Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

'The year of Karen' - Guardian article

142 replies

ArabellaScott · 03/01/2021 13:33

More tedious pish on the 'Karen' phenomenon.

An article that directly equates women calling the police (however unjustifiably, all they did was call the police, hardly an illegal act) with a policeman murdering a man. Because of course the two are equivalent. In fact, I think the article's logic is that the woman who has called the police has actually directly caused the death of the man - it's almost as though the policeman disappears and is absolved, the blame shifted neatly from the (utterly fucking monstrous) actions of the policeman to the (perhaps racist, presumably highly-strung) actions of the woman. (Of course these were two completely unrelated incidents, but never miss a chance to use the correlation = causation fallacy when it helps your argument).

Quoting the last particularly nasty paras so you don't have to read the article:

'Complaints about Karen being sexist were noteworthy mostly for how neatly they re-enacted the Karen dynamic. Confronted with evidence of their own agency and complicity, some white women responded by reasserting their victimhood.

What I’ve found especially useful about Karen memes is the way they’ve given willing white women a tool with which to assess their own behavior and, if they want, improve it. My own mother, who is white, has on rare occasions demonstrated behavior that verged on the Karen-esque. This summer, for the first time, she acknowledged some of those Karen tendencies to me and stated her intention not to act like that any more – a conversation I’m not sure we would have had absent the meme.

Williams recalled similar conversations with white friends, and offered three simple rules to avoid being a Karen. One: recognize the privilege and history of being a white woman in this society. Two: avoid calling the police on people of color unless someone is in imminent danger of harm. And three: “Understand that it’s just not always about you, period. People are not out to get you for the most part, people are not trying to hurt you or harm your property or make you uncomfortable,” she said. “You’re not that special, Karen. You’re not that special.”

By people, presumably the writer means 'men', but it seems striking to me how men have been absolved of all responsibility here. The demon is clearly the writer's mother, and all women who dared to think they were 'special'.

This is pure, naked, misogyny. I would not want to be a woman or girl in the US at the moment.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 03/01/2021 17:21

Telling women what circumstances they can call the police under is a new, woman hating low.

This is true. I wonder if a newspaper article telling women

avoid calling the police

is actionable by IPCC? Are they captured, too?

OP posts:
MorrisZapp · 03/01/2021 17:17

The Guardian jumped the shark years ago. Telling women what circumstances they can call the police under is a new, woman hating low.

DaisiesandButtercups · 03/01/2021 17:11

Maybe socialism will work better now that we no longer have freedom of movement? I have been searching for anything at all positive or hopeful about Brexit, is this a potential silver lining? Like some say about Nordic countries can we now expect greater community cohesion and people will be happier to pay higher taxes for better state run public services?

Anyway back to the point, name calling is never a positive or constructive communication tactic.

Should we reclaim the name? As a preemptive strike we could wear t-shirts with Karen written across the front in big letters. Or even “Proud Karen”.

I really think that to use a given name as an insult is low and seriously lacking in the kindness and compassion which are paid lip service to by so many who resort to name calling for lack of anything more coherent to contribute.

RufustheSniggeringReindeer · 03/01/2021 17:08

@TheBuffster

Think I would throw a festive strop if the child that I grew and nurtured called me a Karen. Same as if they called me a bitch.
My children said ‘ok karen’ to me once

Once

carlaCox · 03/01/2021 17:05

This stuff is racist as well as sexist. Apparently it's only white women who have "agency" now? Tell that to my mother in law! Patronising, offensive rubbish.

SueDeNimm · 03/01/2021 17:03

@DandyMandy these days it's completely acceptable to save all of your hatred for white women post 40. The ageism I see all the time is astounding - on mumsnet and in real life. Some younger men can be respectful but some of that is because of their older woman fantasies. The women their age are openly disgusted by this. How can anyone want an old hag. Then there's men our own age. The media.

Ok if you're a mum doing mum things for people. Otherwise it's a bit like having leprosy 😁. Which of course has faded away!

