Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

AskHumza

55 replies

Sexnotgender · 27/04/2021 16:03

Excellent questions being asked of Humza on twitter.

I believe he’s blocking women rather than answering.

Do any of our Muslim members know the answer to the question in the photo as Humza hasn’t answered it.

AskHumza
OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 29/04/2021 00:32

Why is it bigoted?

It's quite well known that some religions have different rules for men and women. Most of the main ones in fact. And that they may vary a bit between different strands of the religion but are a thing.

The fact that women and men worship separately is just that. A fact.

This man has been instrumental in implementing a law which caused a lot of heavily reported debate, concerns etc. He's a politician. He defended his view and the law is now in force. Also fact.

The question takes something that has for a long time had separation for women and men and that the minister for justice will be familiar with. And is subject to protection (religion). And so can separate men and women for xyz same as plenty of other mainstream religions do.

And said, put your money where your mouth is.

I don't understand why you think stating a well known fact about a religion and asking a question is in any way an attack on the religion.

The exact same question was asked when Ireland did it, whether trans men would be welcome to join the priesthood.

Reasonable question. Very reasonable. Like I say, put your money where your mouth is.

Answer to the latter is no, there's an exception in the law.

Same as in English law hereditary peerages etc which still go to the oldest son (!) have a bit which say actually trans men aren't men when it comes to that.

Funny. Isn't it. Revealing. Also strange that the activists are not going after those transphobic exceptions.

And anyway. The thing now seems to be to call anyone who disagrees with you a racist etc so, seems little point in rejecting a pointed question because of that.

Sexnotgender · 28/04/2021 09:05

Yours are also excellent questions and ones I’m sure Humza will be delighted to answer.

OP posts:
aweegc · 28/04/2021 07:28

I don't really see why that's such a good question. Far better in my mind would be to ask about the practicing Muslim woman having being excluded from exercise because the single sex swimming sessions or team sport is no longer single sex, or about the practicing Jewish orthodox or Muslim woman who requested a woman provide intimate care and then have a transwoman appear.

The question asked can easily be twisted to appear to be attacking a religion, which in this instance where "bigot" is the standard (veiled) response, is essentially walking straight into that response.

NancyDrawed · 28/04/2021 06:56

That is, indeed, an excellent question!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/04/2021 23:35

Missed this, will have a look!