Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Lets support a domestic abuser

30 replies

Gingerkittykat · 13/05/2020 16:36

After I read this sob story about the Reverend Paul Parks and how unfairly he had been treated being sacked as a vicar for domestic abuse I decided to do some digging.

I found the [[https://www.churchofengland.org/sites/default/files/2020-04/Parks%20-%20Tribunal%20Decision%20-%2010.01.20.pdf] tribunal decision here and it is clear he abused his wife for many years including calling her a fucking whore, controlling her movements, threatening her with a knife, driving towards a brick wall with her in an armlock in the passenger seat and managing to blame her for whatever has gone wrong and making out she is an abuser.

The Daily Mail are clearly sympathetic towards him, a poor veteran is now facing homelessness due to his PTSD after being failed by the church. His go fund me is trying to raise 90 000 to pay his legal fees and secure housing.

There is a lot of talk about his PTSD and the help he has had, I wonder what help his wife and children are getting for the trauma inflicted on them?

I am utterly shocked at this, painting him as a nice charitable guy who just lashed out a few times when he is actually a serial abuser.

In 2011, Lois was ill following the birth of her youngest child. The respondent refused to
allow her to leave her bed for a period of some hours. He threatened to kill her and called
her Jezabel. When he finally let her go, he blamed Lois for making him a monster.

Is an extract from the tribunal report.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hoodathunkit · 15/05/2020 16:57

I just found this very well made, nuanced exploration of issues relating to dissociation, dissociative disorder and the controversies surround these diagnoses.

The using his professional experiences and the literature the presenter does a great job of summarising the salient points and touches on issues of culpability for criminal acts (and avoidance of culpability via diagnoses of dissociative disorders) and of the situation that exists whereby many mental health professionals earn their living by promoting dissociative disorders and may find it difficult to admit they were wrong when their career is built on dissociative studies.

Very thoughtful and well researched, some of his other videos are interesting also

hoodathunkit · 15/05/2020 13:20

Obviously I am not saying that it is fine for a man to threaten to drive his wife into a wal, to call her "a fucking whore" or, as the vicar did, to threaten to gouge her eyes out

I just think that it is a mistake to compare a non-combatant's experience of PTSD with a former soldier's experience

There will be common themes to traumatic experiences but each person will have their own unique experience also

hoodathunkit · 15/05/2020 13:13

Having PTSD myself, and also knowing many other people who live with it means I know that threatening to drive your wife into a wall or calling her a fucking whore is not part of the disorder.

I know many people who have been traumatised including people who survived toxic / abusive childhoods, people who were gaslighted over years and people who were traumatised by war and by being trafficked.

People respond to trauma in different ways.

I think that there is a particular problem with former and current service men and women.

To be a soldier people are encouraged to be violent and to be prepared to kill people. Behaviour that would be considered to be murder in a non-conflict situation is encouraged. War is an atrocious thing.

When people serve in armed conflict they may kill people, they may be physically and / or emotionally scarred, they may see their friends killed or injured, they may be tortured or witness toruture.

They may befriend local people only to learn that the people they befriended were punished, tortured of killed for associating with them.

They may have survivor guilt, guilt because they took a decision that saved themselves but resulted in the deaths of others.

It is unsurpsising that former members of the armed forces are massively over represented in populations with drug and alcohol problems, mental health problems, relationship breakdowns and homeless including rough sleepers.

Personally I think that if we train people to be soldiers and to risk their lives serving their county we owe them a responsibility to provide them with proper metnal health services when they leave the forces.

I know of many, many cases where this has not happened.

I also think it is a mistake to compare different personal experiences if PTSD.

The experiences of former soldiers are likely to have different features to those of other traumatised people.

hoodathunkit · 15/05/2020 12:56

Also the term "dissociative fugue" is one on which the client loses their sense of personal identity and goes out and does things that they cannot remember - as the actions were undertaken by another part of themselves of which they are not conscious.

This is exactly what people with DID/MPD claim happens to them and it is frequently used as a way of avoiding responsibility for doing bad things, or not preventing bad things, in my expensive personal experience.

I have personal experience of something similar, as do many traumatised people. Something bad is happening that needs attention and yet one feels paralysed. There is awareness of something bad and yet is is so distressing that one compartmentalises it. This is not the same as dissociative fugue but has dissociative elements.

