Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How do you cope with the hate?

34 replies

cherryontop00 · 01/12/2018 21:59

I usually post on tumblr rather than mumsnet but I hope people don't mind me posting here. I wanted advice from people who are older and probably know better than people my age (late teens).

For the most part, what I read doesn't bother me, but sometimes things get stuck in my head and I can't shake them off. I've read that "lesbians are just broken transmen" and that's stuck in my head and made me wonder if there's something wrong with me. I've been called 'creepy' and 'gross' for saying I wouldn't have sex with anyone with a penis. There's a post going around saying that same-sex attraction is disgusting (because it's transphobic) and that hurts me too. Then there's countless posts calling lesbians creepy vagina fetishists and that really gets to me because even though I know there's nothing wrong with being attracted to women, I really struggle already with feeling predatory or creepy in general when I'm around my crushes and to know then thousands of people genuinely believe I am a creep because I only like women makes it even harder for me to accept that I'm gay and that it's okay to be gay. People (on tumblr) act like the biggest crime is not having sex with a man and sometimes it makes me feel like there's something really really wrong with me because I'm not attracted to men at all.

Then, I also don't understand why radfems/terfs are hated so much. Again, for the most part it doesn't bother me (well, it bothers me that people talk so violently about hurting 'terfs', but it doesn't usually bother me on a personal level), but the other day someone called radfems "scum of the earth" and that's stuck with me. Why would you call someone who believes women don't have penises the scum of the earth, when there's rapists and murderers and abusers out there? There's people who bend over backwards to defend bdsm and prostitution, but the minute you say you don't support porn they act like you're the worst person on earth and tell you to kill yourself.

This is a vent more than actual feminist discussion, but I'm hoping someone has some advice. If I don't read anything then I don't get upset like this, but I think it's important to be in the loop with everything that's happening (+ I think it's important to read what TRAs have to say because I think it's important to hear both sides of the argument), so I don't want to just stop reading forums.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
R0wantrees · 06/12/2018 10:39

cherryontop00 Dr Julia Long's lecture worth watching:
'Transgenderism & Lesbian Erasure'

Have you seen Nanette by Hannah Gadsby?
www.theguardian.com/stage/2018/jul/16/hannah-gadsby-trauma-comedy-nanette-standup-netflix

Bubonicpanic · 06/12/2018 10:07

I don't think anyone should take that idiot boy in that link seriously. Transphobic is a completely meaningless word now.

Tell them to fuck off.

OP posts:
cherryontop00 · 04/12/2018 12:32

Hi all, sorry for not replying sooner. Thank you for your messages. I've been reading everything but was working out how to reply.

I do browse here and on r/gendercritical and r/truelesbians pretty regularly, but I like tumblr as a platform much more than anything forum-based so I'd rather not leave. I don't actively seek out TRA blogs or posts, I mostly follow other radfems, but sometimes posts appear on my dash of radfems debating TRAs or they post receipts, like this (66.media.tumblr.com/f04f74d2788e66af1d6857d99cca1b57/tumblr_pj63hego0V1w3ryav_540.jpg - I know someone asked for links). I'll have a look at afterellen though. I'm not in any real life groups or anything, I would like to be but I'm kind of scared to do anything in real life and those groups seem to mostly be older women and I don't know if I'd fit in.

@CottonTailRabbit, you're right that it's a form of self-harm, but it's the least harmful form I know. Ideally I wouldn't feel the need to punish myself for being gay, and I hope one day I'll accept myself more, but I'm not at that point yet and reading what TRAs have to say is so much better than the other things I could do/have done to myself.

OP posts:
hipsterfun · 03/12/2018 11:04

I hope the OP read the responses even if they didn’t feel able to post again.

Doobigetta · 02/12/2018 23:18

Stop allowing them to make you feel you owe them something. You don’t. You don’t need to listen to them, or understand them, or compensate for their inadequacy. You are not responsible for them or their problems and there is absolutely no need for you to engage with them. In real life, when you deal with people face to face, your instincts often tell you who to avoid. I think online we often switch off those instincts because we feel we need to be open minded, but those instincts are there to keep you safe and comfortable. The people saying this to you are likely creepy weird fuckers or bullies or both, and you’d cross the road to avoid them in real life without a second thought. There are loads of proper feminist women’s groups out there- online and increasingly reaching out into the real world now. Find those and stay away from the TRAs. There’s nothing wrong with you, so stay away from people who say there is.

