Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Commercial surrogacy

28 replies

53rdWay · 03/07/2018 21:39

It looks from the Tom Daley threads like a lot of people weren't aware of what commercial surrogacy is or why any feminists would have a problem with it, or both. So I thought it'd be useful to share some links I've found informative about the issue. Please share others!

Katha Pollitt: The Strange Case of Baby M (this is from 1998, and it is brilliant. "Goods can be distributed according to ability to pay or need. People can’t.")

Julie Bindel: Commercial surrogacy breeds exploitation, abuse and misery

Julie Bindel again: India's surrogacy clinics

Katja Ekis Ekman: All surrogacy is exploitation - the world should follow Sweden's ban

Regula Staempfli: Surrogate motherhood is not work, it is exploitation

Glosswitch/Victoria Smith: The feminist history of surrogacy: should pregnancy give a woman rights over a baby?

OP posts:
UpstartCrow · 03/07/2018 22:15

I'm going to add a link about how poor mothers are being exploited for their breast milk. I remember being constantly thirsty and hungry when I breast fed. Women in the UK can expect their employer to provide them with somewhere to lie down and rest when they are breast feeding. But these breast milk farms just provide women with tables and chairs, and their own babies appear to be going hungry.

An Example of Capitalism Literally Milking the Poor
www.stopsurrogacynow.com/an-example-of-capitalism-literally-milking-the-poor/#sthash.Xf6VYecR.dpbs

Bi11yOneMate · 03/07/2018 22:11

I was all in favour of surrogacy, having gay relatives, until a family member adopted a baby, and I did a lot of reading of early trauma.
There is, I'm told, fairly robust evidence to say that removing a baby from its mother is a pretty severe trauma. No matter how young the baby. And should only be done in the child's best interests.
And then I became a mother myself and saw how much my newborn KNEW me, and preferred me over others.
And then I happened across an article about surrogates in India and how they are treated.
And I'm now wholly against surrogacy, except maybe within a close knit family. Maybe.

I think to be anti surrogacy one needs to have read around it, as the instinct is to go "aww, how lovely".

stillathing · 03/07/2018 21:57

Thanks OP. This is an area where I can feel my opinion changing as I begin to locate it as an issue related to the rights of women and especially children. With a v possibly gay DC I had been all for it in an unthinking kind of way.

There's a growing body of research on the importance of the environment in utero including that the baby begins to be attached to its mother from before birth. They come out preferring their mother's voices for instance. (I love that people manage to conduct experiments around this kind of thing!)

No problem at all with the idea of gay parents, obviously great if they can adopt but I know that's hard currently. Could getting used to shaping families differently work? Gay parents joining forces with lesbian parents for example or with single women who were choosing to go it alone? Does the hetero model have to be only way?