The various controversial organisations claiming to specialise in dissociative disorders continually create new categories of dissociative disorders and break the varying elements of the different disorders down and run expensive training courses about them. It is a gift that keeps on giving to the people running the training courses. Ker-ching ker-ching the money tap keeps on flowing

They may claim that a "dissociative fugue" is seperate to what happens to people with DID/MPD but the basic mechanics are identical.

A person does something, very often something bad, negligent or even criminal, and then claims to have absolutely no memory of the event.

They may embark on a quest, with the aid of their therapist, to "recover the memories".

In my experience they recover memories of incest of SRA that they claim removes or diminishes their repsonsibility for their bad actions or neglect. In fact they may even get competititve with those they have harmed, I have seen this. "You're angry at me for doing x horrific thing, but I was forced to sacrfice babies by a satanic sect so my trauma trumps yours". I have witnessed this insane crap with my own eyes.

In fact over the last few years the "brand" of DID/MPD has changed. Back in the videos of the 80s and 90s you will see extremely disturbed women crying, screaming and acting like traumatised young children.

Nowadays you will see many people claiming to have DID earning significant remuneration, obtaining gifts and receiving narcisistically gratifying social interaction from millions of people. The similarities between the videos of these influencers and the non-binary / trans young people influencers are obvious to anyone who is paying attention.

These latest manifestations of people with DID claim to have some memory of their "alters", so it may be that as the chamelion that is MPD/DID/complex trauma evolves over time, dissociative fugue can become categorised more clearly in such a way that lucrative training courses can be delivered to the benefit of all the quacks on the disociative disorder gravy train.

Having said that, I think it is highly likely that within these networks of quacks, charlatans and mountebanks, there exist many well meaning pracitioners who have simply fallen in with the cult like dynamics prevalent in these organisations and are genuinely trying to help people and are simply misguided.

Part of the problem is that dissociation is a real thing. The mind / body connection is a real and fascinating thing. Somatic disorders are real.

There is an urgent need for this important area of study to be liberated from the confines of the cultic milleu that currently controls it.

hoodathunkit · 15/05/2020 12:27

I have a diagnosis of CPTSD from an experienced NHS psychologist

me too

One a psychologist notorious for promoting SRA conspiracy theorists, who went to considerable measures to obscure her involvement and in fact denied it, while I was seeing them. The other a psychiatrist who I saw prior to me knowing about the ISSTD, the Clinic for Dissociative Studies, the Bowlby Centre et al.

I subsequently saw a psychologist who is also associated with the ISSTD and the Clinic for Dissociative Studies, although this was obscured from me prior to my session.

I know of her involvement only because, when I explained that I had been seen by a psychologist linked to the Clinic fof Dissociative Studies who had tried to get me to believe I had been abused by a satanic cult and repressed the memories, and also that I was concerned about the colleagues of Valerie Sinason, this particular psychologist got very angry, announcned that I was casting aspersions on her friends and colleagues and diagnosed me with delusional disorder.

Is the psychologist who diagnised you involved with any of the multitude of dubious organisations that are allied to the ISSTD?

I'm asking simply because you may not know. I didn't know when i was diagnosed. If it very common for clients / patients not to know in fact.

Gingerkittykat · 14/05/2020 22:24

Complex trauma has become one of the terms commonly used by controversial mental health professionals to refer to what they would previously have called MPD/DID.

I have a diagnosis of CPTSD from an experienced NHS psychologist, association is part of that but there are loads of different forms of dissociation which are not DID/MPD. What he was claiming was a dissociative fugue which doesn't mean someone has alters. Whether DID is a valid diagnosis is a completely different thread.

Having PTSD myself, and also knowing many other people who live with it means I know that threatening to drive your wife into a wall or calling her a fucking whore is not part of the disorder.

OP posts:
MitziK · 14/05/2020 11:06

Meh, the comments are moderated in advance. That'll be why all the comments are about the pawr ickle boy and how awful it is that the big, bad, bully Church isn't giving him another parish full of vulnerable women.

I wonder why he ended up divorced the first time around....?