GreenHats · 02/12/2018 22:40

it really is them not you that is wrong.The idea of lesbians being somehow broken transmen is abusive and homophobic. There is nothing creepy about being attracted to another woman.

Women's bodies are strong & soft & beautiful & awesome and the thought of mutilating them to try and mimic a man is horrific.

nellieellie · 02/12/2018 13:15

I’m in my mid fifties. I used to go on marches for gay rights before it was remotely ‘acceptable’. I’ve seen everyday sexism as a young woman and a middle aged woman. I’ve seen the cultural shift such that the sort of sexism visible in the 70s does not happen today. Yet there is STILL sexual harassment, and assault. And now, the attack on lesbians and women in general by the extreme trans ideology. All it is is the same old misogyny and homophobia dished up in a woke, lefty presentation so it brings in the academics, it brings in youth culture and it grooms.
Other posters have given good advice. Well done for questioning what you are seeing. Find yourself a healthier network. There are so many who find all this disturbing.

BrienneofTERF · 02/12/2018 11:50

OP it’s not you it’s them. They get off on the knowledge their words hurt and demean. So I’d suggest you stop feeding their needs by interacting with their bs.
Also people tend to be more extreme and outlandish online than in real life, I’ve been amazed to meet some rather kittenish people IRL who were depressingly hateful online.

PimmsnLemonade · 02/12/2018 11:48

I'm finding it tough as an older lesbian hearing all this stuff and seeing how much things are sliding backwards for us so I can only imagine what it must be like for younger lesbians now.

I always used to actively avoid reading stuff by Men's Rights Activists, incels homophobes etc but with this - although it's very similar - it's easy to get sucked in, and I feel that I need to follow it to a degree because it has become so influential and these attitudes aren't just on some small corner of the internet, these are increasingly the attitudes that seem to be more widely prevalent - particularly in LGBT circles, which should be the one place lesbians can take refuge from homophobic attitudes.

But still I think it's best to try to limit the time you spend online in those environments or - now you've seen it directly for yourself - to primarily hear what's going on through other forums e.g. I can follow what's going on through Mumsnet with links to what TRAs are doing but in a context where most of the posters here don't think lesbians are bigots and need to 're-educate' ourselves to have sex with people-with-penises.

I don't know if you are on any forums or sites which are pro-lesbian, but, if not, I'd recommended www.afterellen.com and www.reddit.com/r/truelesbians/

QuentinWinters · 02/12/2018 11:46

I know there's nothing wrong with being attracted to women, I really struggle already with feeling predatory or creepy in general when I'm around my crushes
Stop this right now. There is nothing predatory or creepy about being sexually attracted to someone and feeling nervous/,butterflies when they are around. That's a crush.
Predatory/creepy means not taking no for an answer and assuming your right to sexual gratification is the most important thing. Staring/ogling/groping/making lewd comments. You aren't doing that.
You can't help who you are attracted to and attraction is natural, not creepy.
Flowers

ErrolTheDragon · 02/12/2018 10:51

If you want to see both sides from a more helpful POV maybe look for some videos of Magdalen Berns taking down Riley.

I get the impression that TRA types are generally on the page of supporting all manner of fetishes and kinks.... so even if you for one moment accepted their ridiculous label why exactly is this the only one which seems objectionable? Clue.... check the rules of misogyny (2,3,5 I reckon)

https://www.reddit.com/r/GenderCritical/comments/6kkeni/theerulesoffmisogyny/

moofolk · 02/12/2018 10:08

Get off tumblr

ChewyLouie · 02/12/2018 08:30

Everytime you think of reading Tumblr think about the people behind the keyboards ie how many are predators and creeps projecting on to others. You don’t need to listen to their bile and revolting crap. Access spaces that support who you are to stay in the loop. Btw, I shouldn’t have to say this as it’s obvious but nothing at all ‘wrong’ with being a lesbian, perfectly natural.

quixote9 · 02/12/2018 08:20

That's new to me, and I thought I'd heard everything. I mean the business about same-sex attraction being transphobic.

