Staniland Question is so good. Can we think of others?

In the same vein, it is understood that if you enter a changing room, you consent to be naked in front of whoever is permitted to be in there.
So what happens if you do not wish to consent to be in a state of undress in the presence of a man? Are you expected just to avoid all changing rooms? Are Muslim women in particular to be excluded from swimming pools because they cannot risk being seen by a strange man?

When people who have prostates are called men in prostate cancer literature is this a discriminatory , transphobic act as transmen don't have prostates?

Of course we know that only women have uteruses, ovaries, vaginas, etc. And a woman who no longer has some of those parts is still a woman. Her DNA hasn't been altered.

It seems to us unnecessary to explain that but TRAs think they have an "aha!" moment when it's pointed out that only women can become pregnant and give birth, and they ask what about the women who can't, and are they not women, etc.

They seem to confuse
Only A can do X
with
All A must be able to do X.

If TWAW and TMAM, at what point does a Trans Man concede to being biologically female to be given life saving surgery and treatment for sex based diseases such as Ovarian Cancer?

Is it fair that Government financed lobby groups are advocating the removal of the single sex exemptions from the Equality Act Exemptions which allow for example single sex rape crisis centres?

This question really slams the point home.

(and if not, why not?)

As FTF is a valid transgender Identity; Can a FTF be on a trans panel? www.google.com/amp/s/beyond-mogai-pride-flags.tumblr.com/post/167350281550/ftf-transgender-pride-flag/amp

@EdgeOfACoin

Those of are very good. It's important for me to state that I don't believe Stephoknee represents transgender people, but that proponents of the ideology should give some thought to the acceptance without exception mantra in these cases. They might find themselves answering no to your questions but not able to articulate why that person's self-identification is not valid or in good faith. Because they're not willing to do any critical thinking.

The Guardian style guide has it as 'female genital mutilation' still (and not to use 'female circumcision'. www.theguardian.com/guardian-observer-style-guide-f

Am I right in thinking that the Guardian now refers to FGM as Forced Genital Mutilation rather than Female Genital Mutilation?

I heard that somewhere, but not sure if it's true.

Stefonknee is quite good for questions:

Do you believe this person is a six-year-old girl?

Do you believe this person is female but not six?

Why do you believe that they are transgender but not transage?

If you believe that some people are born in the wrong body but that Stefonknee is not one of those people, why not?

Should Stefonknee be treated as a six-year-old and allowed unfettered access to children's spaces?

I went on POF looking for a female partner. Fully one in twelve people were transwomen.

I think many transwomen who register on these sites are seeking the total validation of their new gender identity. Straight women are not enough as they are attracted to the male body, so it has to be lesbians

Should lesbian and gay dating services be forced to allow members of the opposite sex to register on them?

If there is such a thing as 'boy brain' and 'girl brain', then could that not be observed at the 20 week anomaly scan during pregnancy?

How do dogs know the difference between "men" and "women"??

Now that's a great question - because they do seem to know the difference don't they?

Smell?

Now that she's realised that it would have to be 'cis girls and other people with a vulva‘ , will she realise exactly how awkward it would be for Hibo and others like her to have to say all that?

Plus, and it sickens me write this, as FGM can include removal of all or part of the vulva for those whose whose lives this directly affects, is she saying they are no longer people, or girls or women?

I have no words for her crassness.

She mostly seems confused about what she's arguing.

It honestly didn't seem to occur to her that a little girl could suffer FGM and not be "cis".

Now that she's realised that it would have to be 'cis girls and other people with a vulva', will she realise exactly how awkward it would be for Hibo and others like her to have to say all that? Hibo is trying to deliver punchy, effective messages that make people stop and think about a tradition and persuade them to reject the tradition.

She's not trying to lull people to sleep or write a Butlerian thesis that 5 people will read.

Those tweets are horrific - and she just keeps on going. Fml.

She was either being massively goady with that tweet or she's so mired in the ideology she didn't grasp the point Almut was making.

These people are contemptible.

Trans-age has been done- this 6 year old girl was adopted by a family in Canada:

OMG!

^^ I look forward to her medalling at the next Olympics in the mental gymnastics event. Will she also compete in the jumping through hoops and over-reach disciplines?

[quote 334bu]Should we replace Female in FGM with People because some people think talking about women and girls with regard to FGM is transphobic?

Nora Imlau on Twitter

twitter.com/planet_eltern/status/1362713672737583112[/quote]
Those tweets are horrific - and she just keeps on going. Fml.

The little girls lives and the life long damage she is hand waving away because we must always remember to centre men. The only positive from her insane ideals is the ratios, and comments, and sunlight.

twitter.com/planet_eltern/status/1362750164646187014

I wasn't trivialising it or anything, just shining a light on how important words are and that they mean what they are intended to. The appropriation of our words is contemptible.