Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women can rise up without dragging men down

114 replies

Bumpitybumper · 11/03/2019 13:59

During International Women's Day my Instagram feed was flooded with various feminist quotes and mantras, but one which really stuck with me was about how women gaining power, influence and status doesn't mean that men are automatically worse off. I appreciate that the woman sharing it was almost trying to sell feminism to an audience that probably included a lot of men, but surely the premise is wrong? By default women taking up positions of power and gaining more influence will reduce the position of men (as a class) who are used to pretty much having the monopoly on it all.

Sorry if the wording of the thread title isn't the exact quote as i couldn't find the original post.

OP posts:
Deathgrip · 11/03/2019 14:33

Yes, many men realise that equality means losing their inherent privilege - why do you think so many of them hate feminism?

Bumpitybumper · 11/03/2019 14:31

@10IAR
Decent men could miss out though by the fact that their potential to achieve and gain positions of influence will be more limited if women truly gained equality. Of course you (and I) would argue that the original perceived potential was overstated and built on suppressing women but I think the patriarchy and lack of equality benefits lots of men and not just those that display toxic masculinity.

OP posts:
bingoitsadingo · 11/03/2019 14:29

I agree with you. I think men would benefit in many ways from a more equal society, but yes they will 'lose out' on some fronts where they are currently overrepresented.

CaptainMarvelBunting · 11/03/2019 14:26

It's also very male-centric in it's view of power and 'status' - as I understand it, feminism is not about women just getting ahead in the rat race better.

From my perspective, feminism is about liberating women from a system that is stacked against them, so that we see through the scorn that 'women's work' garners. It's the very fact that men would consider it 'dragging them down' to be doing 'women's work' that is part of the problem. The fact that no value whatsoever is placed on so much of women's labour is the heart of patriarchy's crushing boot on us.

It's a vicious cycle. The jobs that tend to fall to women have low status, and therefore women are deemed to have low status, and those jobs are deemed appropriate for those with low status. So men, conditioned to pursue 'high status', eschew those jobs as 'women's work' and round and round we go on the gender merrygoround.

Bumpitybumper · 11/03/2019 14:26

@Grimbles
That's just buying into the assumption that men are 'entitled' to that position in the first place
I certainly don't feel that way, but I do think that for a long long time men have had the luxury of getting these positions without much real challenge from women. I still think men as a class expect to get the vast majority of these roles and I think they will find it hard to accept that true equality means losing that privilege.

OP posts:
10IAR · 11/03/2019 14:26

I feel that equality will only target toxic masculinity though, because that's the problem isn't it?

Men automatically being dominant, being powerful, being the decision makers and high flyers.

In an equal world, the decent men won't miss out. That's kind of the point I think.

Men and women being equal, surely the only people who would disagree with that principle are the ones who would lose out and therefore benefit from inequality.

MagicMix · 11/03/2019 14:25

No, I get what you're saying. It is basically true that if feminism 'succeeds' men will have to lose privilege, status and power.

I understand why people want to make feminism seem palatable and non-threatening to men, and I truly do believe that the liberation of women will benefit men in some ways, but it's quite obvious that male supremacy benefits males.

Bumpitybumper · 11/03/2019 14:23

Just to be clear, as a feminist myself I obviously support women getting more influence but I just worry that it's disingenuous to suggest that this won't be at any cost to men.

That's why I much prefer "when all you've known is privilege, equality feels like oppression" @10IAR as I think it's more honest. Things are currently unfairly unequal and when we hopefully level things out there will be winners and losers. Men may well see some benefits regarding a decline of toxic masculinity, but as a class their power and influence will diminish.

OP posts:
10IAR · 11/03/2019 14:22

Again, Grimbles has it.

I also agree that diminishing toxic masculinity benefits everyone, not all masculinity is toxic BUT toxic masculinity is beyond damaging.

Grimbles · 11/03/2019 14:20

Sometimes there is a limited number of opportunities or amount of influence available and women stepping up does mean that men must step down.

That's just buying into the assumption that men are 'entitled' to that position in the first place.

blueskiesovertheforest · 11/03/2019 14:17

Generally if women gain,men as a class gain because toxic masculinity isn't good for men either. Getting rid of gender stereotypes would benefit children of both sexes, who could grow up to be themselves. Those with entrenched power based on misogyny might be less thrilled and want to prevent it of course.

10IAR · 11/03/2019 14:17

"when all you've known is privilege, equality feels like oppression"

Nobody is dragging men down, and as Grimbles says, that kind of thinking is part of the problem.

Nobody gave a shit when it was women being deprived of opportunities because we're women. But now all of a sudden men are being "dragged down" because women want equality? No, that's not the case at all.

Bumpitybumper · 11/03/2019 14:16

But sometimes it does though? For example the fact that Theresa May is Prime Minister probably means that a man that otherwise would have held that position won't get the opportunity to be PM. Sometimes there is a limited number of opportunities or amount of influence available and women stepping up does mean that men must step down.

OP posts:
Grimbles · 11/03/2019 14:13

The thinking that a woman achieving something is depriving a man of that thing is part of the problem.