It's weird too because I remember being in my 20s snd 30s very well and would actually have a lot in common with many of the people saying these things. Just as well there are still nice people like you around. They do exist it's just more acceptable to vent your (probably covid related) spleen onto 'safe' targets.

DandyMandy · 03/01/2021 16:52

What a joke. As a young woman in my 20s, I feel disgusted that older women (the people I have always looked up to and aspired to be like) are being treated this way. My generation and the generation after mine are doing so much irreversible damage and because most of them are sheep, I wouldn't be able to say all of this. What actually happened to "respect your elders"? Did that fade away too?

PotholeParadies · 03/01/2021 16:52

Karen is a word used to tell women to shut up, and pretend you're in the right.

Mostly white women, but make no mistake, the misogynistic men who use it will happily use it to silence any black woman who disagrees with them, too.

TheBuffster · 03/01/2021 16:50

Not the forum for this.
As I said before I am not going to derail the thread.
I just brought it up as relevant to the general publication output.

SueDeNimm · 03/01/2021 16:26

@TheBuffster the answer is that we have so many more people. Huge amounts of immigration plus were already crowded. When many of those people are paying minimal taxes but getting maximum benefits it's not going to end well. The world has changed and socialism doesn't work so well any more. People want their Amazon prime and ubers and cheap primark clothing and to have sky tv, a £1000 iPhone and a Michael kors handbag even if they earn minimum wage. 10 years ago those things didn't exist either.

IrmaFayLear · 03/01/2021 16:20

Luckily I’ve never had to call the police.

But if someone was breaking into my house you betcha I’d call. Are we supposed to scrutinise the burglar and decide whether we are more privileged than he is before picking up the phone? Confused

TheBuffster · 03/01/2021 16:11

Hello officer, my wife's been murdered
Officer: when did it happen
Oh about 3pm she noticed a man following her but didn't feel the need to run or call the police as she's not that special
Officer: phew, fair cop. For a moment there I thought we had a real murder there. It's just a Karen though so not a real murder.

UppityPuppity · 03/01/2021 16:00

One: recognize the privilege and history of being a white woman in this society.

Has she actually read any history? That’ll be a ‘no’.

Two: avoid calling the police on people of color unless someone is in imminent danger of harm.

I will NOT be giving that advice pile of shit to
my DDs. What so the police only arrive once the harm has happened? I have no idea about the individual case she is using to excuse police/male violence and blame women, but women are physically weaker and sadly women have a need and a right to be on guard - irrespective of who the man is - and should act accordingly.

SantasBritchesSpelleas · 03/01/2021 15:39

'Karen' just translates to: How dare women exist beyond an age where they are deemed fuckable?

Two: avoid calling the police on people of color unless someone is in imminent danger of harm

Oh, thank goodness The Guardian has put me right! I had no idea I shouldn't whip out my mobile to dial 999 whenever I see someone who isn't white.

TheBuffster · 03/01/2021 15:28

I'm comparing education in this country to education 10 years ago. Changes I have seen with my own eyes in my own field. Yes, of course we have publicly funded education, that doesn't mean it's not being underfunded.
I have worked in Malaysia teaching so do know something of these things. Just because there were children there not able to get an education period doesn't mean I accept steamrollering of education here.
Anyway, don't want to hijack the thread as that wasn't my intention. Just merely pointing out that the left is eating itself.

Chicchicchicchiclana · 03/01/2021 15:25

A quite surprising number of Mumsnetters are happy to use Karen as an insult. Very disconcerting.

RoyalCorgi · 03/01/2021 15:18

The only time the use of the word "Karen" raised a smile was when someone described Elon Musk as a "space Karen" on Twitter after he whinged about his coronavirus test results. (Story here: www.standard.co.uk/news/world/elon-musk-space-karen-coronavirus-b71634.html) I still don't approve of the term but it was funny in context.

