Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

India Willoughby on This Morning

44 replies

YippeeKayakOtherBuckets · 17/09/2020 10:50

Very carefully tiptoeing around the self ID issue. She’s very against it.

The tide is turning.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EveryPlanetHasAYorkshire · 18/09/2020 02:14

@MillyMollyFarmer

India only cares about India. The way they behaved on CBB pointing their finger at the women, many older women, yelling: ‘ I am a woman! Let that penetrate!’, as well as repeatedly massaging lotion into their breasts in front of the women makes me very sure that I do not want to share a changing room with them or listen to a single lie they say.
Penetrate is an interesting word choice.
ChattyLion · 18/09/2020 01:40

Brilliant post Michelle

BatShite · 17/09/2020 23:20

Oh, I quoted that post to ponder if JK might possibly send a letter about that tweet. Its total bullshit, and provable bullshit. I have never ever seen her say transwomen are dangerous, let alone saying it for a year!

BatShite · 17/09/2020 23:19

[quote ItsLateHumpty]But then IW also tweeted this in the same thread

Jaimelou starkey @ jaimelouise25. 2h
Replying to @ IndiaWilloughby
How daft is this ! I don’t agree with what she said but people should still be allowed freedom of speech to say how they feel

India Willoughby @ IndiaWilloughby
Of course 👍 I’m the same. She spent a year telling the world that trans women were dangerous, and then creates a character who uses women’s clothes to get close to a victim. Disingenuous to say it’s just another story. But it’s one book. Don’t read it if it stresses you out 🤷🏼‍♀️

twitter.com/jaimelouise25/status/1306578732833017858[/quote]
As I recall, India has always been very against self ID. India did go quiet at one stage about it after a particularly brutal mauling from TRAs, and I think she might have tweeted once or twice in a neutral type way about it while that was going on, but always been quite obviously against it. But..I would bet the huge majority of 'old school transsexuals' are against it and find it not just as barmy as we do, but also find it threatens their own priveleges. After all, there was no debate really besides a few quiet feminist circles, when it was about men who have fully transitioned, and many women were fine to be a bit uncomfortable to 'allow' those men to feel better about themselves. Hell, if it was all about me, I would be fine with those who had actually transitioned in (most) womens spaces. But its not, and I know some women are not ok with it, hence my line in the sand. And I think this is where a lot of women are. So 'old school transsexuals' were correct, the behaviour of transactivists has indeed threatened (and removed) their priveleges. The MRA type behaviour has helped a great many women find their voices, and listen to other womens stories. And come together as one really..

Datun · 17/09/2020 17:44

@SunsetBeetch

I'd like to see Rose of Dawn given more.of the spots on GMB that would normally go to India. I'm not just saying this because I agreed with her, but I think she did a muxh better job at getting pointd across, whilst being calm and measured.
She has a far better overview of all the issues. When India speaks, it's all about India and what they want, think, need. With appeals to the camera about how on Earth could they ever be expected to use facilities designed for their sex.

Rose of dawn takes a far more neutral approach to all of it.

However, it would be marvellous if more women were actually asked about what they think should happen to their own rights.

Wouldn't it be staggering on GMB to see the ratio of 4 to 1 in favour of women and not the other way round? It's extraordinarily sexist.

SerenityNowwwww · 17/09/2020 17:37

How old is India? Because we know that women of a certain age are... well pretty much ignored or ridiculed/attacked - either way, have little authority or power.

India is finding this out maybe?

ZuttZeVootEeeVro · 17/09/2020 17:36

Willoughby was very aggressive with women, knowing full well that cameras were recording Willoughby's every move.

I'm not confident that they'll be less aggressive in womens spaces when no cameras are present. All it may take is a woman or girl to say or do the wrong thing and Willoughby's temper may rear itself again.

If some women are happy to share with them, maybe they can campaign for shared space and leave other women and girls with the safe and with dignity of women only spaces.

ShagMeRiggins · 17/09/2020 17:33

Sorry, wrong thread.

