Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Just a rant, I am at work and need to vent.

92 replies

Sarcelle · 04/02/2020 09:27

Just been issued with laptops at work which means carrying back and forth. About 5 years ago we had to do this, but they withdrew them after a few years when they put permanent devices on hotdesks with meant you could leave your laptop at home. So now we are back to schlepping back and forth with heavy laptops, albeit they are lighter than the ones used before. The old ones we had at home had to be returned so if you are in the office you need to bring your laptop.

I and most colleagues commute and of course it is cumbersome and you have to keep your eye on it.

One of my male colleagues, a caring sharing one, said how you getting on with your new laptop. I said the laptop was fine but a pain to carry back and forth. He said, its not too bad. I said it is if you are a smaller person, which I am. He said come off it, you are not much smaller than me. He is about a foot taller, a couple of stones heavier and his arm/reach is longer. Talk about seeing things from your own perspective, the minimising twat.

I had to leave my desk and type this out. Otherwise I am ready to tell somebody/anybody to fuck off.

And breathe.

OP posts:
deydododatdodontdeydo · 04/02/2020 16:41

Laptops and their carriers have, like the rest of the world, been designed to suit a 70kg 5' 8" male frame.

Laptops haven't been designed for men - they have been reducing in size and weight since they were first invented. If they were designed for men they would have stopped the miniaturisation process as soon as they were acceptable for men.
However, OPs company could be guilty of not taking women into account when purchasing - smaller, lighter laptops tend to be more expensive, and if they bought heavier laptops for cost reasons, that would be a feminist issue.

Butterymuffin · 04/02/2020 16:34

They've been going that way for years, and it's hardly your employers fault.

It is her employer's fault that they didn't buy lighter laptops though and that they insist on staff carrying them around.

OP, are you expected to work at home on the laptop too? I would leave it at work if not, and if you are, I would say you'll work on your home machine and transfer files on a suitable password protected device.

AudacityOfHope · 04/02/2020 16:25

I bought new scales today (because I am a super cool person) so I just weighed my laptop out of curiosity piqued by this thread.

It weighs 1770g. I've no idea if that's relatively light or not compared to other laptops. But I know it's not as heavy as the bag I take to work every today that contains my make up, notebook, and lunch.

ahagwearsapointybonnet · 04/02/2020 16:16

Well at least you know what to get him if you have an office Secret Santa (a copy of Invisible Women, of course!).

Sarcelle · 04/02/2020 16:15

Sigh. Not about my challenges it is about assuming the world is the same for everybody as it is for him. Carrying a laptop is not a feminist issue. But minimising a woman's opinion is.

Bowing out of this thread.

Thanks for some of the suggestions about lap top bags etc. Thanks also to the majority who get it.

OP posts:
thehorseandhisboy · 04/02/2020 16:15

Carrying laptops is a feminist issue. Laptops and their carriers have, like the rest of the world, been designed to suit a 70kg 5' 8" male frame.

Women do not have a male frame yet are expected to use equipment designed for some with that frame who has 40% more or thereabouts more upper body strength to them.

This causes women problems which, as OP describes, are completely dismissed or minimised if women try to raise them.

OP, the suggestion about requesting a charging cable to keep at home is a good one. They do add extra weight. Also about requesting an OH assessment - if carrying a laptop is aggravating your existing injuries or illnesses there should be provision for you to leave it at work, or a lighter model provided if you have to take it home, or another device for you to use at home.

It's bloody annoying that women have to ask for their needs to be taken into account at every turn though.

Veterinari · 04/02/2020 15:51

I'm not sure that posters are being rude - you have posted this in feminism and whilst it is recognised that many things in the world are designed for men, I'm not sure that carrying a laptop is a feminist issue and it's a bit of a stretch to try and make it into one!

It seems you have some challenges with various injuries/ health problems which makes this particularly challenging for you, but that doesn't make laptop-carrying a general feminist issue and it's a bit weird to try and make it one. Perhaps speak to occupational health if you think it's a particular problem for you?

Sarcelle · 04/02/2020 15:06

He is actually a nice guy. Not arrogant but just patronising a bit sometimes. And on this occasion, patronising quite a bit! Practically patted me on the head!

OP posts:
NYnachos · 04/02/2020 13:22

OP - your colleague is an arse. I'd have had to tell him that life isn't all about him, people are different. He sounds a joy to work with.

FWIW - I had a trolley case once. I damaged my back severely when lifting into the car. Again some people scoff at that & think I'm making it up.

In your shoes I'd be tempted to contact your boss/HR & tell them you need either more than 1 laptop or an occupational health assessment.

Dyrne · 04/02/2020 13:15

I completely get it, OP. It’s not the laptop, it’s the complete blindness of your colleague to an experience even slightly different to him. DP sometimes does the same; and he doesn’t even realise it. It’s just that as a white, straight, mid-30s, tall slim man, the world around us has basically been created with exactly him in mind and so he rarely comes across these barriers. To his credit, he realises this most of the time and can empathise with others’ experiences,”.

You weren’t expecting your colleague to fix your problem, you weren’t even wanting to kick off massively; you just wanted him to not completely dismiss your experiences, and then when he did, you wanted to come on here to have a little moan to like minded feminists. I don’t know why some posters are being so hostile to you.

deydododatdodontdeydo · 04/02/2020 12:59

OK he wasn't exactly brimming with empathy, but I don't think the rage and need to tell someone to fuck off is an appropriate response to:

"come off it, you are not much smaller than me."

OhHolyJesus · 04/02/2020 12:50

Another derailing scenario. A female colleague of mine climbs with another colleague who is male. She says she just can't reach the next hand hold thing (technical term), he asks how come/why not? Because it's too damn far away for her arm. "I just don't understand how you can't reach it", because he can reach it.

I'm not deaf but I can empathise that certain situations make life difficult for a deaf person, sake for blind, dyslexic, wheelchair-bound people.

No I'm not comparing women to disabled people or that women are weak, nor am I suggesting that men cannot empathise, what I am saying is that the OP has expressly reiterated that the rant was about minimising her experience of something that bothers her a bit. It's not life altering to have to carry a heavy laptop around (but it could be). Sometime we just want to answer and not have to explain further or defend a response.

A boss one confided to my about his problems at home, in my work frame of mind as his assistant I set about finding a solution, he told me all he wanted to do was have someone listen for a moment, he was going through a tough time (and yes I suggested professional help as I'm not a therapist and it was not my job to be his therapist but I was his friend), maybe the OP's colleague could have just thought about it for a moment and gone "that's rough, I had no idea that the weight of a laptop could be such a daily pain in the shoulder/back".

As PPs say I hope you can escalate and get a risk assessment and/or a lighter laptop OP. Maybe this encounter and this thread will mean you won't suffer and have it result in any back issues.

Plexie · 04/02/2020 12:49

Sorry, what's your solution?
To make laptops smaller / lighter? They've been going that way for years, and it's hardly your employers fault.

Well perhaps employers shouldn't introduce working conditions that compel their staff to carry an extra 2kg of weight to and from work? Like in the old days when they had desktop PCs and staff weren't expected to take their work equipment home overnight.

picklesdragonisawelshdragon · 04/02/2020 12:41

Deydo, I think her solution to her colleague being unsympathetic would be, I dunno, her colleague saying 'Oh dear, I didn't even think what it's like for smaller people' instead of 'come off it, it's not that bad'.

Plexie · 04/02/2020 12:38

Your employer should be providing DSE (display screen equipment) assessments which include the use of laptops (both in an office environment and at home) and carrying them around. If problems are identified they need to address them and provide adjustments (eg suitable backpack, extra power cable to leave at home). If you can't resolve it with that and suffer physical symptoms, ask for a Occ Health referral.

It's no different to providing special mice to people with wrist problems, or adjustable chairs for people with back issues.

deydododatdodontdeydo · 04/02/2020 12:36

Sorry, what's your solution?
To make laptops smaller / lighter? They've been going that way for years, and it's hardly your employers fault.
To not give laptops to women / small women? Imagine the uproar!
Really think you're harsh and unreasonable calling your colleague a twat.

Biancadelrioisback · 04/02/2020 12:32

I refused to carry mine around as it was too heavy for me. None of my (male) colleagues had ever come across this issue before and were quite shocked that I found it too heavy. They sort of ignored the problem for a few weeks but when they realised I was deadly serious, I was bought a SurfacePro which I happily carry around in my handbag. I keep a charger at home and one at work plus have my old laptop on my desk just incase I forget my surface.

It's amazing how people just don't realise that we are all different

AudacityOfHope · 04/02/2020 12:20

True. It's cost me a fortune getting my trousers shortened, I can tel you.

Sarcelle · 04/02/2020 12:18

Audacity, now 5ft 2 but not at all silly) used to be 6 inches taller. But that decade carrying a laptop has reduced her to a mere 5 ft 2.

OP posts:
Sarcelle · 04/02/2020 12:15

OP forgot to mention I had scoliosis too! Silly me. Just as well, some posters might also add that to my attention seeking crimes. People really are shitty to each others these days, aren't they. You see threads about it and think it is an exaggeration but from some of the comments on here you would think I was stomping around crying about a laptop. It was about a man minimising my experience of lugging a laptop around.

My original conversation with colleague wasn't a rant. He asked me how my new lap top was, I said fine etc apart from carrying around. He minimised my experience and that was why I ranted in here. Perhaps the posters in here who also show zero realisation that how others experience life and stuff is not how they do could forward their contact details and I will forward to colleague, house on fire and all that. (I am imagining quite a lot of Fatima Whitbreads walking around).

OP posts:
EL0ISE · 04/02/2020 12:06

Have they done a risk assessment ? Was this done on, say people under 5’ 6” or who weight under 70kg or who have an injury or health condition ? Does this new rule also apply to staff with disabilities?

Because they are saying it’s now part of your job to carry this about. And take it on and off your back many times a day eg when you sit on a bus or tube. That a lot of lifting and twisting.

Did the risk assessment take account of other things you might be carrying eg power supply , paperwork, personal items like a handbag?

And of course they know ( because you have notified them in writing) that you have an injury and you are concerned that this new requirement will exacerbate it.

HorseWithNoLang · 04/02/2020 12:04

HeresWally.. lol

OP massive sympathy with the back problem and totes agree with you and others here about your ridiculous colleague.

(Am I imagining it or are there loads of new posters on this thread? Which is great..waves..)

OhHolyJesus · 04/02/2020 11:47

Slight detail.

Ages ago there was a study on women carrying those heavy monthly magazines around, it showed how if you have a handbag on one arm and are not balanced (with a heavy magazine in the other) you can change the shape of your spine over time.

I have scoliosis so switched to a backpack and stopped wearing heels.

Laptops probably feature in Invisible Women but I haven't finished reading it yet.

suziesue45 · 04/02/2020 11:41

So, if you forget your laptop there are no desktops to use at work now? Yes we have this in our place too, I'm lucky I have a desk top (Which I refuse to give up) and a laptop for any meetings I need to go off site for. I feel your pain, and this is going to sound sexist but as a woman I carry my normal bag, packed lunch bag (as the place I work does not have a canteen) and also my laptop bag with any papers and items I need for the meetings so I do look like a bag lady at times.

SonicVersusGynaephobia · 04/02/2020 11:41

My company has heavy laptops and they are a nightmare, and they do cause shoulder/back problems and a lot of female staff say they are far too heavy.

I drive to work so I don't have to lug it around with me on my commute. I do travel a lot though, and it's too heavy to bring with me if I need to carry it, and pulley trolley bags are not helpful in busy places either.

To resolve this, I no longer bring my laptop with me when I have to travel to meetings. It probably makes me less productive but if company want to address that they can bloody well pay for a laptop that is a suitable weight to be properly portable (for a woman, not for the default reference man, men have 40% more upper body strength than women, even if a man is the same size and weight, it's not comparable. Your colleague is an idiot).

If you develop any back or shoulder problems as a result of having to carry the laptop with you, then the employer is liable for that injury.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread