.... citing that without it, they are only catering for one protected characteristic.....

So getting some really good women’s policies on the back of this bullshit.

I'd like to be absolutely upfront and say that I'm in really strong disagreement with most of you here on trans issues - and also that I'm happy with that position, and won't be changing my mind and I don't want to spend time justifying that position because I don't for a moment believe I'm going to change any of your minds either.

BUT this seems like a really brilliant move from @Huckleberries73. It seems like there's a lot of winners from pushing policies forward in this way. It also seems to me like really good ground for people of opposing viewpoints to meet on.

It just seems good that there's a way to direct opposition into something that has a positive outcome for women in an organisation.

Serpenta · 21/05/2021 12:53

' We also both listed ourselves on the census as superstraight.'

Why?

peadarm · 21/05/2021 12:50

@toffeebutterpopcorn

Good boy! Sad when it’s the men who have to push this bolder up the hill though.
Though men are less likely to be targeted and abused by TRAs...
DdraigGoch · 21/05/2021 12:46

@toffeebutterpopcorn

Good boy! Sad when it’s the men who have to push this bolder up the hill though.
Well they are 49% of the population so given that not all women are onboard, of course men need to be active too.
SirSamuelVimes · 21/05/2021 12:42

Puuuuulllllll indeed!!

My DH is totally turned. Outraged by the whole thing, he frequently has seen a thread on here and started a discussion with me about it before I've seen it. He has refused to answer "gender" questions at work and told them he doesn't have one, he has a sex, male. We also both listed ourselves on the census as superstraight.

I objected to only being asked my gender on an HR form for a school based role, told them under gdpr they can only record relevant information, and as sex is the characteristic in the equality act I would only agree to providing the information of Sex: Female for their records. They confirmed that they would record it as such and said they would review the HR form.

Drip drip drip.

WarriorN · 21/05/2021 12:37

I'd been yes deared till last week when a few key news articles (eg Weight lifting in Olympics and Lisa Keogh's case) and a query about pronouns for the penny to drop.

He actually thought people put pronouns in their twitter bio to be ironic. As everyone he has known of doing it is the sex they say they are.

He even did some basic maths calculations around numbers of trans people v numbers of women regarding language of "birthing people" and needing gender neutral toilets, and how many women it would affect, who would also be bothered. (Millions.)

Defaultname · 21/05/2021 12:36

@toffeebutterpopcorn

Good boy! Sad when it’s the men who have to push this bolder up the hill though.
It's the timid we need to push up the hill!

(Hee hee).

ifIwerenotanandroid · 21/05/2021 12:35

Oh, I love this thread! Flowers to all.

WoolOfBat · 21/05/2021 12:32

Amazing OP and OP’s DH!

🥂

WoolOfBat · 21/05/2021 12:31

I think some men are likely to get sports as an entry point @OhRene.

Have you tried to show him a link of the New Zealand weightlifter who may compete in the Olympics?

I would also show: Rachel McKinnon cycling, Fallon Fox’s tweets about crashing skulls and a picture of her opponent, the Australian transwoman rugby player (the size compared to biological women) and comment that this particular transwoman was allowed to play but was outraged as they wanted to shower with the other women. No surgery.

If your DH is into golf, I believe that there is a transwoman golfer who relatively recently failed to qualify as a man but now is smashing it as a transwoman.

Would any of those help?

Your DH might also be surprised at the statistics that about 50% of transwomen in prisons have a history of sexual assault. And are trying to get into women’s prisons (this peaked one of my female friends).

ArabellaScott · 21/05/2021 12:10

PUUULLLL.

Grin
ArabellaScott · 21/05/2021 12:09

Well done, OP and OP's DH! Fab.

CorvusPurpureus · 21/05/2021 11:27

I turned the Assistant Head with responsibility for pastoral issues the other week, when I went to rant at her about proposed resources for a whole school PSHE day.

Genderbread unicorn promptly went in the bin. Debate on sex-based stereotypes in school & the workplace went on the agenda.

Large chunk of the credit to JKR, to be fair - AH had vaguely heard about that, was agog at the details, & agreed it was ridiculous & vile the abuse JKR got for, as she concluded, 'well, she didn't say anything nasty & it was all just common sense, wasn't it?'

PUUULLLL.

OhRene · 21/05/2021 11:20

@Bordois you're right. So many men cannot see nor comprehend it. I showed DH a video of a Canadian woman who filmed a man following her for over 45 minutes, all around a city. He followed her anywhere from 10ft to 50ft away, turning right when she turned right, going left when she did, even walking around the same block in circles at one point, him crossing the street when she did and back again when she did and walking was all he was doing. Walking behind her.

After about two minutes of watching the over the shoulder video I saw it for what it was. A Male intimidating, scaring and threatening a women. But my DH took most of the very long video, with added prompting from me to finally stop saying, "Yeah but he's not actually doing anything though" and "He's just walking. He's allowed to walk!" to "oh that is a bit creepy isn't it?" And my husband is a sweetheart! Wouldn't ever think to be like that.

But he doesn't get it.

Bordois · 21/05/2021 11:10

I think a lot of men "get it" in the same way as a white person "gets" racism. When its over there happening to people then although we can say how terrible it is, and how it shouldn't be happening we don't really understand how it can infiltrate everyday life and how it makes you feel even when "something" isn't happening.

Its going to take a lot more men actually having the realities metaphorically slapping them around the head for any actual change to happen. Which means women and children being hurt.

Irishmom7 · 21/05/2021 10:27

@Abhannmor Irreversible Damage is a very easy read though it was upsetting in places so I had to take breaks.

I didn’t nod along with every word and rolled my eyes once or twice. It is very American but a real eye opener. I haven’t read Helen Joyce book yet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread