Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Isn't Andrew Gilligan a brilliant journalist?

31 replies

Twistables · 21/07/2019 01:17

The doctors at the Tavistock are finally speaking out. Children ‘misled’ at gender clinic
thetimes.co.uk

OP posts:
bunslinger · 21/07/2019 07:08

pepperpot99 - you've badly misremembered what happened. Gilligan made two mistakes in a live radio interview (not a printed article), firstly strengthening Kelly's statement that the 45-minute claim in the report was 'unreliable' to a statement that the Government 'probably knew it was wrong'. And secondly, describing his (anonymous) source as an 'intelligence service source' when he should have said 'one of the senior officials in charge of drawing up the dossier'.

Obviously neither of those mistakes did anything to out Kelly. And neither of them detract from the main point of a very important story and a brave piece of journalism - that the 'dodgy dossier' had indeed been 'sexed up', which has now been admitted by everyone involved, including both Blair and Campbell.

David Kelly's identity became public because Kelly told his employer that he'd spoken to Gilligan, and they cynically decided to reveal his identity to the press to attempt to discredit the original story (by inserting clues in a press release and then responding to any wrong guesses that were put to them). This in turn led directly to Kelly's disgraceful public shaming by the Foreign Affairs Committee.

Obviously Gilligan wasn't entirely perfect, misspeaking in a live radio interview, but did break a story of major national interest, which has now been vindicated, and did nothing to compromise the identity of his source.

pepperpot99 · 21/07/2019 06:45

He's the journo who printed a twisted version of Dr David Kelly's critique of the Blair Govt's '45 minute Iraq attack' allegation - outing him when he was supposed to be anonymous - which eventually culminated in that man's suicide. So I'm going with 'no he's not' too.

boatyardblues · 21/07/2019 06:34

I only know of one story he did which was an extremely cunty hatchet job so I'm going with no he's not.

It would be too outing to say. Nothing to do with trans issues though.

How convenient! Your own hatchet job post and an excuse for not standing up such a damning assessment.

wafflyversatile · 21/07/2019 01:32

It would be too outing to say. Nothing to do with trans issues though.

WeirdWoman · 21/07/2019 01:29

Which story was that @wafflyversatile ? Confused

wafflyversatile · 21/07/2019 01:23

I only know of one story he did which was an extremely cunty hatchet job so I'm going with no he's not.