Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans Widows' Escape Committee 4 - A New Hope

962 replies

TinselAngel · 03/05/2020 12:23

Who would have thought we'd make it to thread 4?

Let's have some mutual pats on the back for the amazing support women on these threads have given to other trans widows, and the accidental consciousness raising that has come about as a result of this community.

This is a support area for women who are, or have been, in unhappy relationships with male partners who are transitioning, or exploring their "gender identity"

If you are in that position-

  1. You are not alone
  2. It is not a situation that you should be expected to tolerate, let alone celebrate.
  3. There is always a way out, if you want it. The thread is called Escape Committee for that reason

Remember: women talking to each other is a powerful weapon!

We now have a website which has been very well recived, and if any women who have contributed to these threads would like to write their story for inclusion on the website that would be wonderful.

Do post to get the new thread going. Links to the website and previous threads will follow.

As ever our thoughts are with the women still stuck in these relationships- check in, we do worry about you.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
EastCoastTranswidow · 15/08/2020 18:19

@socialworker222

Congratulations East coast. So glad to hear you've felt that relief. Getting the practical/legal/financial stuff sorted can really feel like progress and movement. Hope you can keep the momentum going and eventually be secure and independent. It's interesting you look back at the 'he' ex as fake. For me the made-up person isn't the man I married and divorced, but the strange fake woman he now pretends to be. I've never believed that was his true, authentic identity, just him trying to act as someone new because of his issues (and yes, I think it can fall into mental illness/personality disorder). Your amicable and tolerant arrangement is clearly manageable for you. Good luck and be proud of yourself for being proactive and decisive.
Social from my perspective, the male side was fake in that he was never satisfied with his life, underemployed, depressed, took on various personas of masculine males (wearing work boots, growing a beard, being "tough") and these never lasted long. He would flit from being poncy like Oscar Wilde to being a skinhead type (minus the racist stuff). It was all an act, and it never satisfied him for long. The female persona is another side of the same coin - he thinks that now this is his real self and will make his life happy. This "woman" is doing the same things the man did - impulsive shopping (but this time for lingerie), going online looking for validation ( from men now) , and acting like Greta Garbo in drag. Its just another persona, gleaned from films and books. I certainly hope this is her real persona, because there is no going back from bottom surgery!

I have come to the conclusion he is a very troubled person, with deep mental illness. Almost like people with multiple personalities. And of course, when I say this to anyone (which I rarely do), I am told that being transgender is as valid as being gay. I just shake my head and move on. They never had to live with these people and see this destructive behavior in person.

socialworker222 · 15/08/2020 16:45

The conundrum is a bewildering question that I realize I will probably never know or believe any answer to. Partners certainly don't have to believe what they are told. I was with my ex for many years and was able to link the transition to all his previous restlessness, dissatisfaction, introspection and narcissism. So it was just the next version of this rather empty person. We know these men well and may conclude our own narrative that makes sense. You rightly identify the sway Seaside between picking over what happened and feeling the full loss (waves of grief is spot on) and practising detachment. That part is vital for relief, space to think, and refocussing on you, what you want, and what you need to do. Self-care is an absolute priority (I say that with hindsight, having somewhat overused booze to get through Grin). You're making progress. What impressive women populate these pages Flowers

TinselAngel · 15/08/2020 11:31

Great news East and gives hope to people like Maureen who are still in the trenches.

The conundrum of which persona was real and which was fake can drive you insane and it's one I've given a lot of thought to.

Whilst you're with them, certainly in my case, the decision to transition appears to be something they struggle with due to the gravity of it, but then after the event they seem to lose all that.

I think this is largely down to queer theory/ the piggy backing on gay rights in that they have to say that they were "born this way", that they didn't have a choice, that it was transition or die.

What should we believe, the evidence in front of our own eyes at the time, or the rationalisation they tell the world afterwards? I've decided to believe that people change, and then they rewrite the past to justify and excuse that change.

I don't have terrible judgement and it wasn't all lies. He changed and I wasn't prepared to change with him.

OP posts:
socialworker222 · 14/08/2020 22:14

Congratulations East coast. So glad to hear you've felt that relief. Getting the practical/legal/financial stuff sorted can really feel like progress and movement. Hope you can keep the momentum going and eventually be secure and independent. It's interesting you look back at the 'he' ex as fake. For me the made-up person isn't the man I married and divorced, but the strange fake woman he now pretends to be. I've never believed that was his true, authentic identity, just him trying to act as someone new because of his issues (and yes, I think it can fall into mental illness/personality disorder). Your amicable and tolerant arrangement is clearly manageable for you. Good luck and be proud of yourself for being proactive and decisive.

