Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

'Mother' and 'Father' advised against.

57 replies

AdaFuckingShelby · 13/03/2021 10:07

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-56372118

What's next? Primary care giver day?

OP posts:
andyoldlabour · 13/03/2021 12:34

Quadzilla

"so you can be rewarded by climbing their Workplace Index."

That will be "The wokeplace". Are these supposedly intelligent organisations really so scared of Stonewall that they are forced to perform actions which are more typical of an extreme religious cult?

AdaFuckingShelby · 13/03/2021 12:30

I agree Melroses . Completely understandable in a school setting where parental/guardian consent is required for things. But in a university I can't help but feel it's part of the erosion of the sexes.

OP posts:
WarOnWomen · 13/03/2021 12:16

Also, when you meet someone you might say do you have any siblings but you quickly start talking about brothers/sisters once it's established what they have. Same with partner and wife/husband parent and mum/dad.

So it's fine for initial contact but I'd think you were a bit weird for continuing to talk about sibling when I've clearly said sister and parent when I've said mum.

WarOnWomen · 13/03/2021 12:12
  • WITHOUT using the word Asian
Melroses · 13/03/2021 12:11

Parent or Guardian is appropriate in a school situation, because it is addressed to the person(s) who have legal responsibility to the child.

It makes no sense beyond that though. Certainly not adults at university.

WarOnWomen · 13/03/2021 12:11

I prefer these:

•	Parent or guardian, rather than mother or father
•	Partner, rather than husband or wife
•	Sibling, rather than brother or sister
•	Artificial or synthetic, rather than man-made
•	Humankind, not mankind
•	Workforce, not manpower
•	We provide cover or staff, rather than to 'man'

I do not like:

•	You or they/their/them, not he/she or him/her
•	People/person or individual(s), rather than man/men or woman/women

It reminds me of when someone was looking for a colleague and everyone was saying "black hair, short, wearing blah, blah" and I sat there amused as everyone tried to describe the person using the word Asian.

WarOnWomen · 13/03/2021 12:02

@Lilyofthevalleys

Are they rebranding as Personchester university?

Haha 😂

highame · 13/03/2021 11:52

I remember Partner....

highame · 13/03/2021 11:50

I think if Stonewall are involved then my automatic reaction is a lip curl but over the years neutral terms have been introduced that really do make sense. Parent seems perfectly reasonable and in various settings works really well but this doesn't mean words like mother and father etc dissappear, it depends on context.

I remember starting to be used and it didn't take long to adjust though lots of people did and still do use terms like wife and husband. No one is offended, it shows the variety of our relationships.

Now if they were telling me the word mother no longer existed then I would tell you where to sling your hook!

Imnobody4 · 13/03/2021 11:00

I think the reaction is a bit OTT. I've been doing this for decades. The crunch is when people are being banned from using sex specific words at all . For example if I know someone I'll refer to husband or wife or partner or mother or grandad. But if don't know them I'll choose neutral terms.
It's the fact that staff have asked for guidance that bothers me. Is it that they're being subjected to nitpicking criticism and denunctiation from some quarters.

Biscuitsanddoombar · 13/03/2021 10:57

My letters from school were addressed to “dear parent/guardian” I assume it’s just easier when doing a mass mailing to all parents. There are so many things to be pissed off about but I don’t see this as a problem

ParadiseIsland · 13/03/2021 10:54

Sorry but apart from the first line, I can’t see the issue.

A partner vs husband/wife has nothing to do with gender but the recognition that you might be a couple wo being married.

Some people will be orphans/in care so guardian is more appropriate (and can be found in all the school’s doc at my dcs school)

Etc...

cisterectomy · 13/03/2021 10:52

Back in the 80s I ended up refusing to take letters home addresses to Mrs (my surname) as I wasn't raised by my mum and dad so the Mrs of the house had a different surname, I made such a nuisance It was explained why by the secretary and head many times why they genetically sent letters to Mrs child's surname. One day my exhasperated teacher Mrs F handed me a letter, and it was addressed to parents and guardians. I didn't complain for me really I went to school with kids in care/foster and had taken action when I'd seen Tony B cry in the cloakroom, he lived with his grandparents, his parents had died. He didn't need to tell me why it was the first time I just knew why. It hurts like fuck to be a kid without a mum or dad and have teachers constantly tell you or ask you take take letters home to mummy and daddy. It's was a constant othering and heartbreak. Im proud enough of that action to tell people about now more than 30years later and the fact I started it in my school Ill take credit for it being standard now. If you were raised in a 2 parent or even 1 parent home you don't know the feeling. And if it stopped another little kid crying in the cloackroom clutching a letter they couldn't deliver to mummy or daddy no matter how much they wanted to. I don't care.