ShagMeRiggins · 17/09/2020 17:32

This is it, according to one twitter thread. This is literally all that is said in the book.

India Willoughby on This Morning
SunsetBeetch · 17/09/2020 17:29

I'd like to see Rose of Dawn given more.of the spots on GMB that would normally go to India. I'm not just saying this because I agreed with her, but I think she did a muxh better job at getting pointd across, whilst being calm and measured.

SunsetBeetch · 17/09/2020 17:26

@MillyMollyFarmer

She spent a year telling the world that trans women were dangerous

Careful India, making up defamatory accusations like that is potentially a legal matter. She did no such thing, and you know it. Males are dangerous as a group, we know this.

Fuxking hell. She's done no such thing. Shock
Datun · 17/09/2020 17:06

In an interview, with Karen Ingala Smith (Counting Dead Women), about domestic violence perpetrated against women, in response India said it's the men they felt sorry for 'this particular year'.

Thinks women should shave their legs otherwise they're dirty. And has no understanding of why that's sexist. Called Jenni Murray something like a has-been dinosaur because Jenni disagreed.

Harangued Amanda on Big Brother, it was awful to watch.

And calls mumsnetters every name under the sun.

India Willoughby has zero affinity with women. None.

I don't think anyone doesn't totally understand why India thinks they are more deserving of women's spaces than other transwomen. The same way that Tara Hudson thinks it is they who are more deserving, due to how long they have been a transwoman. Or those who say they pass and think it is that which makes them deserving. Or Pip Bunce who thinks they are deserving three days a week, but not the other four days when they are dressed as a man.

Any number of male born individuals, deciding on the exact criteria which each one wants, in order to have women's spaces.

Nah.

MillyMollyFarmer · 17/09/2020 16:37

She spent a year telling the world that trans women were dangerous

Careful India, making up defamatory accusations like that is potentially a legal matter. She did no such thing, and you know it. Males are dangerous as a group, we know this.

ItsLateHumpty · 17/09/2020 16:21

But then IW also tweeted this in the same thread

Jaimelou starkey @ jaimelouise25. 2h
Replying to @ IndiaWilloughby
How daft is this ! I don’t agree with what she said but people should still be allowed freedom of speech to say how they feel

India Willoughby @ IndiaWilloughby
Of course 👍 I’m the same. She spent a year telling the world that trans women were dangerous, and then creates a character who uses women’s clothes to get close to a victim. Disingenuous to say it’s just another story. But it’s one book. Don’t read it if it stresses you out 🤷🏼‍♀️

twitter.com/jaimelouise25/status/1306578732833017858

SunsetBeetch · 17/09/2020 13:30

She's just posted this in response to Penis News:

"Oh f* off. Real trans people are incredibly tough. Survivors. Have to be. Don’t need protecting from a book shelf. #JKRowling"

twitter.com/IndiaWilloughby/status/1306570480686698497?s=20

India Willoughby on This Morning
ThinEndoftheWedge · 17/09/2020 12:54

I am a woman! Let that penetrate!

Wow - horrid.

I’ve never felt the need to state that. Ever. Now let me think why...

zanahoria · 17/09/2020 12:39

Watching IW on CBB was a real eye opener. She insisted loudly that she was a woman. Amanda Barrie even agreed with her but talked to her like she was placating an angry toddler. Yet even after agreeing with India, Amanda did not treat India in quite the same manner she treated the women in the house.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 17/09/2020 12:39

In all honesty, I really wouldn't object to a fully transitioned person using the loo of their choice, even though I know full well they aren't female. It must be awful to not he at ease in your own body.
But unfortunately exploitative males and thick as shit woke celebrities have ruined it for genuine trans people and women.
In the past we would have all politely pretended not to notice a tw using the loo and not felt threatened. Now we have to worry about whether that person is a predatory male masquerading as a tw.
I don't know why this is so hard for society as a whole to grasp.
I see the BMA have agreed to give away women's rights yesterday as well!

