Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Asking people to use preferred pro-nouns is abelist and discriminatory - what affects your ability to comply?

397 replies

DJLippy · 18/06/2018 16:15

I wanted to start a thread because I am really going to struggle to stay within Mumsnet talk guidelines.

I struggle to use preferred pro-noun's with those who I genuinely don't believe are the sex they claim to be. Because I have dyspraxia pro-noun policing creates a barrier for my fluency. I have to stop and think to change the pro-noun. I can go back and edit my post for 'mistakes' to comply but I miss out on pro-nouns (again because of my disability.)

I have spoken to those with autism and they've told me similar things - that they genuinely find it difficult to lie.

I also think that it is difficult for those for whom English is a second language. Un-learning sub-conscious grammar structures is hard enough for English people - I can only imagine how much more difficult it must be for those from other countries.

I think this is a real issue when Mumsnet creates a three strike rule. I have stopped posting since the new rule change because I honestly and truly do not mean to break rules - I can't abide by this code and I don't always have the mental energy to police my sub-conscious like this.

Does anybody else have a reason (other than the fact that they don't agree) that they find it difficult to follow the new language laws? Is it right that social media platforms and public institutions create more barriers for those who are already disadvantaged?

OP posts:
Moussemoose · 18/06/2018 19:32

I am fully supportive of the disabled community and would love to see a more open approach to communication.

My issue is that some posters started off by saying "I can't do this because of X". I spend a lot of time trying to break down barriers. Colleagues try to get young people work placements and are told "no because they can't do X".

This is often not the case and people can be taught, can change and can adapt and can work successfully. So when people say "I can't do this because of X it feeds into discrimination".

X makes it more difficult but it can be done. Now if you don't want to do it because you object on other grounds - go for it, just be careful.

If you read my posts I'm trying to break down fixed ways of thinking about disability and allow people to develop skills.

thebewilderness · 18/06/2018 19:30

I'm berating no one.

If you read the title of the thread I think you may come to the realization that you are berating people for talking about the problems they are having instead of "adapting" ass you think they should.
Usually we talk about the problem to seek a solution. Short circuiting the process is ill advised. I would think, as a person who works with children, you would know that.

RiverTam · 18/06/2018 19:28

Sorry, should say on the subject of preferred pronouns, not on ableism.

Cascade220 · 18/06/2018 19:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

RiverTam · 18/06/2018 19:28

@Moussemoose you might want to take a look at what Camille Paglia has to say on this subject, she’s got it bang on.

TerfsUp · 18/06/2018 19:27

Or perhaps, for once, neurotypicals could adapt to us?

Cascade220 · 18/06/2018 19:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TerfsUp · 18/06/2018 19:25

It would be so lovely if the non-autistics, with their supposedly superior empathy and communication skills, could adapt to us some of the time.

I always say that I'm not disabled by my condition; I'm disabled by society's attitude toward my condition.

Shut up and adjust. Shut up and adjust more. And more. And more.

BeyondSceptical · 18/06/2018 19:25

Mousse, I am not here to represent the autistic community - I'm here for me, just like you are

thebewilderness · 18/06/2018 19:25

It astonishes me that we teach lying to appease authority from the earliest age as a good thing and then depending on the circumstances punish people for lying. All part of the dominance dance but don't dare name it that.

CircleSquareCircleSquare · 18/06/2018 19:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TerfsUp · 18/06/2018 19:24

Perhaps, but would you ever impose a 'three strikes and you're out' on students with these difficulties?

I don't know about MM but MNHQ is certainly willing to throw those of with autism under the bus, despite claiming its support for minorities. Good to know that feelings are more important than supporting people with disabilities.

And thanks for the extra cognitive load, MNHQ - like I don't have enough to do, trying to act neuro-typical in my daily life.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 18/06/2018 19:24
BeyondSceptical · 18/06/2018 19:24

Where are the rules making the world lie for my fucking feelings?

JoyTheUnicorn · 18/06/2018 19:24

I would hope when you work with autistic young people you wouldn’t be insisting they lie.
You wouldn’t be working with my child if that was the case!
Recognising the two sexes is one of the basic things that humans do. You can’t force people to ignore that, and given that one of those sexes has proven over the years to be more dangerous than the other, it should be a safeguarding issue to override such a basic and fundamental difference when teaching anyone.

Cascade220 · 18/06/2018 19:23

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

zen1 · 18/06/2018 19:22

However, when you start to use learning difficulties as a reason for not using them you might end up backing yourself into a corner.

I find this post inherently disabilist. I have a child (nearly 10) who has a severe language disorder and autism. He is unable to linguistically distinguish between ‘he’ and ‘she’ and might never be able to. Friends, family and school staff are frequently ‘misgendered’. God forbid he encounters anyone with such a lack of understanding when he becomes an adult.

TerfsUp · 18/06/2018 19:21

Yep. The old medical model of disability - we're broken and not as good as other people so we have to jump through hoops so society will accept us.

ErrolTheDragon · 18/06/2018 19:21

even if they are not perfect they can adapt

Perhaps, but would you ever impose a 'three strikes and you're out' on students with these difficulties?

Moussemoose · 18/06/2018 19:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TerfsUp · 18/06/2018 19:20

So how would you explain to a person with autism that they are expected to lie in order to spare feelings? Many autistic people would find this highly distressing.

Yep. I didn't have any say about being born autistic and it has affected every aspect of my life. Now I am being expected to lie to protect another person's feelings. OTOH, it is another way that society expects me to adapt to it because I'm broken.

MsMcWoodle · 18/06/2018 19:19

I object because it's lying and morally wrong.
It goes against my deeply held beliefs.

ThisisSparta · 18/06/2018 19:18

Sorry I came on to post about how all these new ‘woke’ policies are discriminating against disabled people and got annoyed at the rubbish Mousse was spouting. Off to calm down for a bit

Emmags0309 · 18/06/2018 19:18

I rarely post but I can’t believe i’m reading some of the things here.

To the poster who is telling people with autism that they should try harder, you are telling them to talk in a way that, for them, is lying. You are asking them to say things that, fundamentally, they do not believe. It would be like me trying to teach my autistic cousin to tell the world that she believes in a particular religion, just to keep people of that religion happy. It would be impossible.

dianebrewster · 18/06/2018 19:18

Religion / belief is a protected characteristic - I am a Quaker, speaking the truth is central to my religious belief. Used to drive the dc mad as I would never 'fib' to get them off the hook with school. Where does that leave me if I am compelled to call men "she"?

I will try to be strategic in my use of language and avoid pronouns, I will not tell a lie, so this makes it very hard for me to speak the truth.