Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Is Transphobia Actually Sexism?

177 replies

CiderIsRealAle · 25/06/2018 02:09

(NC not new poster)

When a person is discriminated against or bullied because they present or behave in a way that defies sex sterotypes, it is a manifestation of sexism (often with homophobia thrown in).

This means the hastily added and confusing protected characteristic of 'gender reassignment' in the Equality Act is unnecessary, because sex already covers it.

For example. If someone is male by birth but changes to a female name and presents in ways associated with women - long hair, make up, dresses, etc and their employer insists they dress 'like a man' - that is sex discrimination and a double standard because they would accept a woman wearing the same clothes to work.

So how about removing 'gender reassignment' from the EA protected characteristics and raising awareness that a male (or female) who is being compelled to adhere to sex stereotypes is experiencing sexism?

How about transgenderism/transsexualism comes under the protected category of religion or belief?

Hate crime on the basis of sex (for not confirming to sex stereotypes) could be included too, which would mean that both misogyny and what is currently considered 'transphobia' would also be covered.

This would mean everyone is protected, including women, and no one's rights are trampled and if the now not needed GRA (gay marriage allowed + transsexualism is a protected belief/religion) the extra bonus is that the law would be based on reality again.

OP posts:
blackdoggotmytongueagain · 25/06/2018 02:53

It’s an interesting idea. It won’t be tolerated by the trans community, as snappity has demonstrated though - they have no desire to have their rights protected under their birth sex - they want the legal right to have the fiction of a sex change to be their protected characteristic. No law that protects biological reality will be tolerated, which is why they are so upset when organizations attempt to uphold the EA exemptions and segregate by sex.

Snappity · 25/06/2018 02:38

So, in summary, you want to remove gender reassignment as a protected characteristic in the Equality Act 2010 and get rid of the Gender Recognition Act. Quite apart from making it impossible to change birth certificates this manifestly reduces discrimination protection for trans people. One quick example - the ability to bring complaints of indirect discrimination would be wiped out.