PlanDeRaccordement · 14/05/2020 09:56

Sorry to read that you were mistreated and abused hood. Hope you are in a better and free place now.

I don’t know anything about the other cases, but I did read the all the published court documents, police reports and Browns own testimony before deciding to support the petition for her release.

hoodathunkit · 14/05/2020 09:56

Actually, there may be some cases where someone under 18 should receive a life sentence

I remember reading recently about a kid who had a very long history of sadistic, voilent sex assaults against other children.

Sometimes some extremely disturbed and dangerous people may simply be too dangerous to be at liberty.

In general though I think that minors (under 18) deserve a second chance, but it does depend on the crime/s

hoodathunkit · 14/05/2020 09:53

Thanks for your post PlanDeRaccordement

As someone who was tortured by a pimp I took an interest in this case, for obvious reasons, but while I read a lot about it I cannot claim to be an expert in it.

Your post makes a lot of sense and, when i have a moment i will take a more thorough look at the evidence.

She received a life sentence for his murder. Which I dont agree with. Not because it wasn’t murder, it most definitely was by her testimony and the forensic analysis done. But because I don’t think anyone under age 18 should be given a life sentence.

I think we can agree on this bit at least and thanks again for your post

PlanDeRaccordement · 14/05/2020 09:43

Actually, Brown killed the man at his flat, not her flat. Which is how she was able to rob the flat and steal his truck after killing him in cold blood. In her testimony, she stated she told him she was 18yrs old when he asked and he believed her.

She received a life sentence for his murder. Which I dont agree with. Not because it wasn’t murder, it most definitely was by her testimony and the forensic analysis done. But because I don’t think anyone under age 18 should be given a life sentence. The Governor also did not fully pardon her, but gave her clemency so her sentence was commuted down from life to time served. Which I agree was the right thing to do.

I just did not like the PP who twisted the facts of the case into a self defence killing of a pimp who had tortured her for years. That is a complete fabrication.

hoodathunkit · 14/05/2020 09:36

Many of the facts in the Brown case are disputed

What is not disputed is that she was selling sex at 16 years old and that she shot the man who went back to her flat in the back of the head at a time when she was being exploited by a violent pimp who went by the name of "Kut Throat" or Kut to his friends

Trafficked women often perceive their pimps as boyfriends, at least in the early days of the "relationship".

Pimps also routinely use coercive control, brainwashing, sleep deprivation and drugs to control their victims.

A former prosecuter in the case campaigned for her release.

She didn't escape jail, she served 15 years in jail. Her crime was very serious, however you look at it.

However she served 15 years for a crime she committed when she was a drug addled, trafficked 16 year old.

She was a model prisoner and studied hard in jail. Do you think that 15 years was not enough?

heavy.com/news/2019/08/cyntoia-brown-pimp-garion-mcglothen/

PlanDeRaccordement · 14/05/2020 09:14

Cyntoia Brown did not kill her pimp. She was a 16yr old living with her gangster boyfriend. They were both involved in armed robberies. She solicited a man for sex in a car park. The man picked her up, bought her dinner, did NOT have sex with her, fell asleep. She then took her own gun out of her handbag, shot him in the head, robbed him and then stole his pickup truck. This is all confirmed by forensics.

Beerincomechampagnetastes · 14/05/2020 09:13

I can’t talk about kk anymore or I’ll gouge my own eyes out.
Your thread is very interesting op - it’s not my intent to derail it...Brew

hoodathunkit · 14/05/2020 09:06

Of course- if you choose too. Many people do good work..... the vicar has done good work also? Still wouldn’t overlook his shit and the damage he’s caused and use him as an example.

Of course we shouldn't overlook bad things people do.

As far as I'm aware Kim Kardashian does not have a history of long term coercive control, and of repeated violent acts including threatening to gouge someone's eyes out, unlike the vicar.

I am completely uninterested in celebrity culture, "shapewear" or KUWTK.

I mentioned Kim Kardashian precisely because she appears to be yet another vacuous celebrity who relies on her good looks, someone who feminists might be disapproving of, and yet there is clearly more to her than meets the eye.

She has done a lot for Alexis Martin and Cyntoia Brown and whatever else I might think about her I salute her for her work against the US prison industrial system. She is also training to be a lawyer and giving a lot of her money to support people who have either been imprisoned unjustly or who deserve a second chance.