There are obviously some trans people who think everything everwhere always is only about them. Narcissists to equal Trump. :huge shocked face here: Figured that dogpile had to be a one-off.

As Lumiere says, if you think that way, then trans is homophobic. You're instantly through the looking glass and into deep nonsense.

Stay away from that garbage is my advice. It'll mess with your mind and make you do stupid things sooner or later. Hanging with the cool kids isn't worth it.

SonEtLumiere · 02/12/2018 06:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ContentiousOne · 02/12/2018 06:48

Oh, it clicky linked itself!

ContentiousOne · 02/12/2018 06:45

Do you watch Arielle Scarella ? She's a lesbian youtuber - trans friendly, but also lesbian friendly. Here's a link to her latest video which you might find helpful. Sorry, don't know how to do clicky links.

I think it might be nice for you to hear another young lesbian call out the 'genital preference' shit.

IdaBWells · 02/12/2018 06:38

The ridiculous idea of lesbians being “vagina fetishists” for being sexually attracted to women is a new one created by very angry men who feel entitled to women’s bodies. A biological woman is more than her vagina she is female in every cell because of her chromosomes. It’s not just our wonderful vaginas that make us women it is every single bodily part of us. It would only be a man who would reduce a woman to her vagina. Never be ashamed because you are attracted to the unique bodily sexuality of women. Remember, your attraction is a SEXUAL attraction, not an attraction based on gender.

I would suggest you stay away from toxic online environments and hang out here and in similar spaces, also watch movies made by women and feminists. Be aware that so much of the media we consume is created by men with a male perspective and a male gaze.

I am not a lesbian but the development of so much recent ideology in the last couple of decades which denigrates lesbians makes me extremely angry and is so clearly misogynistic. It’s a good idea to reach out to older women because we know a lot of these ideas have developed during our lifetime and can tell you exactly where it came from and help you trace it’s history so you don’t believe this crap that “it’s always been this way” as a new orthodoxy.

SignMeUp · 02/12/2018 02:51

Every word in this thread! Verbatim, this would make a great article for some large well respected magazine. People need to hear it

Rattinghat · 02/12/2018 02:17

You've done your duty by reading both sides of the argument. The people writing that hateful stuff have severe psychological issues. You wouldn't read endless forums written by people with Munchausen syndrome, or that disease where people want their limbs amputated, because you would recognise that too much exposure to it would mess with your head. This is just the same.

Now stay off tumblr, get out in the world and enjoy hanging out with some real women.

CottonTailRabbit · 02/12/2018 01:51

I think it's important to read what TRAs have to say because I think it's important to hear both sides of the argument), so I don't want to just stop reading forums.

Why would, you, a lesbian hang out where homophobic loons are spouting their homophobic vitriol. The vast majority of the population would be appalled if they saw what was on those forums. Those loons are not showing you a side of a rational argument. They are homophobic, deeply lesbophobic. They are not normal. Stay away from them. Find some nice normal lovely lesbians to hang with instead.

Frequenting those forums is a form of self harm. If you are struggling with your lesbianism, seeking out the most lesbophobic corner of the internet is not helpful.

ErrolTheDragon · 02/12/2018 01:41

It sounds as though you really could use a break from reading, let alone engaging with, these homophobic misogynists.

You're welcome here. Thanks

Mrskeats · 02/12/2018 01:13

Just know it’s not you. They are the creepy ones. Your preferences are your business and they have no right to try and dictate.
The lesbians are broken trans men thing makes me furious on your behalf. Disgusting.

hipsterfun · 02/12/2018 01:09

It’s not you, it’s them. You’re fine Smile

Following the logic, I’d be a penis fetishist. I can live with that utter fucking nonsense devised by people with issues so huge as to be visible from space Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread