Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Threat to freedom of speech, Oxford university

32 replies

BovaryX · 22/01/2020 06:44

In yet another example of the existential threat to freedom of speech, Merton College Oxford proposes draconian conditions on an upcoming debate on gender which will prevent the GC position being articulated. As a poster on another thread commented, the anniversary of George Orwell's death shines a spotlight on the dystopian environment where rigorous debate, critical thinking and freedom of speech are struggling to withstand an onslaught from those that believe in none of the above.

^Academics have accused Merton College of adopting a “draconian” stance towards free speech by “suppressing gender-critical thought”.
Prof Selina Todd, a historian at Oxford University, said she was “stunned” by the event’s rules, adding that it sets a “dangerous precedent”.
“My understanding is that universities and colleges are supposed to be upholding free speech” she said. “Merton College seemed to me a place where you could debate calmly and an informed matter, and the way this has now been couched as 'you're not allowed to debate' has left me staggered.”She said it is “very worrying” that a reputable university college such as Merton has made such an “overt statement that debate is not welcomed”^

OP posts:
brendansbuddy · 22/01/2020 08:14

Looks like a complaint to [email protected].
Astounding that a university would allow a 'conversation' or debate with certain views and language disallowed.
What a load of...

BovaryX · 22/01/2020 07:43

It's not much of a discussion if the views of those who question the ideology in question are prevented from articulating the reasons for their dissent. This is happening in Oxford university in the 21st century.

Prof Michael Biggs, an Oxford sociologist, said: “The code of conduct seems intended to instil anxiety in the audience, who cannot know what viewpoints are forbidden

OP posts:
RicketyClickety · 22/01/2020 07:35

And the obvious complementary pairing of people who decide gender is an unstoppable societal belief that they just have to go along with by changing their appearance.

RicketyClickety · 22/01/2020 07:33

It's not much of a "conversation" if everyone has to pretend that it's still the 1950s.

Since the majority of people who identify with/as the opposite sex stop after a few years when they realise gender is societally imposed b**cks that doesn't fit everyone, surely this is an important view to have in the "conversation".

Whynotnowbaby · 22/01/2020 07:29

Very sad, Merton was my staid old college and there were many things I found difficult there but I never thought this would be one of them.

feetfreckles · 22/01/2020 07:22

So to attend you must agree not to offend people with gender diverse identities.....except those who think their gender identity is null and ..hold on now...different to their sex ....whose existence is basically offensive

Anyone up for making logic part of the national curriculum?

OP posts: