Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

He/Him

79 replies

Tibtom · 05/05/2021 16:06

First time I have had someone reply with this after their name. I know the whole pronouns business so perhaps it is a surprise it has taken until now. But the thing that struck me is it is not a neutral statement; it comes across as a stamp of authority/control. We live in a sexist society where is it acknowledged additional supports need to be in place for women. Yet here we are in a situation where men proclaim their status in their emails. "I am male, I am from the oppressor class, I am your lord and master"

Is this just me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EyesOpening · 08/05/2021 09:21

@BlackAlys

A colleague at my school has suggested that we all do it.

Not me, thanks very much.

I've also been told of a group of Year 7's who are asking all their teachers what their pronouns are. I teach one of the children so am waiting for the question.

Any ideas how to answer them without flagging myself up as the anti Christ?

I haven’t had anyone ask me yet but I’m planning to go with “whatever you’ve been using so far about me because I haven’t had a problem with it yet”
Iootraw1 · 08/05/2021 09:14

Sorry endoplasmicreticulum I didn’t mean to quote you. I meant to respond to poster who talked about being school staff and what to do if asked to declare pronouns.

Iootraw1 · 08/05/2021 09:13

@EndoplasmicReticulum

If you're a teacher your pronoun will be "miss". Male equivalent "sir".

Always annoyed me.

I would tell them it’s up to them to decide depending on how they perceive you. (That’s what’s we’ve been doing for many centuries after all). We look at someone and refer to them how we find them. - looks like a man? Refer with male pronouns, looks like a women ? Then refer with female pronouns. Genuinely can’t tell? Whisper desperately to someone who might know - “woman or man ?”, before addressing them. If I was still working in a school I’d honestly find it funny if any of the children then decided to call me Mr or use he/him pronouns in front of other staff, which is quite likely if you say they can decide according to how they see you because being kids being kids would find it rather amusing and devilish to purposely select the opposite for you. It would certainly make other staff wake up and realise how bonkers this all is - they would naturally want to tell the pupils to call you by your real title (Miss/Mrs) but would realise they can’t because you have ‘declared’ your pronouns to be as they always have been - FREE TO CHOOSE ACCORDING TO WHAT WE SEE/THINK/PERCEIVE.
NiceGerbil · 06/05/2021 20:27

It's a bit like every time you meet someone at the (very male) industry events, everyone you meet says hello! I'm a man. My name is Dave. And you say hello! I'm a woman. My name is sue.

When you're at something like Oktoberfest in London where there's lots of women in durndels with blonde plaits serving steins to mostly men who are a bit pissed. And you have long blonde hair and are clearly female and so get treated by many of the men as they treat the women in durndels.... Which by the way is not good, the understanding is the men are there to be entertained and the attractive women are there to be looked at etc...

How does pointing out to every man I meet that I'm a woman and him saying yes and I'm a man help?

Yeah it's all a bit odd.

Not least the dynamic of a lot of these corporate events.

WarriorN · 06/05/2021 19:58

If you work in a male dominated industry, it doesn't half emphasise that.

It's also very sexist.

Academics who have a PhD and so use Dr rather than mr or mrs, finally have a levels of equality in emails and letters. Their sex can be anon.

Whack a bloody pronoun on and all that goes. There's been studies on sexist responses to male or female names.

MissBarbary · 06/05/2021 19:53

@Shizuku

I mean, it couldn't possibly be that he just wants to show some solidarity with a vulnerable minority could it?

So hilarious watching you trying to turn every single trans inclusive act or statement into something dark and sinister.

I'm sort of with you / not with you on this.

I personally think stating your pronouns is a risible act of virtue signalling nonsense but I'm really not seeing that it's aggressive, territorial pissing, telling you am a man or anything else dark and sinister.

MissBarbary · 06/05/2021 19:50

They're just "virtue signalling prat" to me- whether male or female. Prime example was Jeremy Corbyn.

CardinalLolzy · 06/05/2021 19:45

Lots of women have experience with males making sure you know they're "male". See it all the time with privileged classes - know your place etc.

LadyBuffOfBuffdonia · 06/05/2021 18:46

Typical Aquarius!

Shizuku · 06/05/2021 18:42

I mean, it couldn't possibly be that he just wants to show some solidarity with a vulnerable minority could it?

So hilarious watching you trying to turn every single trans inclusive act or statement into something dark and sinister.

YellowPenPinkPen · 06/05/2021 18:25

They've either been captured, or they're a prat.

stressbandit · 06/05/2021 15:47

Hate all of this she/her stuff also or the worst one is they/them. I don't understand why people need to do this? I find it really odd and I hope my kids grow up normal and not feeling the need to do it.

StealthPolarBear · 06/05/2021 15:44

The comparison to star signs is excellent

LadyBuffOfBuffdonia · 06/05/2021 15:03

I'm up for enforced stars signs instead.
It'd be interesting to see the sweeping generalisations born of that:

Arrogant Aries
Stubborn Taurus
Attention seeking Leo

Of course it's all rubbish, DH is an introvert Leo, but it makes about as much sense and relevance as gender woo.

VickyEadieofThigh · 06/05/2021 15:00

If ever asked by the organisation I work for to do this, I'm considering either replying with 'That triggers my uncertainty about my gender and seeing anyone put pronouns in their signature also triggers it - have you considered the impact of this?' OR putting 'Pronouns: I. Don't. Care'.

Pinkpaisley · 06/05/2021 14:59

My DH has it in his work email now. He works in a male dominated field. I also work in a male dominated field. I’ve raised this issue with him several times focusing on how he is making it harder for women in a male dominated industry. He won’t change his signature. It’s an edict from his boss and it’s not a battle he is willing to fight. My point that he is only free to not choose to fight that battle because he is a man fell on deaf ears.

I would normally consider my DH very enlightened and distinctly feminist, but on this issue, he has really bought into the “it’s kind” argument.

Vargas · 06/05/2021 14:51

Veggie box delivery CEO (Abel and Cole) has she/her in her newsletter profile. Utterly pointless wankery. I would love to know the thought process that went behind why on earth she thought her customers would give a flying fuck what her pronouns are? It's about as useful as knowing her star sign...

Ameanstreakamilewide · 06/05/2021 14:22

A fella I work with did it too and I instantly lost all respect for him.

LadyBuffOfBuffdonia · 06/05/2021 13:06

Any ideas how to answer them without flagging myself up as the anti Christ?
Paddington state.
Followed by questioning.
When are third person pronouns used?
Why are third person pronouns used?
Why would you need to know my pronouns?
If you teach English
Why are pronouns the only part of speech anyone seems to remember? Can they suggest ways to make subordinate clauses and exclamations this memorable?

Beowulfa · 06/05/2021 12:20

@WyldStallions

My autistic son was asked this recently. His rather nihilistic response: "I have no pronouns. Do not refer to me in any way."
That's brilliant.
QuentinBunbury · 06/05/2021 12:03

DP has it in his signature block, he is senior in his organisation.
He is trying very hard to make their organisation a more diverse and inclusive place as its dominated by white males. I know he is not doing it to demonstrate authority.
Hes doing it because he's been told by the LGBT group at work that it will make it easier for trans people to disclose their identity in his team. A marker of being a "safe" person if you will.

It makes it really complicated. If I had to put pronouns on my signature I honestly don't know what I'd put, I don't feel female I just am, and I'd love to simply identify out of my oppression. But I can't.

She/her is something society has given me, not something I've chosen

deydododatdodontdeydo · 06/05/2021 11:02

I would assume they'd been pressured or shamed into doing it like many of us.

Fromage · 06/05/2021 10:21

Bergamotte you have educated me/I.

I am rather taken with bink/bonk and will consider making up my own special snow/flake pronouns and changing them at will.

Maybe pay/gap or redundancy/candidate or maternity/leave which is what she/her signifies to many clueless wombles in the workforce.

CardinalLolzy · 06/05/2021 08:31

@NiceGerbil

In s sexist org with a huge pay gap it would seem to me to be a bit... Yeah. What the OP said.
Exactly. "I am considerably more male than yow"
WyldStallions · 06/05/2021 07:52

My autistic son was asked this recently.
His rather nihilistic response:
"I have no pronouns.
Do not refer to me in any way."

Swipe left for the next trending thread