The evolution from apparently vacuous celebrity to responsible, thoughtful, mother who is learning to be a lawyer and putting her considerable wealth and social influence to the support of the most disadvantaged people in society should be applauded surely?

Beerincomechampagnetastes · 14/05/2020 08:49

* Do you think that Kim Kardashian's work in this respect should not be mentioned here? *
Of course- if you choose too. Many people do good work..... the vicar has done good work also? Still wouldn’t overlook his shit and the damage he’s caused and use him as an example.

VerityB1 · 14/05/2020 08:48

Have any of us here contacted the Daily Wail?

TheProdigalKittensReturn · 14/05/2020 08:43

The Church of England appear to have handled it very well. The report is clear and fair. It acknowledges the PTSD but also considers things like his failure to seek help when he knew he was a risk to his wife and his coercive behaviour over the duration of the relationship and outside of his ‘dissociative’ episodes.

That's reassuring, shame the media have defaulted to the usual "abusive men are the real victims and they always deserve another chance" angle.

hoodathunkit · 14/05/2020 08:38

Christ, I really don’t know what to say to that. KK lauded on the feminist board ffs. Yep..when she’s not slapping her sister around she’s stellar hmm

She really has done excellent work getting Cyntoia Brown and others released from jail.

I mentioned this because I think that if someone does great work it should be recognised regardless of their sex, their celebrity status or lack thereof or any other issue that I may disagree with about them.

Do you think that Kim Kardashian's work in this respect should not be mentioned here? Is she a woman whose name should never be mentioned here other than to criticise her?

It feels like we are back in the good woman / bad woman split again. Is there room for a nuanced perspective in your type of feminism or do only certain women achieve the dizzy heights of your approval?

SuperFurryDoggy · 14/05/2020 08:34

The Church of England appear to have handled it very well. The report is clear and fair. It acknowledges the PTSD but also considers things like his failure to seek help when he knew he was a risk to his wife and his coercive behaviour over the duration of the relationship and outside of his ‘dissociative’ episodes.

This CofE comment from the news article jumped out at me:

“Following his arrival, Rev Parks quickly fell out with his parishioners who say they found him overbearing and controlling”

hoodathunkit · 14/05/2020 08:32

thanks OneEpisode :)

I took the trouble to check out the psychiatrist involved

A very interesting man very involved with a number of mental health organisations specialising in "complex trauma", an interesting diagnosis applied to people who have endured multiple or ongoing traumatising events.

Complex trauma has become one of the terms commonly used by controversial mental health professionals to refer to what they would previously have called MPD/DID.

It is a fascinating area to research

Beerincomechampagnetastes · 14/05/2020 08:05

Kim Kardashian has been doing sterling work on prison reform and on highlighting the kind of cases you refer to.

Christ, I really don’t know what to say to that. KK lauded on the feminist board ffs. Yep..when she’s not slapping her sister around she’s stellar Hmm

Beerincomechampagnetastes · 14/05/2020 08:03

Comment on the daily mail are supportive of the vicar.

^Actually, people like him make for excellent pastors, suggesting that he overcomes a few issues. Everyone has something, and especially him, who has experience. She's not a lame duck either.^

Actually people like him make excellent pastors Yes, it’s always positive to have an abuser in a position of authority.

A few issues No big deal really.
she’s not a lame duck either Six of one and half a dozen of the other really.

Beerincomechampagnetastes · 14/05/2020 07:54

So really what’s happening here is that this woman and er children are just unfortunate collateral damage? The real issue and the focus right at the centre is the man and how he’s been let down and what we can do for him?

He is an abusive bastard and shame on anyone who donates.

hoodathunkit · 14/05/2020 07:45

Self-defense? Extenuating circumstances? Nope. (Among feminists, yes, but regular media, no.)

It's not just feminists

Kim Kardashian has been doing sterling work on prison reform and on highlighting the kind of cases you refer to. I'm no fan of celebrity culture and I've only ever glimped KUWTK when training at the gym. Got to give credit where credit is due though.

Sometimes the cavalry comes to the rescue from an unexpected place - has been my frequent experience in life