PopperUppleton · 17/09/2020 12:23

Gosh Michelle I love your writing.

It's the women being present in women's spaces thing isn't it? No validation in a third space. Once seen, never unseen - again.

Thanks to all in this board for the education, and I mean all. Having lurked for years it's clear just what women are up against, and even now it's repeated day after day after day.

Like the Carti person in the Times comments, wilful misunderstanding and ignoring all other points of view except their own.

No means no. No males means no males. I don't give a flying frig about how you feel about yourself or how much money you have spent on your presentation. Mine and my daughters' safety, dignity and privacy are simply too important to give away.

happydappy2 · 17/09/2020 12:11

I feel deep sympathy for any man who has undergone 'gender reassignment surgery' and incorrectly been told that they can now use womens sex segregated spaces. Whichever male Dr/psychiatrist/politician told them they could use womens spaces was giving away something that wasn't theirs to give.
I hope in the future better alternative treatment is available for people with gender dysphoria as the current system is not sustainable.

MillyMollyFarmer · 17/09/2020 12:04

India only cares about India. The way they behaved on CBB pointing their finger at the women, many older women, yelling: ‘ I am a woman! Let that penetrate!’, as well as repeatedly massaging lotion into their breasts in front of the women makes me very sure that I do not want to share a changing room with them or listen to a single lie they say.

MichelleofzeResistance · 17/09/2020 11:55

I don't necessarily agree with but do have sympathy with IW and with those who would term themselves as the 'old school transsexuals'. When it was simply a case of a very small number of the population who were for the most part gay males and had made a full physical transition, there were all the same issues for female people including major ethical ones, but the impact was small enough and quiet enough in approach to female people that they were for the most part able to have that use of female spaces. For a time it more or less worked if you didn't look too closely at the issues.

This ship has sailed due to the political lobby. IW like Debbie Hayton, would like access to women's spaces restricted only to males who have made enough of a transition - Willoughby has explained in interviews, Willoughby doesn't want to use mixed sex spaces or to share with those Willoughby themselves perceives as males. To them it is about protecting the full sense of transition and entry to women's spaces for themselves, so they can feel themselves as a woman amongst women. However from the female perspective, as the quiet bits got very loud indeed and it became obvious that the slightly opened door of any male permitted at all was going to be forced to its widest extent of all males wishing to feel themselves as a woman among women regardless of motive being admitted, with a side order of gleeful enjoyment in silencing, oppressing and excluding non compliant women, and a whole lot of 'there's no such thing as sex but a woman can have a penis' and how impossible it will be to have any boundaries at all.... it's shifted to the only possible line being no male people at all, ever, regardless of circumstance.

Third spaces are the only remaining solution. IW doesn't want third spaces, for the same reason that a self identified male with a beard who is gender fluid doesn't want third spaces: the presence of women in those spaces to be among them is essential for feeling validated. However the real need for safety, privacy, dignity, respect for chosen TW identity, has to be separated from any male person using female people, many of whom don't consent, because it validates them. Which means not equally respecting female people's safety, privacy, dignity and respect for their identity, plus excluding those females who can't do it from having any space at all, for the better happiness and sense of self of a male. That's the bit that is unacceptable.

Sadly, to IW and many others, that's the bit that is really painful.

ThousandsAreSailing · 17/09/2020 11:35

IW is no friend to women. Didn't you see IW screaming at women in the BB house?
IW has never agreed with self ID but that only some men, those with surgery I guess, are actually women
I would not feel that women's needs were being represented if IW took a woman's place on a board

Redshoeblueshoe · 17/09/2020 11:30

I only know IW from television, and the aggression shown when they were on BB is why they should not be in women's toilets.

picklemewalnuts · 17/09/2020 11:24

If I were in the ladies with IW, and were a stranger, I probably wouldn't feel worried. I'm assuming I know India's public persona in order to say that. If Our association were closer, I would be less comfortable as I have seen India's finger shaking and shouting at people who disagree.

Swipe left for the next trending thread