OnlyTeaForMe · 13/03/2021 10:49

I read the headline and then the article expecting to be outraged, but actually, I think this is common and sensible practice in schools and unis.
If they are forbidding the students from calling the adult human female who gave birth to them 'Mother' then I would have reason to be outraged.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 13/03/2021 10:45

I really can't see the problem...it's not like the students have been told they can't refer to their parents as mother or father it just means the staff need to be mindful that not all families are the same.

butterfly990 · 13/03/2021 10:38

I thought the term "mother" was now deemed gender neutral or am I out of date with current thinking 🤔

eeyore228 · 13/03/2021 10:36

I avoid using any terms when I can. I recall taking a phone call from someone who sounded female but the person was in fact transitioning to male. I was corrected and then threatened. I was mortified because I would not intentionally offend anyone, I apologised immediately and he continued to verbally abuse me. He then made a formal complaint that I was transphobic. Luckily for me manager was with me when I took the call, otherwise Im not sure what would have happened. Sad

FlowersAreBeautiful · 13/03/2021 10:33

Why do these 'ideas' seem to spring up around mother's Day and international woman's Day. Be interesting to see if there's anything around father's day

Deliriumoftheendless · 13/03/2021 10:28

Using parent/guardian is appropriate when you don’t know the family situation, I think.

I work in primary and use the term “a grown up at home” if I don’t know the kid well- some kids live with aunties, grandparents, are in care etc. Some don’t have mums due to bereavement, some have been left by parents. So there’s all that as well.

Obviously you wouldn’t say “your grown up” to a uni student, but if you don’t know who they have at home it is genuinely inclusive to use parent/carer. I would say if you know your student lives with mum/etc it’s better to use the word mum/etc.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/03/2021 10:26

A University of Manchester spokesperson said it had "simply produced a guidance document for our staff that encourages the use of more inclusive language to avoid bias or assumptions".

"In that, we recommend the use of the term 'parent/guardian'," they added.

"This is well established terminology and does not in any way mean that we are banning the words 'mother' or 'father'."

That sounds perfectly fine and sensible, and actually quite surprising it wasn't already the norm.

DaisyWaldron · 13/03/2021 10:24

since giving birth.

DaisyWaldron · 13/03/2021 10:23

I really don't see what the issue is. I think I've been a "parent or guardian" on just about every child-related letter I've ever had some nice giving birth. And I'm in my mid forties and finding Mother's Day incredibly hard this year after losing my mother - assuming that everyone has a mother or a father (or a husband or a wife) when that's clearly not going to be the case for everyone is just inconsiderate. Use the word "mother" if you know it's appropriate, and use more widely-applicable words when you don't.

JellySlice · 13/03/2021 10:22

From what is in the article this change seems reasonable. Why not use sex-neutral and gender-neutral language where sex and gender are irrelevant?

ErrolTheDragon · 13/03/2021 10:20

This sounds like a bit of a non-story tbh. Using a neutral wording 'parent or guardian' is afaik completely normal for letters from school for instance. It avoids the assumption of a 2 parent heterosexual household in which the mother does the bulk of the parenting, for instance.

In most cases the move to sex neutral language is a good thing. It's bad only when misapplied to situations which truly are sex specific eg anything pertaining to pregnancy and childbirth.

AfternoonToffee · 13/03/2021 10:19

Some of it just seems good advice though, I can't help but think it is a bit of a storm in a teacup. Lots of posters on here complain about the term ladies and everyone is just as welcoming.

I think it is a bit OTT to have guidance, but we live in a time where people are so fearful of saying the wrong thing in case in unleashes the wrath of doom that they want their backs covered. So it as a start of a pushback maybe.

Swipe left for the next trending thread