EastCoastTranswidow · 11/08/2020 15:05

MonkeyBusiness Lads I am waiting to finish the mortgage refinancing to give her some cash to leave and then she will move out. Its ok, we still get along and don't argue so its not a volatile situation.

MonkeyBusinessLads · 11/08/2020 10:29

EastCoast can you not get him out? Why after a divorce is he allowed to live with you?

EastCoastTranswidow · 10/08/2020 20:07

Thank you Seaside The memories of the person who was apparently a facade are some of the most difficult ones to process. Its sounds insane right? It took me a good year to accept it, and I still cant believe my lovely husband was a fake, an actor, and a made up persona. It really makes me question my own ability to read people and attract this sort of crazy. I think its a mental illness, but of course that viewpoint is not allowed in this day and age. Its not something that should be normalized, and no amount of trans rights discussion will ever make me think otherwise. The prevalence of all these gender options has made men think they can do whatever they like. Maybe in the future they will do that, and not marry women in the first place, and waste years of our lives.

SeasideM · 10/08/2020 19:30

EastCoast so glad to hear the paperwork is final. Sounds like a lot of stress that they are still there at the house. Hope there are plans for that to change in the future. Cheers to no more drama! You are correct that you did what you could.

Thank you InvisibleDragon for the show of support. Sorry to hear you have dealt with abuse as well.

No new updates here. Upshot is at roommate status. Down shot (is that a phrase?) is still not an equitable arrangement but working on it. Doing loads of detachment work to not be brought down by all of their drama. Most days doing ok and still waves of grief for the memories of a person that was apparently pretend.

Kettlingur · 10/08/2020 16:44

Congratulations EastCoast. Here's to a new, FREE life! Wine

EastCoastTranswidow · 10/08/2020 14:15

Well, I wanted to give an update. My divorce was finalized 2 weeks ago. On the day of the hearing, I was a mess and my emotions were all over the place. Kept thinking about my wedding day, and how happy we were.

Now 2 weeks on, I feel relieved. Like a weight has been lifted. No more drama, no more worries about my husbands emotions and the "journey" and its just not my problem anymore. He still lives here in guest room, and I am working on refinancing to get his name off of the mortgage. Of course, the ex has been chatting to men for months and is planning to go out of state in a few weeks to meet a guy she fancies, has been buying all sorts of lingerie in preparation. I am just so done with it all.

Overall, I feel good. Not great, but good this whole insanity is over and I did what I could.

InvisibleDragon · 10/08/2020 11:49

Hello,

I found these threads a couple of days ago. I'm not a trans widow but I wanted to offer my support to all of you going through this. Flowers

I spent too many years in an emotionally and sexually abusive relationship and a lot of the behaviours I see described here about constant boundary pushing - especially around sex - are things that I really recognise from that relationship.

My ex really got off on the power trip of getting me to participate in sex that I didn't like. He also had a knack for making huge logical leaps and jumping between different topics, making it really difficult to pin down what we were talking about -- other than that I was wrong or offensive in some way.

A lot of this sounds similar to things I'm reading here about partners continually pushing for more and more fetishised sex; and logicking you into feeling unreasonable or bigoted for objecting.

So I just wanted to say that I'm sorry to hear about what you are going through. These behaviours are straight up manipulative and cruel. You shouldn't have to deal with such unkindness and I'm sorry that you do.

Solidarity xx

MonkeyBusinessLads · 04/08/2020 11:27

Message me if you want the details

SeasideM · 03/08/2020 23:13

@socialworker222 “ about betrayal, your sense of self and your life narrative, and what you want in your future” —very much this!

illaria · 31/07/2020 13:26

@MonkeyBusinessLads I think that would be helpful, thank you.
@socialworker222 it's very difficult to navigate, emotionally. As it's the weekend approaching, I'm now back to worrying about him as I know he is likely to indulge and the fear of something dreadful happening (due to the desire for risky behaviour) now he no longer has a minder of sorts, has returned....

socialworker222 · 31/07/2020 12:42

it was me who was truly the other woman
Well-written Ilaria. I think it's completely normal to ruminate on what happened, what it meant, was was true/false, who they were/weren't, what lies were told and was what sincere... eventually I got to the point of realizing I would probably never 'know' for sure the answers to those questions, and even if given them by him (in some future scenario where we could have a full and frank discussion), I probably wouldn't believe him or find peace. The answer for me didn't end up with him, but with me letting go of needing to know, accepting I never would, and trying to leave it be. Took me several years mind you.
And re. therapy, I hope you find someone good as I did; this isn't centrally about the 'trans' thing, but about betrayal, your sense of self and your life narrative, and what you want in your future. Agree that unfortunately counselling isn't always neutral or helpful as soon as rainbow issues arise.... good luck.