ArabellaScott · 03/01/2021 15:15

Is the message that we can just never stand up for ourselves?

Yes, of course.

FestiveStrop, with respect, your teens are a very small sample size. I'm going by reports in newspapers, online, youtube videos, etc. I've only ever seen 'Karen' applied to women.

OP posts:
SueDeNimm · 03/01/2021 15:14

@TheBuffster I can imagine these are hard times for you at the moment thanks to covid. The conservatives most certainly do not 'hate' teachers or education though. But as a country we spend a lot of money on education and healthcare - more than most. FAR more than most.

Many teachers would love to go and work in places like India helping poor children. Except their economy is almost as big as ours (we have only just overtaken them) so a good look at the world shows very clearly that as a country politically and economically we are extremely left wing and generous. In fact the 'welfare for everyone' is undoing us on the world stage currently.

As another example New Zealand does not have free healthcare. Their education is poor. There are council houses but they are few and far between and NOT for life. Housing is expensive. As is everything else. Taxes are not low. Yet to the left wing it is utopia. With a great PM! But it's not a free lunch and few have more than the basics.

SueDeNimm · 03/01/2021 15:04

There is no invisible privilege for Karen aged women. It's the smug little shits in their 20s that have the privilege. We have all been there - having middle aged men fawn over us and listen with rapt attention to our drivel because they really really want to shag us.

Don't fucking tell me that women in their 30s and older juggling disrespectful children, bosses and husbands are privileged.

Having said that kicking those further down the chain isn't cool. Instead of allowing yourself to be walked all over and then taking it out on the weaker get strong. Get real power and tell those walking over you to fuck off.

I see it on here a lot. Women with appalling husbands getting arsey on threads. Get pissed off with your shitty husband instead. Don't decide you are going to be 'assertive' when you think it's ok and be a doormat the rest of the time.

Get a decent career and stop putting up with shit at home then maybe you won't want to be a Karen when you are out. Maybe you won't be stressed and sleep deprived if your lazy DH and DC help around the house and treat you with respect.

TheBuffster · 03/01/2021 14:59

As a woman in education everyone hates me, right or left.
Yes agree that right wing does not equate with evil, but people naturally fall on one side or another for a lot of things (I cannot forgive the conservatives for what they did to education.)
As naturally somewhat left I find my supposed allies are somewhat ghoulish, but many of my opinions clash with even well meaning people on the right.
I am politically homeless.
But now am complaining so probably will get accused of being a Karen soon.

TheMarzipanDildo · 03/01/2021 14:56

Not to be hyperbolic, but that article is a fucking disgrace.

FestiveStrop Maybe I've become used to it as a mother of teens?

I’m 21, so probably could be considered the same generation as your teens. Please do not let them dictate what you find or don’t find offensive. They are not the arbiters of wisdom (probably quite the opposite!)

My “friends” seem to use the term to refer to any middle aged woman on a game show with short hair and a thick accent. Hmm

SueDeNimm · 03/01/2021 14:53

Yeah but the guardian hate women who aren't a) poor or b) black. Unless they are doing a 'worthy' job like social worker or nurse. And they especially hate the 'middle classes'. Well the women anyway.

In fact I find that most left wing people (I'm on the middle left on some things more central right on others) hate anyone white with money (hence the raging antisemitism centred around wealthy Jewish people because all Jews are rich surely)?

In fact alongside the hatred of tories I'm finding that the 'kind' party and 'caring' people are neither. You never hear this kind of hatred from the right-ish (as in 99% of conservative voters as the UK right isn't exactly super right).

Intolerance does seem to be the preserve of the left currently, overseen by the good old guardian which is every bit as biased as the daily fail.

FestiveStrop · 03/01/2021 14:50

Sorry to disappoint but my DC have never called me bitch, Karen or anything similar.

We are close and talk about everything which is why I was drawn to this discussion.

I'll bow out now.

TheBuffster · 03/01/2021 14:48

But the fact that it's not Ken tells you what you need to know.