Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Men don't care about women's jobs

43 replies

ExtraPineappleExtraHam · 16/03/2019 10:14

I work for a big healthcare provider, which covers about a quarter of England. The company has been having a two year long admin review. Yesterday my colleagues and I were all pulled into the large meeting room and given the news that we all expected. Jobs are being cut and jobs are being downgraded. People will lose money and there is really no room for progression past £12 an hour in this trust anymore.
We were all women. 25 of us. I imagine this isn't unusual for the trust. Most women I know work in admin. A representative for the review didn't even turn up for us to ask any questions or to explain the process. That's how little they value us, they sent a PowerPoint presentation to do their dirty work.
My opinion is that the men at the top feel that women are of little value. They see us all as replaceable, and that we don't care much about career progression because so many of us are part time. Plus we probably have a man at home whose earning the real money. This is just a bit of pocket money for us, to break up the monotony.
I just get the feeling men would push back against this kind of thing more. At the end I was one of the only women to vent my frustrations that no one was there to ask the very important questions to. I feel like becoming a Union rep just so I get to actually speak to someone about this. I'm not even one of the ones effected as I'm the lowest of the low and they can't actually take away anymore of my pay but I'm angry on others behalf. Why do some women just seem to accept this shit?

OP posts:
andyoldlabour · 16/03/2019 11:24

My wife is working as a masters qualified scientist in the private sector, and the male and female staff are paid roughly the same - very poorly. She is on £12 per hour, but some of the junior scientists/technicians are on around £8-9 per hour.
Wages are falling back in all sectors and jobs atre being cut all over the place.

Newbuild · 16/03/2019 11:23

Why do you think woman are drawn to low paid roles? Flexibility? I was thinking about this recently about ‘typical’ woman’s roles being not well paid and often at risk of redundancy.. I agree it’s true but it’s also led me to wonder why woman degrade themselves to these roles?
I work in a very Male dominated industry, they’ve not had a woman come to an interview in years - I do the hiring and would love to hire another woman.
I’m not being goady I’m curious as to why this happens.

IM0GEN · 16/03/2019 11:22

You are right . I encourage all my children to go into jobs which have traditionally been Male dominated as they generally pay more and have better T and Cs.

Many worthwhile jobs which contribute a lot to society have crap wages or conditions just because they are mostly female eg care workers, cleaners, nursery workers, hairdressers, many admin jobs.

ExtraPineappleExtraHam · 16/03/2019 11:15

@BadPennyNoBiscuit the healthcare assistants are also band 3, obviously you get more the longer you stay but there's no 'danger pay.' The HCA's are also largely women and non British nationals, not many men would stay for that money.

OP posts:
MIdgebabe · 16/03/2019 11:09

I think it’s capatalism which builds on patriarchy rather than simple sexism...structural

BadPennyNoBiscuit · 16/03/2019 11:05

I think most people would assume you'd be paid a lot more than £8 an hour for your job.

ExtraPineappleExtraHam · 16/03/2019 10:59

@BadPennyNoBiscuit I really enjoy my job, and I feel like I can make a difference to their lives. But I used to earn more working in a deli eating olives and Brie all day and listening to 6 music. It's not really fair that I'll never get a pay rise.

OP posts:
ExtraPineappleExtraHam · 16/03/2019 10:56

@DpWm yes I am. Do you not think '1000's of police staff face job cuts' makes a bigger impact than 'admin assistants in the NHS lose their jobs'?
But we are just as important as those on the 'front line.' I've even heard people in my own establishment talking about how there's too many admin and that they 'don't know what we do all day.' The fact that they don't get how important medical secretary's, information governance and medical record clerks, financial assistants, receptionists and ward admin are in their own trust are is astounding. I do think this links back to women not blowing their own trumpets enough.

OP posts:
BadPennyNoBiscuit · 16/03/2019 10:53

Thats not a job you should be paid minimum wage for doing. You couldn't pay me to step foot on to a secure/forensic mens mental health ward.

DpWm · 16/03/2019 10:49

Yeah that's really shit.
I presume you're in the public sector?

There are massive cuts across the public sector and believe me they are not discriminating on the basis of sex. (The police force eg).

Yes, women are more 'agreeable' when it comes to accepting a low wage, that's a different issue.

When it comes to cuts to a work force though, economic decisions do not account for maleness or femaleness.

My male friend who cares for the elderly has experenced dramatic losses to his sector and staff cuts he is also experiencing stresses.
It's important to direct anger where it's due which isn't necessarily sexism but is usually economic incompetence due to bad governance.

bsc · 16/03/2019 10:46

There have been a series of articles in the guardian about how the job losses since austerity measures have had a greater effect on women than men. Possibly by Frances Ryan?

ExtraPineappleExtraHam · 16/03/2019 10:38

I do agree that there are redundancy's across the country but there seems to be a lot made of some in the media and not others. I do feel that gender comes into it.
I work in secure services, I am a ward clerk for a rehab ward of men detained by the mental health act, usually they've been transferred from prison. Our jobs are tough. Yesterday I went to the toilet on a different ward and there was just a man watching me through the glass, grinning. I regularly go into the ward for meetings, to make a drink or to ask a service user a question about their food choices or doctors appointments. There is an element of risk as these men have criminal pasts and they don't see any other women. There's also a lot of responsibility for the security of the unit. Imagine if I accidentally held the door open for someone or didn't send a letter to the ministry of justice on time? I'm paid £8.78 per hour.
Now they are saying that for that money I have to do the same work as someone a pay grade above me, for no extra money. It's so unfair. I feel men would just tell them that they aren't happy to do that. However we have been raised to nod, to accept, to do whatever to keep the peace, to make the tea, to work through lunch-breaks. I wish my colleagues had more fight in them.

OP posts:
exculpatrix · 16/03/2019 10:36

There is a definite trend across society generally of "women's work" being valued less than men. Traditionally female heavy sectors, such as nursing, PAing, etc attract less income and less social cachet than traditionally masculine work, regardless of the actual skill or effort involved.

xtinak · 16/03/2019 10:27

If you want to do something like becoming a union rep, you should do it. You could make a difference and you sound like you would be good at it. I see some of these issues as mainly structural/institutional inequalities that men don't specifically want or directly cause, but at the same time we all need to recognise and correct them rather than just seeing them as "how it is". However, the lack of a representative here seems not just like a lack of interest in their part but actually a possibly conscious decision to create a barrier to any action on your part. You should address it. Good luck!

DpWm · 16/03/2019 10:27

Some of the biggest redundancy losses have fallen to men.
Our country is falling to bits and everyone is affected.

Ifonlyus · 16/03/2019 10:25

Admin jobs are so undervalued and underpaid. They still get away with paying the same as I remember them being advertised for 20 years ago, when I left Uni. Admin jobs are so far removed from the typist and filing clerks that used to constitute a company's admin. In yet, some jobs which require few celebral skills or education - like warehouse worker or supermarket security or estates staff - more typically carried out by males, have typically been paid more.

DpWm · 16/03/2019 10:25

To be fair mass redundancies also happen in work places that are very male-orientated. (Manufacturing for example).

Healthcare is particularly prone to redundancies at the moment because of government lead austerity measires.

Your anger could be usefully applied as a union representative but recognise that structural economic decisions rather than sexism are at play here.

StephsCaddy · 16/03/2019 10:21

That’s shit and I’m inclined to agree that it’s because it’s a female dominated sector

Just look at retail - thousands of jobs have been lost this past decade and no one seems to really give a shit.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.