Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

I was mildly GC in front of my mates today. Holy moley, this has gone further than I realised.

118 replies

LeesPostersAreInFrames · 24/03/2019 18:42

I have a hobby group of friends, we met up today. The hobby attracts left wing types, of which I am one.

The subject of LGBT+ came up, and after a bit the subject of gendered toilets and changing rooms came up. I expressed that I felt women's spaces should be strictly for women only.

One friend said that the toilets in almost all of the schools, colleges and universities in the area had been changed to non-gender specific.

Another said that their training in several fashion retail spaces had been to allow a person to use the gendered changing room of their choice. There was a "larger" changing area (not allowed to say disabled), which they could offer to trans people, but they could go in the gendered room they felt most comfortable in. I asked what happened if anybody ever complained; they were trained to say they were sorry but policy was to allow people to use the space they felt most comfortable in. These spaces had curtains but they'd had problems previously with mobile phone cameras being used.

The girls in the schools had expressed discomfort at boys being able to hear the rustle of sanitary wear wraps as they used them.

My friends seemed surprised at my views, and I didn't go any further. I'm not really sure how to have these conversations, but it seems utterly essential and urgent.

It's in the UK, and it's much more widespread than I had thought.

Help. How do I get people questioning this stuff?

OP posts:
Chiochan · 24/03/2019 21:57

I have two kids and one income (so REALLY dont want to lose my job) but if it really comes down to it, I will.

CharlieParley · 24/03/2019 21:32

LeesPostersAreInFrames bravo for stating your opinions so clearly. That sounds like a very good first conversation, especially since the others volunteered some of the issues themselves. That's often something you first have to explain.

You did well there. Judging from my experience, your fellow hobbyists will pay a little more attention to certain issues over the next few weeks. Give them a little time and if you want to, you could talk about sports. The policy of allowing males to compete against females in female-only sports is almost universally rejected.

I've been doing this for about a year now and with one exception every single person I've spoken to shares our views. It's a nice bit of gaslighting that ours is a minority view. You start to feel really unsure when people keep saying that. But the claim is actually an incorrect extrapolation from the fact that there is wide support for equal rights for trans people. This support is then simply assumed or claimed to also extend to wholehearted support for gender ideology.

We all support equal rights for trans people, of course. We simply don't agree that the rights of female people are superseded by the rights of males who identify as trans or that such males actually are women or that a woman is whoever identifies as one.

And according to a number of polls, we know that the vast majority of people reject legal sex self-identification. People simply do not agree with the idea of giving intact males access to female-only spaces. Most people of course are still unaware that the self-id campaign is not about post-op transsexuals but crossdressers and others who do not medically transition. Once they find that out, they are frequently quite angry about that.

RepealTheGRA · 24/03/2019 21:31

Chiochan

Check out your whistle blowing policy. Then whistleblow, it’s a safeguarding issue.

Chiochan · 24/03/2019 21:26

I work in a school and the idea of mixed loos is very scary but I dont know if I would be able to speak out. The school has a staff member who is very activly pushing 'inclusivity' in the Gires vein and no one will openly challange it.
There are probably more than average number of kids with complex issues. The school has already had to make the main wall seperating the boys loos from the rest of the school half glass (I very strongly suspect to stop them assulting each other) so the idea that young girls will be forced to share their loos is very concerning.

LeesPostersAreInFrames · 24/03/2019 21:05

Thanks, and fair point on the language (normally something I pride myself on! Blush)

OP posts:
MeAgainAgain · 24/03/2019 21:01

My yes it is was to racism

SpartacusAutisticusAHF · 24/03/2019 21:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SpartacusAutisticusAHF · 24/03/2019 20:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MeAgainAgain · 24/03/2019 20:57

Yes it is

R0wantrees · 24/03/2019 20:57

One friend sai£ the toilets was unisex in most schools and colleges

Naming these correctly as mixed sex is helpful.

(language matters)

RepealTheGRA · 24/03/2019 20:51

*Yet in this country it’s cool for us to have men and boys in our toilets

So it seems that men in other countries are unsafe to be around women and girls when they are in the toilet*

Is that not called ‘racism’ Confused

LeesPostersAreInFrames · 24/03/2019 20:46

Gently getting your friends to think about why they have a certain position on something, and getting them to think about questions they might not have done so yet, is not evangelising in my book.

If they have thought about it and are well informed and of another conclusion to me, that's fine. It could be much more than fine, because I'd love to have my mind changed so I can stop worrying about the impact on young people of the erosion of women's spaces. At the moment, I'm concerned that a massive regressive problem is being sleep walked into, because not many people have really thought it through.

OP posts:
RepealTheGRA · 24/03/2019 20:46

I'd rather be engaged in critical thinking rather than be suffering from insomnia, surviving on autopilot. Which is "woke".

Good answer Grin

MeAgainAgain · 24/03/2019 20:42

I mean in the shops

Obviuosly still in schools etc

MeAgainAgain · 24/03/2019 20:41

Mind you when I was a girl there were still communal changing rooms.

Maybe still are somewhere

littlbrowndog · 24/03/2019 20:40

And you can ask your mates why the un say that sex segregated toilet spaces is safer for women and girls

Yet in this country it’s cool for us to have men and boys in our toilets

So it seems that men in other countries are unsafe to be around women and girls when they are in the toilet

How does that work ?

MeAgainAgain · 24/03/2019 20:38

The room within a room thing is iffy as well.

As it's away from where most people are.

The shops I've been in with unisex changing have had proper doors and have opened out onto shop floor, which is better.

The changes do seem to erode the opportunity for girls to do the sort of shopping as a group and trying stuff on together looking in communal mirrors that used to go on, which was fun when I was a girl.

SleepingSloth · 24/03/2019 20:36

No evangelising going on from me!

You said your friends seemed surprised at your views. That to me says they don't have an issue with it like you do. But then later you said 'help, how do I get people questioning this stuff?' If they are ok with it, then that's it. But you want them to question it and presumably come to the same conclusion you have.

MeAgainAgain · 24/03/2019 20:36

Unless top shop have changed since I was a teen, flimsy curtains are standard.

Any old bloke being able to wander in is dodgy as hell.

The response to this often seems to be 'I don't like changing rooms with curtains so I don't use them' but that's not a solution is it?

Also opens the way for victim blaming if /when something happens (well she knew there could be men in there and she still stripped to her knickers).

SleepingSloth · 24/03/2019 20:31

Yes, there was this slightly weird impression of, yes, we know women don't feel safe in mixed changing spaces or loos, but what can you do, trans people's rights trump that kind of attitude.

For me, it's nothing to do with trans people's rights trumping mine as a womans.
If cubicles are floor to ceiling, I just don't mind who is in the next the changing room or toilet cubicle as I don't have to be in there with them. Before I go in the cubicle, I am fully dressed, by the time I come out, I'm fully dressed. Why would I feel unsafe? I do understand the issue with curtains in changing rooms, I don't like them as there's always toddlers wondering around playing with the curtains and I don't particularly want to be undressed in front of anyone I don't know. I still use them though.

littlbrowndog · 24/03/2019 20:31

All the lols at skyzlimt

littlbrowndog · 24/03/2019 20:30

One friend sai£ the toilets was unisex in most schools and colleges

How does the friend know

Is the friend a toilet inspector through out the Uk ?

LeesPostersAreInFrames · 24/03/2019 20:29

More seriously, you need to exist in a world where many people think you are wrong. Yes, make your views known, but evangelising only ever puts people's backs up. And people can be just as well informed as you but form different opinions based on that information.*

No evangelising going on from me! Confused I stated two opinions (women should have access to women only spaces, and mixed sex individual cubicle floor to ceiling wall and door changing spaces were my preference) then shut up and listened to other people. Who, I guess, might already be en route to changing their own views.

I don't want too live in a world where everybody agrees with me. But I want to do my best to encourage people to think critically about the erosion of women's spaces and not just comply without question.

OP posts:
nzborn · 24/03/2019 20:29

If l had to share a changing room area with males l just wouldn't buy anything from the shop.

l think when businesses combine toileting areas is lazy.

As a Women and Mother l am very conscious of mine and others personal space.l just think that it is a higher risk to share these type of areas.

Our local Gym/swimming pool just reopened and now the main changing room is communal,apparently their are family changing rooms but you have to go through this main area to to reach them.People have commented nude men can be seen in this area so we won't be joining it.

l just think some of us are more private than others.

LeesPostersAreInFrames · 24/03/2019 20:21

I know I’m missing the point, but what hobby attracts left wing types?

😬 Glad I wasn't the only one wondering that.

Lentil knitting Grin

Lentil weaving you idiot Count! Grin

Weave your own granola

Singing

Absolutely ROFLMAO at these things!😂

I'm being boring and trying to retain some semblance of vague anonymity. I didn't know these was a link between our hobby and political views until in another random conversation last week when somebody who has been doing and teaching it much longer than I have, pointed it out when I was saying it seemed to attract nice and decent people. Although I do like weaving my own granola.

Yes, there was this slightly weird impression of, yes, we know women don't feel safe in mixed changing spaces or loos, but what can you do, trans people's rights trump that kind of attitude. I stayed away from confronting that because I'm only fairly recently "peaked" myself and unsure what to do or say for the best. Hence seeking ideas on here, or at least people who recognise this feeling!

Seriously. The gender neutral toilets being more common than not now in schools has floored me. I thought we were some way off that.

OP posts: