Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Academics frightened by stifling regime on campus

53 replies

BovaryX · 02/09/2020 09:06

There is an excellent article by John McWhorter about the threat to academic freedom on campus. He compares the humiliation ordeals suffered by dissenting academics as like struggle sessions from Maoist China. He also describes the quasi religious aspect of this political orthodoxy and makes the interesting point that some of its most fanatical adherents do not belong to the demographic group on whose behalf they are relentlessly offended.

To what extent would you worry about the following consequences?” To the hypothetical “My reputation would be tarnished,” 32.68 percent answered “very concerned” and 27.27 percent answered “extremely concerned.” To the hypothetical “My career would be hurt,” 24.75 percent answered “very concerned” and 28.68 percent answered “extremely concerned.” In other words, more than half the respondents consider expressing views beyond a certain consensus in an academic setting quite dangerous to their career trajectory. So no one should feign surprise or disbelief that academics write to me with great frequency to share their anxieties. In a three-week period early this summer, I counted some 150 of these messages. And what they reveal is a very rational culture of fear among those who dissent, even slightly, with the tenets of the woke left

OP posts:
BovaryX · 02/09/2020 09:24

queen

It's a very interesting piece and it highlights the similarities this political movement has with other grim historical totalitarian regimes. The religious intensity with which its adherents denounce the heretic also has historical resonance. 16th century resonance.

Overall I found it alarming how many of the letters sound as if they were written from Stalinist Russia or Maoist China. A history professor reports that at his school, the administration is seriously considering setting up an anonymous reporting system for students and professors to report “bias” that they have perceived. One professor committed the sin of “privileging the white male perspective” in giving a lecture on the philosophy of one of the Founding Fathers, even though Frederick Douglass sang that Founder’s praises. The administration tried to make him sit in a “listening circle,” in which his job was to stay silent while students explained how he had hurt them—in other words, a 21st-century-American version of a struggle session straight out of the Cultural Revolution

OP posts:
queenofknives · 02/09/2020 09:15

Thanks for sharing this. I really like John McWhorter in general and find he always has interesting things to say. There definitely is a climate of fear. I think what people often miss is how women academics have been struggling with this for years already, but it was seemingly confined to one issue. Now the same tactics and ideas are applied to every issue, the authoritarianism of the left is becoming impossible to ignore or dismiss.

Anyway, I'll look forward to reading this!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread