Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How do I deal with traditional inlaws?

106 replies

AliceWonderland88 · 22/01/2021 13:01

A bit of background: My Husband-to-be is from another country and we have had many discussions about expectations before becoming engaged. I was so delighted until I found out his family's expectations of me as his wife to basically become his servant and cook, clean, take care of the children AND his parents while somehow keep running my business. I am English and this isn't my fiance or I's expectation of my role in our marriage. However, his family bring it up nearly every time I see them now and it's beginning to get in the way of our relationship. I have made it clear to them but obviously don't want to offend them. My fiance doesn't say anything and would rather bury his head in the sand and claims he didn't know anything about this expectation from his family. How can I approach this in a firm but cordial way? Thanks in advance

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MmeLaraque · 25/03/2021 11:50

@ThePoetsWife

This may all sound small but it's constant. My partner gets left to relax and I am expected to serve food and drinks and even clean their house when it's not even my home. I let him off sometimes because he's often not around when this happens as I visit them while he is at work.

FFs why did he relax? Why didn't he stand up to them? Why didn't he take on the chores/help?

You have a DH?DP problem.

This. You have a DP problem.

I cannot *imagine being expected to clean someone else's house, except under the most extenuating circumstances (e.g. they died/had a terrible accident and it's a one-off event).

Doing it under the circumstances you describe here? No. If, somehow, we ended up going to clean someone else's house under those extenuating circumstances noted, DH (and indeed our offspring) would be mucking in. No ifs. Not buts.

AliceWonderland88 · 11/02/2021 11:51

I mentioned previously in this thread that I DO say NO to a lot of their requests. I do have a backbone and have told them that it is not my job to care for my fiance like a baby and that we are a team. They look at me like I'm an alien! I'm happy to make the occasional cup of coffee but I'm not hoovering their apartment and when they tell me to do stuff I look at my fiance and say "go on then" lol trust me I'm pretty blunt these days lol. It just doesn't stop and I feel like I am talking to a brick wall and no one sees a problem with it but me :(

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 23/01/2021 05:45

If he doesn’t want to as he secretly holds their views of can’t stand up to them now, what chance will there be in the future?

Right now you’re in the strongest position you will ever be in vis a vis his family. You’re not married and you don’t have a child. Pregnancy, childbirth and looking after children is very tiring at best. So if you’re not standing up to them now, you don’t have a hope in hell of standing up to them in the future.

Consequently that’s both of you not standing up to them. Something has to change. And don’t let it be your marital status unless or until this is sorted. At the same token be very careful not to waste years on this man if he won’t / can’t change.

Also be very aware, unless you’re going to go low or no contact, the in laws will become more annoying and hold more importance in your life the further your marriage progresses and the older they get.

All in all your fiancé seems fine with the status quo. If he weren’t, he’d be prepared to change it if he risks losing you so I’d be testing him now and deciding my future. If you don’t do anything, you are actually effectively making a choice to accept the situation as is.

custardbear · 23/01/2021 04:55

Personally I'd call it off unless he tells his family you're not slaving foe them, some men from other cultures like this can and do change once they've trapped you, sounds like you're on this pathway if he doesn't respect you enough to stand up fir you now

GallowsHumour · 23/01/2021 04:33

Marrying him would be an act of insane stupidity.

Also, let’s call it what it is. Your part ex’s parents aren’t ‘traditional’, they’re misogynistic.

Smallonesaremorejuicy · 23/01/2021 04:26

Please be very very careful, I would be more worried that he wasn’t a weak husband, but a strong wilful one , who knows exactly what he intends for your life to be like once you are married & especially when you have a child. Run as fast as you can .

Gooseysgirl · 23/01/2021 01:09

Run for the hills.

MrDarcysMa · 23/01/2021 00:50

Ermmm I wouldn't be marrying him until he's made crystal clear to his parents that you won't be his/ their servant. Why hasn't he said anything ?! Hmm

BananaPop2020 · 23/01/2021 00:43

This has got disaster written all over it,

Svalberg · 23/01/2021 00:37

@chipolte

Sorry OP, I wasn’t calling you weak, I meant that is how his parents see you.
She is though. OP, either grow a backbone or accept that you're a doormat. In my relationship, I do/did things for my DPs & my DH does things for his. There has never been any conflict between us about this. In my DPs house, DH is treated as a guest, in his DPs house, I'm treated as a guest. If anyone vacuums his DPs house, it's him, not me! He doesn't even expect me to make a cup of coffee when we're there.
Newbreadsmell · 22/01/2021 21:37

FUCK! How can he just stand there and expect you to act like some sort of servant? Wtf is going through his head?

Imagine this was reversed... he would tell you to sort it out pronto or he’d be off, yes??

mrstasty · 22/01/2021 21:03

Bloody hell, what culture are they from? It sounds awful. Are they elderly?

BernardsarenotalwaysSaints · 22/01/2021 20:47

If he really had your back he'd have told them a long time ago that what they expect of you will not be happening. I'm not sure how loudly we have to say this but please RUN

chipolte · 22/01/2021 20:39

Sorry OP, I wasn’t calling you weak, I meant that is how his parents see you.

chipolte · 22/01/2021 20:28

They have been testing the boundaries to see how much you will put with. You have shown them what you will put up with it (ie. much more than most women would).

By letting your fiancé relax while you get told to serve food etc. you are confirming to your fiancé that you are prepared to do all of life’s drudge work for him, and you will go with what his parents say even though you don’t like it.

Do you honestly expect this situation to improve when you have kids? When his parents are older and therefore expect more ?

Many women from traditional cultures born and brought up here no longer put up with this nonsense (I know as I am one of them) so men like this look for an English girl who is weak and voluntarily is willing to put up with it instead. You would be an utter fool to marry this man.

yummyeclair · 22/01/2021 20:23

Hello OP, from experience I can tell you actions speak louder than words . If your DP does not tell his parents now , he never will . Believe me I eventually walked out after being expected to do everything for him and his family. Essentially a servant/slave for PIL. A DP who doesn't speak up now, never will. You will have no privacy or freedom . In some traditional families women are not treated as equal or respected. It is not always the culture but individuals in an extended family who behave in this manner to daughter in laws. Good luck .

partyatthepalace · 22/01/2021 19:49

@DecemberSun

It sounds as though he agrees with them, OP. Run while you can.
This. I’d give him one chance to prove himself but wouldn’t hold my breath
Milkshake7489 · 22/01/2021 19:42

If you don't want to put up with this forever, and potentially have any future children witness you being treated as a servant, you explain to your husband that he needs to put them straight.

You telling them obviously doesn't work... they need to hear from their son that he won't put up with you being disrespected in that way.

If he won't speak up for you, I wouldn't marry him (but that's just me).

Whatsnewpussyhat · 22/01/2021 19:35

My partner gets left to relax and I am expected to serve food and drinks and even clean their house when it's not even my home

Fucking hell OP, can't you see this is just the start. Once married they will own you.
If you are passive enough to accept this shit already you have no chance later.

What on earth don't you say no!!! Cleaning their house ffs. You know how it will be or you wouldn't have asked here.

If someone told me to serve food in someone else's house or hoover I'd laugh in their bloody face and leave.

Yogaposer · 22/01/2021 19:21

People will wonder why I can't leave but thats a whole other thread.

Yogaposer · 22/01/2021 19:20

Haven't read the full thread but I will once the kids are in bed.
In my bitter experience, my husband (both of us British-Indian) said we would only live with his parents until we got a deposit for our own place... that was ten years ago. The deposit was saved up and yet...we are still fucking here. It's not been a bed of roses, they aren't bad people but I just want some bastard space.
Plus DH's interfering siblings get on my nerves.
So I guess what I'm trying to say is, don't fall for any promises of how things will be different. My mental health is shot.

Whatwouldscullydo · 22/01/2021 19:14

Do not marry him.

He'd not be sitting down relaxing he'd be helping you if he really was as great as you say.

He'd be standing up for you. Not enjoying the perks of other people treating you like the hired help

Do not marry him

NotMeNoNo · 22/01/2021 19:06

You need a trial run of some interventions all done with wide eyed cheerfulness and you need to be a solid double act. And prepared.

So e.g. they ask you to make the coffee
You turn to him "shall we make some coffee?"
Him "you relax Alice I'll make them, yes really mum I will, I often do at home"

See success in getting through before you commit. Its as much or more your fiancees job to sort this.

ThePoetsWife · 22/01/2021 18:53

This may all sound small but it's constant. My partner gets left to relax and I am expected to serve food and drinks and even clean their house when it's not even my home. I let him off sometimes because he's often not around when this happens as I visit them while he is at work.

FFs why did he relax? Why didn't he stand up to them? Why didn't he take on the chores/help?

You have a DH?DP problem.

LolaSmiles · 22/01/2021 18:46

If you are both happy in your relationship and happy with a more equal balance of responsibility then he needs to stand up to his parents now and make it clear that they keep out.

If he won't do this then there are several concerns:

  1. He secretly agrees and is hoping you'll fall in line after marriage, especially if children are involved
  2. He is weak with his parents so they will always be overly involved in your relationship
3.. You can't rely on him to parent future children in a way you agree because either he supports the traditional set up, or he'll fall in line with his parents
  1. You could find yourself being lumbered with family responsibilities and old age care years down the line.