MonkeyBusinessLads · 31/07/2020 10:22

Ilaria if you would like a recommendation of a private psychotherapist I saw via Skype who specialises in narcissistic abuse and has increasing experience in helping trans widows private message me. I had around 8 sessions in all and it changed everything for me. She gave me lots of resources and homework to do so it was very directed and targeted rather than someone just listening and nodding.

TinselAngel · 30/07/2020 16:43

Envy(not envy)

OP posts:
illaria · 29/07/2020 23:58

*her - apols for typos

illaria · 29/07/2020 23:53

@TinselAngel re Norman Bates - I recall a time we took his (dreadful) mother away and she was talking about how she'd make her boys brush her hair for hair *ugh

illaria · 29/07/2020 23:43

I can be going about my business, happily enough and then it hits me like a sledgehammer - how the hell have I become the villain in this narrative? How am I the prude, the unreasonable partner, the one who doesn't measure up?

It's bloody mind blowing!

I've realised today he has blocked me on WhatsApp - why? What an absolute weapon! I had no intention of messaging him anyway but it's a reminder of the gatekeeping, the arbitration which was so prevalent

illaria · 29/07/2020 23:37

@WalkedAway @SeasideM I used to be very confident would my looks and my sexuality. He has made me feel as though I'm a prude. He would counter by saying "but darling, you are sexy blah blah.." but he knew the seed had been planted. The more he said it, the more reassure I felt because I knew he didn't mean it. He used to say, whilst utterly inebriated that he wanted to be stroked and made to feel sexy in his crap tights and nylon nighties. In one frank conversation, post one of his binges, I tried to make a comparison. Imagine if I liked dressing in Y fronts and wearing riggers boots, whilst staggering around watching porn, would he stroke me? He said "yes" (he wouldn't have) I countered that that would be generous but I couldn't force you to be aroused by it if of you engaged.
It seems that was what he just couldn't get. I was okay with him turning him self one (albeit a sad, solitary exercise) but he required me to be aroused too. He'd talk of past partners and how they'd engaged.
Now, tell me if I'm wrong but if they really were on board, aroused, why are they exes?!?
The cognitive dissonance is astounding not to mention the sheer lack of self awareness and narcissism

SeasideM · 29/07/2020 23:13

@WalkedAway you summed up this feeling so perfectly. “ The way this experience affects your sense of your own sexuality and femininity, your own identity as a woman, the way their dual focus on themselves as women and on you, the airless isolation of their closet--these are particular poisons with an afterlife in your psyche. ”

SeasideM · 29/07/2020 23:11

@TinselAngel I’m right there with you at cynical Gin clink. Still in the middle of it but the last narc rage a few weeks back and the outrageous things said to me stamped out any last feeling I had. The person I initially met was never real.

@illaria the journaling you are doing and adding in things you’d like to have said seems like a great idea. The AGP in my home also started with just dressing and I had no clue how it would escalate.

WalkedAway · 29/07/2020 22:54

Illaria,

I'm late to your posts, but what you say about your ex is so familiar to me: a choice of dress that seems to echo his mother's era and the time he would have become eroticised; the fixation on tights.

My ex favored 1960s era white cotton slips, and told me directly that his mother caught him in one of hers, and that's the reason he wanted one.  He also wanted me to shave his legs and then to put tights on him, and would send me selfies of his legs in various pairs of them.  I thought this fixation was due to the fact that his legs were the one part of his body that bore a closer resemblance to a woman's body (although he certainly liked bras, too, and photographing himself in them).  

But the other thing I wanted to address is his continuing hold over your thoughts, which I suspect is due to the trauma you experienced. The way this experience affects your sense of your own sexuality and femininity, your own identity as a woman, the way their dual focus on themselves as women and on you, the airless isolation of their closet--these are particular poisons with an afterlife in your psyche.

I'm more than two years on from moving out, and just under two years post-divorce, and I still can't even think of my ex without a shadow of that madness stealing over me, and if I happen to cross paths with himever seeing his carthat feeling is even more pronounced.

Talking back to him as you are doing in your journal is one good antidote.

TinselAngel · 28/07/2020 23:11

I think that is probably a pretty accurate assessment with regards to him, (dressing as his Mum is a bit Norman Bates though 😱), the only thing I'd disagree with is that you'll always love him.

Some time and perspective will help with that, but also they usually start behaving so appallingly post break up that the love gets killed.

God, I'm a cynical old witch these days. Gin

OP posts: