This is NOT a woman

This is why no trans should go to jail ever. An identity parade would be a far greater act of literal violence than rape or assault.

It reminds me of this story about a bunch of men in wigs beating some poor bloke up. Reported completely uncritically as a violent crime by women.

Just piss off- this a ridiculous situation.

Nona don’t be silly, why would there be a need for an identity parade? It never happens, remember? Silly mummy getting all confused. Everyone knows being trans means you are no threat to anyone at all.

gendercritter "I can imagine there are certain men who are getting off on this manipulation of people."

Oh, absolutely. Possibly the only time they feel they have power. Possibly a feeling that is quite addictive.

Bump

This makes me so angry. The person is not a woman - this is probably another hilarious ‘prank’.

On the upside witch’s comment about her cat made me really laugh.

Can't they do him for lying to the police?

And then if the witness is asked if the person they saw was there and they say "yes, it was the man with the beard" do they charge that person, or are they expected to throw out the statement on the basis of misgendering? What if they say "the one with the beard", is that acceptable?

Given that this was in the USA the police there put out something called an APB (all points bulletin I believe) which is a brief summary. If in this case it was to say, for example "white female, 5ft8, brown hair" and so on then everyone would be looking at entirely the wrong potential suspects.

I’m genuinely interested in the identify line up question.

What do the police do? If the suspect says that they are a woman do they pull in five other women of similar height and colouring?

Because given the fact that the witness almost certainly described the person they saw as male then that would make the line up unfair surely.

But then if the person insists they are “female” to the point that they claim entitlement to a women’s prison surely the line up should be female.

If you are claiming “trans women are women” how do you resolve this problem?

Has this actually come up in law enforcement procedures yet? Does anyone know?

I can imagine there are certain men who are getting off on this manipulation of people. The power we are giving them. It makes me feel physically sick

In the meantime the male criminal is throwing a temper tantrum because he wants ‘other women’ to stand with him, in order to feel validated
More ladyfeelz than sense I guess.

SelfID - how's that working out again? Swimmingly!

Kadin is lucky he is not black.

I wonder if the 'I am a woman' thing is a prank too.

Little shithead.

It’s not meaningless though Destiny.

Everyone knows what a woman is.

Everyone can tell the difference between a woman or a man (even very small children)

“I called them with questions because it clearly looked more like a man [my bold] Mmm! More honest than Fox, who called him "suspect / person"

Surely someone has to realise that this sin't sustainable in the real world!

Woman? Yep that word is meaningless.

Yes u too would like to know how the description went down.

No one has ever answered that. When people go missing or commit a crime what do they tell the police or hospitals they are phoning asking if someone has been brought in...

OFFS! More stunned than stunning.

That's one stunning and brave woman there.

Showing a picture seems to be the standard media way of saying "obviously we know this person is male but we're not allowed to tell you that using words".

I wish they had done that with the NASA furry.

Comment after comment of sexist and misogynistic tripe (bitch, twat, silly/stupid girl etc), when I know it would have been different if Naomi's picture had been shown (and their posts on Mastadon right after the event).

I’d love to see the identity parade.

“Now if all you gentlemen could just line up each side that ‘lady’.”

“What lady?”

“The one with the three day stubble” 😳

“Wot?” 😕

In the meantime the male criminal is throwing a temper tantrum because he wants ‘other women’ to stand with him, in order to feel validated

Destinysdaughter
Can you imagine the identity parade??
How would that work! Either have people who match the "woman" description making th accused stand out or people who look similar to the accused but dont match the description

Showing a picture seems to be the standard media way of saying "obviously we know this person is male but we're not allowed to tell you that using words".

That would be funny if this whole distortion of reality wasn't so bloody disturbing.

That ain't no lady. Though the police walked the Fanno Creek trail what they found at the end of it was still not a lady. Even my cat can tell the difference between a man and a woman by voices alone and she only has a brain the size of a walnut.