Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How to not alienate my 13yo?

30 replies

accessorizequeen · 30/08/2020 08:26

I talked last night with my 13yo DS about JKR and trans issues. It came up because my Dsis is anti-JKR and has previously called me transphobic for not wanting to be called Cis. My Dsis is very dear to me and incredibly supportive, so I’ve no desire to get into arguments with her. My DS assumed wrongly that I believed TWAW. Seemed very upset and horrified that I did not, although he agreed people couldn’t change sex. He said a Transwoman became a woman when they had transitioned and I was denying this. I didn’t manage to get the importance of language over to him. I did say that a huge proportion of TW never have surgery. He shut down on me and I sense that he is upset and shocked by my stance. He has said in the past he would like to be a girl, I’ve certainly wondered if he was trans at times, and he’s certainly a feminine boy. I do not wish him to feel that I’m not supportive of him, but I am at a loss how I should continue. I sent him the link to JKR’s post and said I hoped he might read it. Help!

OP posts:
BGirlBouillabaisse · 30/08/2020 08:47

It's tricky for ASD children to understand that you can have differences of opinion and still love and admire people. This is a really useful learning experience for your DS. It's clear he's trying to understand your point of view if he's researching JKR on Twitter.

Perhaps you could look at Twitter together. How do people present their arguments? Who is being calm and rational, and who is just lashing out? Whose point of view is he able to take on board more easily?

accessorizequeen · 30/08/2020 08:40

He’s just joined Twitter and was looking at the I stand with JKR hashtag. He mentioned it in front of my sister and I had to quickly shut things down. My Dsis will not debate or discuss, she just thinks I’m transphobic and wrong.

OP posts:
accessorizequeen · 30/08/2020 08:38

Yes, he has ASD. Very b/w thinking, more so than my two other boys who are also ASD. I did send the article link to him, and said I was open to discussion. Didn’t have an answer to the “once they’ve transitioned, they’re a woman” approach.

OP posts:
BGirlBouillabaisse · 30/08/2020 08:35

Ah sorry, I see that you linked to JKR. I think it's important to teach him to understand that taking a nuanced, well-informed position on something means understanding the debate from differing viewpoints (not that anyone on Twitter got the memo Grin).

BGirlBouillabaisse · 30/08/2020 08:33

Is your DS ASD? Gender dysphoria is common in ASD children due to sensory issues and black/white thinking.

I think it's important that he sees both sides of the debate. Has he read JKR's piece? Engage him about what specifically he disagrees with. Discuss the science. If he's bright, you could share some of the articles you read, and remind him that, in order to debate a topic, he needs to know it inside-out and from all sides.