Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Real names

39 replies

emerencemaybehopeful · 15/09/2019 06:57

Magdalen Berns told us that she wasn't our martyr.

I've seen so many calls for women to be brave and to use our own names, more this weekend than before. Not to hide behind the very few women who are standing up and who are losing so much because of it.

And I want to talk about that somewhere. Because I finally got angry enough to start writing last week, and I have dithered about what name to use.

I have so much respect for those who use their own names. And I'm not the least bit embarrassed or afraid to own my opinions. But I have a very unusual surname and if I use that name, which is my husbands and which I've never really been reconciled to, my children will be easily traced. I've invested energy into keeping their online profile small. Because it isn't just about me, the individual. It's me, the mother. Me, the member of a small community. My name is not just mine, it connects me to others.

I hate the fact that the first question asked by friends who read my article was 'what name do you plan to use'. What world is this, that not one, but many asked this question? It feels a bit cloak and dagger. Which makes me want to just go ahead and put the name that is on my passport and drivers license onto all I do.

I'm getting into knots thinking about this and I'd appreciate other people helping me understand the implications of all the different decisions. To what extent is my female socialisation, my desire to protect my children and family, getting in the way of me doing good work?

Would I feel the same if I didn't use this surname purely because it felt easier to give in to my husbands strong feelings about the family having one name? I grew up with a double barrelled name and my parents each had their own and I hated that, so when he refused to pick a new name I agreed to just take his. But I don't identify with the name or with his family. And as I said, it's not a common name.

If I use a variation on my name, is that still hiding? My middle name? My mothers surname or my fathers?

Are the stakes different for those who work in certain jobs, or is that just a distraction or excuse?

What do we gain from real names vs pseudonyms? What do we lose?

OP posts:
Juells · 15/09/2019 12:36

I don't use my real name on twitter because it would trace back to my daughter and her partner. It's OK to make the choice for yourself, but not for other people.

SirVixofVixHall · 15/09/2019 11:17

I am in the same position op. My surname is very unusual, it is my husband’s name, it then makes my children easy to find and /or bully . If you google it my husband and daughter will come up.
I am on twitter under my real name, so I am careful about what I tweet. I am stuck about what to do. I agree there is strength in numbers , but I feel a responsibility towards my family too.
I am fairly vocal in real life about women’s rights, but I am far less vocal online. I could use my very common maiden name, but that also feels cowardly. It is a dilemma.

Inebriati · 15/09/2019 10:52

My take is to look at other areas where women live with abuse and risk.
What do we tell women who are living with domestic violence? We don't tell them that they must leave, now.
We trust them to know when they have the resources to act safely.

Barracker · 15/09/2019 10:17

Do what will be most beneficial to you and to your ideals.
There are spies and secret agents in every fight. If every member of the French resistance felt compelled to declare "actually, my real name is this and my true motivation is X" the war might have ended differently.

Additionally, there is a reason why our democracy preserves anonymity in voting. It preserves fairness.

Sometimes it is more important to remain anonymous and provide show of strength in numbers instead.

If you are a public figure and your name lends weight, then use it.
If breaking anonymity would place you and your children in danger, or even just hobble your effectiveness, then don't. If you know you would say less, self-moderate more, reduce your actions because of your name being known, then it's a counterproductive exercise.

Be the most effective you can be. Only you know whether that will be named or anonymous.

Don't feel pressured by the game of chicken. The aim is to make the biggest difference you can.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 15/09/2019 09:09

Mouthy, what was your employers response, if you don't mind me asking?

I find it disturbing that so many employers buckle and don't support their employee; and tell the complainant to piss off.

I'd expect a bit more loyalty from mine, but i'm too chicken to test that theory myself.

pachyderm · 15/09/2019 08:49

I hear you OP. I'm also GC under my own name but in a careful restrained way, focusing on "safer" issues like transing of children and sports. It's easier to get people thinking that way and I've managed to "peak trans" a lot of people I know. On AGP and more out there topics, I use a pseudonym as there are risks to me and my family work-wise.

BarbaraStrozzi · 15/09/2019 08:12

I too have an unusual name. I'm also in an area of employment where I'm required (it's in my contract) to be politically neutral, and we have quite detailed rules about keeping private political activity and professional life separate - this is all political views, not just trans issues. So I tend to be ultra cautious.

I have however deliberately commented BTL in some national newspapers in a very careful and I hope respectful way - but nonetheless unequivocally gender critical. I've done this partly as a defence against doxxing. If the shit ever hit the fan, I'd be able to say to HR, yes, these are my private political views, they're out there under my own name, but I'm careful not to link them to my workplace, and I do have freedom of political expression in my private life clearly set out in our workplace conduct guide, and freedom of belief is a protected characteristic under the Equalities Act.

Qcng · 15/09/2019 08:12

I wouldn't use your real name unless you are 100% confident. It doesn't sound like you are.

The main impact about the "real name" thing going on at the moment is so you can see so many women coming out as GC and being brave, but there's no obligation to do it.

FlaviaAlbia · 15/09/2019 08:11

Don't forget that some TRA's/MRA's are completely unhinged. Didn't Posie Parker and Caroline Farrow have their kids schools published online?

In your place I'd use a pen name.

truthisarevolutionaryact · 15/09/2019 08:01

A real dilemma OP. Currently the prevailing institutions of power have been captured by men determined to silence women and appropriate all the safeguards and rights that women have fought for. And that makes us vulnerable. Until the law acts to protect free speech and ensures that women are able to speak out about this abuse without losing us our jobs and our safety, I'd have no hesitation in hiding my real name.
There are some judicial reviews - fair cop and Maya Fortstater to name a couple - which hopefully will help - if they win.

PotatoShape · 15/09/2019 07:49

Whilst I agree that I am hiding a bit by not putting my name out there, it also means I can actually say what I think, no holds barred. There is no polite way to say that men can never be women. It will always result in anger and attacks from these men.
But nothing will be gained by being silent, or living in enforced 'agreement' by the attacks.

nettie434 · 15/09/2019 07:43

My twitter account is my real name and used for work. It does limit what I can say not just on feminist topics. If I was starting again, I might have two accounts, one very 'professional' and formal, the other completely personal.

If you have an unusual name, as you do, you are more identifiable, especially if you are on different social media where different pieces of information can be put together. People will have different levels of concern about this.

I do understand the rationale for asking women to be more 'out' in terms of identity but women (and men) will need to think about this carefully. Any decision has to be what's right for the individual

BitOfFun · 15/09/2019 07:20

I'd have a professional pen-name. As you say, using your married name could draw attention to your children.

MouthyHarpy · 15/09/2019 07:16

I use my real name on (one of) my Twitter accounts. That got me a complaint for transphobia to my employer, which included twice a statement that I should be sacked for my ideas/beliefs.

So there are risks.

However, speaking a to a journalist and having a little bit of my story in the public domain actually relieved the burden of carrying the experience.

But it depends on where you’re publishing and what your affiliations are, and how you declare those affiliations. If you’re publishing in, say Medium, as a private individual, then go for it!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread