Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The boys have predators on their clothes, the girls have prey.

80 replies

dinodora · 18/07/2018 07:49

sonshinemagazine.com/magazine/animals-aggression-and-entitlement

An interesting analysis of high st children's clothes.

My boy does love sharks buand he would say they're prey to humans - I must say I'd have struggled with many of the girls clothes these days as I'd have preferred the dinosaurs.

Regularish poster, I've nc.

OP posts:
dinodora · 18/07/2018 21:36

Mogleflop the only 'trans' child I ever met was later dx autistic. It was very much the love of long hair and the whole Disney princess thing. He loved colour and swish.

Interestingly a friend's autistic child also went through a strictly ballroom loving phase around 4-5. Asked for a ball gown for Xmas. Had never watched tv till that prog; he didn't really follow the plots of most programmes.

Knowing about asd in a professional sense id day some children would be drawn to girls outdoors due to the sensory element.

Gruffalo, I do feel the same sometimes. I also had a pang of 'something' when I knew I was having a second boy - I do like some girls clothes probably due to colours and style, (and the sensory element, which I do think anyone gets if they wear a lovely dress or blouse etc. Men's clothes tend to be less flowy and sensoryish)

OP posts:
Mogleflop · 18/07/2018 20:13

I'm sure I've read that autistic girls are more likely to want to transition than neurotypical girls. Thinking about it based on this article, a tiny facet of this could be the sensory issues around clothes.

wejammin · 18/07/2018 20:10

I have really strict rules for myself when dressing DS and DD - for DS no blue, vehicles or predators, for DD no pink, flowers or hearts. I do this because it does make me think about the messages that are portrayed by their clothes, to each other and the world. It also means that I dont get The Rage quite so much at the clothes grandparents buy because it's just the odd thing that is overly gendered (2 year olds tshirt with fake handbag containing lipstick anyone?)
DD is nearly 4 and point blank refuses dresses or skirts, only likes underpants and shorts have to have pockets. My DM is convinced she's "going to be trans" (massive eyeroll) - I just think she's sensible and not been brainwashed by the limitations of gendered fashion

GruffaloStick · 18/07/2018 19:56

I hasn't made the predator connection, interesting article. When I was little I was obsessed with dinosaurs and found it baffling as an adult that they are considered a boy thing.

I was very insistent when pregnant with DD that she wouldn't be dressed head to toe in pink and frills much to everyone's horror when I knitted green and grey cardigans etc.
Shes nearly 2 and still wears lots of practical bright clothes and we avoid slogans but what I struggle with is that I think she looks 'cutest' in pastel and pinks and those seen as stereotypical girls clothes. I feel drawn to then when dressing her and if I'm completely honest I like it when she looks 'pretty'. This completely goes against my views as a feminist, I know it's related to social conditioning, I know it doesn't matter a jot as long as she is dressed practically but it's still there.
Not sure why I've typed all this, just musing out loud so to speak

VulvaOfSteel · 18/07/2018 14:16

@mogleflop
Shock

mustn't google

OrchidInTheSun · 18/07/2018 13:40

Thanks for this OP - that looks like a really interesting website. And very good article :)

LastOneDancing · 18/07/2018 13:35

weighted - I need that 'I'm not bossy...' shirt for my DS1 Smile

Hellbent I interpteted the shirt as trying to make the exact point you raise, although perhaps it can be read two ways.

I actually quite like Morrison's clothes for boys, because they do occasionally have green, yellow and orange colours clothes, away from the sea of grey and blue. I find Asda the worst offender for shit like 'Its a boy thing' slogans. I can't abide them.

I also cannot comprehend why characters need to be sex-specific on clothing. Why can't Sky be pictured with the rest of the original PP pups on a unisex tee? It's bizarre.

ErrolTheDragon · 18/07/2018 13:32

My DD would have chosen the grey octopus every time. We ignored the girl/boy divisions (well, sometimes not so much 'ignored' as loudly derided). She had pretty dresses etc too, no limitations.

dinodora · 18/07/2018 13:29

THE FECKING PATRIARCHY!

that's why.

OP posts:
SardinesAreYum · 18/07/2018 13:24

Oh re the fabrics - adult clothes and Unexpected Transparency!

How many have been caught out (once - and never again!) by something that looked solid in the articifial shop lighting and in daylight is sheer or even see through?

Why do they do that? How many women want to wear transparent clothes? Not many FGS. It's so frustrating.

Yesterday I was walking to work and a woman in a lovely white dress went past, on her phone, striding along, obviously office ready. I could easily see her bra and pants through her dress in the sunshine. She may have known this, but more likely she did not. I was tempted to ask her but didn't as too quick and it would have been a bit weird of me. Just reminded me of a time my friend wore a skirt that was transparent, didn't realise, no pants, in a job with loads of men there (betting shop). She was mortified.

Why do they do this? They KNOW that we often won't see what it looks like in sunshine. It's almost like it's deliberate but I can't quite believe that. But otherwise - why?

WeightedCompanionCube · 18/07/2018 13:23

Hell glad I could cause offence to someone.

dinodora · 18/07/2018 13:15

Yes..... but....

The teeth are still sharper on the boy's sharks.

The boys have predators on their clothes, the girls have prey.
The boys have predators on their clothes, the girls have prey.
The boys have predators on their clothes, the girls have prey.
OP posts:
silkybear · 18/07/2018 12:38

I noticed Boden have a decent range of girls clothes at the moment...dinosaur and shark dresses included...sadly a bit pricey for me but I think they are heading in the right direction.

dinodora · 18/07/2018 12:33

And the girls get burnt arms.

OP posts:
dinodora · 18/07/2018 12:33

So girls go to the beach to eat ice cream and wear bows; boys go to surf.

OP posts:
dinodora · 18/07/2018 12:32

I'm sure everyone else knew this but I didn't, that let clothes be clothes have a website: Grin

https://www.letclothesbeclothes.co.uk

In a group I'm in a parent was complaining that there were 2 octopi related t shirts in a shop, the girl's one distinctly different to the boys one. Her daughter loves octopuses. (Apologies if anyone knows this group, I'm keeping it anonymous as possible.)

The boys have predators on their clothes, the girls have prey.
OP posts:
MoltenLasagne · 18/07/2018 12:27

I hate how flimsy fabric is for standard women's / girl's clothes until you get to more premium brand. I was looking for work shirts and the vast majority I'd need to wear something underneath. How is that practical? It really winds me up that shops like Next have good quality men's clothes in natural fibres and their women's clothes are almost entirely created in man made, staticky, flimsy fabrics. Shopping for toddler clothes, it seems this trend starts as soon as babies are out of baby grows.

Hellbentwellwent · 18/07/2018 12:26

Sorry typos, not dad... dd

Hellbentwellwent · 18/07/2018 12:26

weighted
I've got a few slogan tops for my girls - one that's "I'm not bossy - I have leadership skills" and there's another floating around a laundry pile somewhere with "forget princess I want to be a scientist"
I just wanted to point out that although these are better, no one would ever use bossy as a descriptor for a man, assertive sure but bossy is primarily a slur used against women who dare to have their own opinions on how things should be done, so while it’s an improvement on t shorts that day ‘cute’ or some other such drivel there’s still an implied sense that girls who are assertive are less than boys who are.same with the princess scientist one, boys don’t have to reject a fluffy label to adopt a more ambitious one, they just gets the ambitious one by default.
That’s not a criticism of your choice in tshirts for your dad just pointing out that that’s the best of a bad bunch and even the best on offer by manufacturers still carry implied inferiority for the female sex

grasspigeons · 18/07/2018 12:24

SardinesAreYum - ask most uk men to wear speedos to see how little they like being on display - its just a bikini bottom for men.

PookyHook - agree with the cherry thing as well, i can't believe this is an accident.

i hadn't noticed the predator thing, just the boring colours and generally more aspirational slogans. But thinking about it the only animal prints we have on clothes are sharks and tigers.

PookyHook · 18/07/2018 12:17

Has anyone else noticed the cherries?

My dd is 4 and has just moved up to the older girls age category of clothing. I went shopping for her recently and I searched the whole shopping centre but nearly every shop had clothes that were far too grown up looking for her.

In several different shops I found clothes that I initially thought looked ok, but then found they was covered in images of cherries. I don't know if it's just me, but I feel that there is a sexualised message in images of cherries on little girls clothes, as if it's advertising their virginity as a cherry waiting to be popped.

In the end I bought her clothes in mothercare from the little bird range.

SardinesAreYum · 18/07/2018 12:12

We looked in the boys section as well obv but DD is sizable of bum and that didn't work either.

DD1 prefers boys clothes always has - confortable, decent coverage.

Girls clothes are so revealing, women's too. I think that the average man would feel really really vulnerable if he suddenly had to dress like teen girls / women are epxected to / what is fashionable etc.

SardinesAreYum · 18/07/2018 12:10

4 year old girls are not demanding to be dressed like daisy duke in ting hotpants.

Very few parents are keen either.

We went shopping for shorts for DD (8) and in all the shops they only had stuff in the girls section that would have had her arse hanging out.

In the end we got a load of stuff from JD sports Grin

SardinesAreYum · 18/07/2018 12:09

Where does this come from?

It's like in the 90s when we all had low-rise muffin tops... I looked and looked and looked for jeans that came up higher and there simply weren't any, so I had to buy muffin top ones. Why does this happen?

then they say it's driven by demand Confused

dinodora · 18/07/2018 12:00

Yep sardines.

Several mums of girls have been saying to me that their preschool daughters sit in their push chairs in their dresses often "showing every thing off" and pants that are too small....

If I'd had a dd I think I'd have done the same and got boys pants for as long as possible.

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread