model pretends to be trans

Trans trans ARE trans

Scrimshaw, are trans females in fact male or female? The trouble with language that says black is white is you can never tell what fricking colour anything is supposed to be any more. False implies anything.

Yeahnahyeah I have every sympathy for her! What a ridiculous situation we are in, though. That's what I find so darkly humorous. Not laughing at her predicament - I hope she has good support and some sensible women looking out for her.

Either self-ID is sacrosanct or it isn't. Either trans people should always, always be believed, or they shouldn't. Either sex is a "spectrum" or it isn't.

That's too binary for the spectrum-believers.

Here's another one of many articles about this
www.google.com/amp/s/www.cosmopolitan.com/entertainment/celebs/amp28542883/carissa-pinkston-lies-transgender/

I feel incredibly sad for this young woman, and very concerned. The pile on is ugly and will get worse I suspect.

She is only 20. Sure, a silly lie, but imagine the wrath of your peers at that age upon bring called transphobic. I don't think her comments were transphobic at all. There are no receipts that she compared trans to peodophilia AFAIK.

Those posting 'haha' type posts, have a think....

This is about a young woman who is now an outcast.

I hope she is ok. This poor woman.

As far as I can see, thirdfiddle, she said trans females aren't women, or some other such apostasy.

Mind you, of course she is trans! She says she is. No debate.

I'm going to be trans tomorrow. I'm going to be a new category meaning someone who identifies as someone who believes all this stuff is crap.
Can I have my badge and adulation at 7am please?

Gender is merely assigned at birth, often incorrectly, and genitals are not indicative of anything. She says she is trans, she must be trans

Absolutely! We must not forget that trans ideology teaches us penises and clitorises are virtually the same; so naked baby pics prove nothing.

Did she actually say transwomen were paedophiles? Or express concern that male paedophiles would say they were trans (and if they say it they are) in order to get access to young girls? If the former then yeah maybe transphobic. The latter I'd agree is a concern. It's how safeguarding works, you do have to stop completely innocent people from doing things in order to reduce opportunities for dodgy people to be dodgy.

OP you need to get the transphobic title of this thread changed - nobody ever pretends to be trans. It just never happens. If someone ids as trans then trans they are.

nauticant I love you.
There is also another woman (as is dinosaurs would call her) claiming to be a man who identifies as a woman. Which is clearly a big steaming pile of bullshit but I'm not sure if we're allowed to say that. Will I get deleted?

Acceprance without exception!

They made the rules now they need to folliw them. Therefore if she says shes trans then she is trans and they must accept it.

One of the comments shown in that link says they know she isn't trans because they have seen her naked and seen baby pics. That sounds like they're reducing her to her genitals. Gender is merely assigned at birth, often incorrectly, and genitals are not indicative of anything. She says she is trans, she must be trans.

On another note, I feel quite worried for her. This abuse she must have received for her initial comments to lead her to claim to be a transwoman must have been pretty horrific. And now that it's been exposed as a lie (despite that contradicting the whole idea of self identification), she is going to be bullied mercilessly I imagine. I really hope she is ok. It's a very toxic environment.

circumgender

Brilliant.

MonkeyToesOfDoom not according to trans activists. They campaigned to demedicalise it

A medical professional when they give the person a diagnosis of dysphoria or the person is receiving treatment for dysphoria.

No, you don't have to have a medical professionals, say so to identify as Trans.

Isn't there some woman that identifies as a man who identifies as a woman?
She's trans.
She transitioned.
It doesn't matter how her body looks or that it has never been altered, she's trans.

Why doesn't that apply here?

Saying TW are not W, is not transphobic. Calling them paedophiles is though.

Who gets to say whether someone is trans or not?

A medical professional when they give the person a diagnosis of dysphoria or the person is receiving treatment for dysphoria.

This young woman lost her job and possibly career because she said transwomen are not women.

Was she even claiming to be amab?

From what I read she said she transitioned very early and certainly implied that she was a transwoman now.

Rookie error - she should have known that only true trans people (as ordained by the transisterhood) get to conceal genuine biological facts about their birth.

Was she even claiming to be amab? According to the tenants of self-id, she can be biologically female, present in a stereotypically female way, and whatever identify she declares is valid. She could be a feminine, female, who identifies as male. She could be non-binary. She could be gender fluid. She could even be a feminine presenting female who identifies as a woman, but not in the boring way.

Lots of TRAs claim that they were "born female", just "violently mis-assigned male at birth". I don't see how this is any different.

The alternative is for all these woke folks is to throw a young black woman under the bus for Having Opinions While Female, and they are far too woke for that, surely?

Saying TW are not W, is not transphobic.