Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

A bare breast on a t-shirt at a conference

330 replies

poopsqueak · 18/05/2018 21:18

I was at a conference yesterday with many speakers.

The audience was of a digital nature.

One speaker came on stage with a t-shirt with a woman with a bare breast on (faded and 'artsy') and I didn't think much of it. He was 35, male and talking about an organisation he had founded. The talk was very interesting.

When the next speaker started the conference organiser came on stage and apologised for the t-shirt of the previous speaker and said he hadn't seen it prior to the speaker going on stage and mentioned a 'Twitter incident'

When the next speaker started half the audience were on their phones seeing what the 'incident' was. I found this very rude to the speaker who was speaking while lots of people were looking at their phones.

Turns out a person had left in the prior speaker posting on Twitter saying that they were 'shaking with anger' at the t-shirt and 'crying in the toilet'. They used the official conference hash so people could see. People began discussing and the person who was upset sent a lot of tweets about it.

I'm really in two minds about this. I don't think the t-shirt was great, but the guy said he was jet lagged and had come straight from the plane so maybe hadn't changed. I feel torn between the sides of a speaker wearing a sexualised t shirt on stage and what I see as a another person who I think has had gross overreaction that has cause upset for the conference runners.

I feel like the guy who ran the conference apologised as soon as he could and did what needed.

To further confuse me, the person who was upset then accosted the guy with the shirt outside and they had words. The person then tweeted that they had felt victimised by the shirt wearers language.

Really I just want some others perspectives on this incident as I am I two minds. I am all for (and talk actions to ensure) the progression of women in tech, but feel the slightly hysterical reaction to a t-shirt mire the message? What do you think?

OP posts:
LaSqrrl · 22/05/2018 09:58

That is not what you were doing though OP, both in the OP and subsequent comments. You were berating her for being upset at blatant misogyny.

You need to review your attitude towards the position you hold. Because it does not seem to be on the side of women in your industry.

And yes, you should be defensive and upset. You were in the wrong on this. Very much so.

poopsqueak · 22/05/2018 09:43

Oh god, give over. Ah yes I shall resign from my position because someone on Mumsnet shouted me down.

People are allowed to have differing opinions and take differing actions to yourself (and myself) and THATS OK.

We are also allowed to critical evaluate both men (with shitty t-shirts and attitudes) and women.

OP posts:
LaSqrrl · 22/05/2018 09:39

^ THIS, AAK, just THIS

AngryAttackKittens · 22/05/2018 08:40

Can we talk about the "this woman is making me and other women look bad and that's why we can't have nice things" thing that the OP and a few others are doing? This reaction comes up a lot and leads to a lot of throwing other women under the bus, and I think it's important to think your way through (ie that lurkers might benefit from reading that conversation).

TheNavigator · 22/05/2018 08:34

I have to agree, having read through the thread, the reaction that has seemed most inappropriate and has shocked me the most is the OP's reaction - when she claims to be on a women in tech board!!!

OP - you have chosen, consistently, to scrutinise and criticise how a woman reacts to blatant sexism in your industry rather than focus on the actual sexism. Why are you on a women in tech board? Is it to stop female colleagues getting uppity, because you surely aren't their ally.

LaSqrrl · 22/05/2018 08:27

And fucking shame on you OP, for being on a women's board and all. Please resign, let someone who actually CARES be given a shot in the role. You clearly do not. You only care whether this woman's reaction was deemed 'appropriate' or not.

You are failing your duty of care.

LaSqrrl · 22/05/2018 08:25

OMG, are we back to the woman's reaction of blatant misogyny again? Clearly groundhog day.

This man was never going to change his opinion, no matter how nicely a woman might have asked him. The event organisers made a weak apology and that was that, so clearly they don't give a fuck either.

Very true, Assassinated.

My gawd, I feel like screaming - "misogyny, what misogyny, only fucking everywhere!!!" about a million times on this.

What part of 'inappropriate' do people not get? Sexism and obvious displays of male supremacy are NOT OK! Fuck, I feel like I am screaming it out for those in the slow seats, I really do. This is 101 shit.

AngryAttackKittens · 22/05/2018 07:36

Well she's achieved a wider audience for his actions so more women can realise he's misogynist and will double down on it if called out. Handy to know if you were ever considering working for or hiring him/his company.

This is definitely the kind of information I'd like to have about the potential new boss before my first day at the office. Ideally before the interview in fact so I can probe a bit and see if whatever advantages the job might offer outweigh the unpleasantness of being forced to interact with someone so boorish.

poopsqueak · 22/05/2018 07:34

Not entirely sure assassinated.

I have put a comment on a feedback form I was emailed, I assume she has done the same.

A couple of people also mentioned it on twitter before she commented so I also assume they have mentioned it too.

OP posts:
AssassinatedBeauty · 22/05/2018 01:48

Well she's achieved a wider audience for his actions so more women can realise he's misogynist and will double down on it if called out. Handy to know if you were ever considering working for or hiring him/his company.

This man was never going to change his opinion, no matter how nicely a woman might have asked him. The event organisers made a weak apology and that was that, so clearly they don't give a fuck either.

Do we know that she hasn't also put in an official complaint?

LightofaSilveryMoon · 22/05/2018 01:47

Ofgs, BeefyCakes - do you realise that you are shooting the messenger, and ignoring the message here? Woman gets pissed off and upset by the dickhead and his pervert T-shirt, but it's the woman's fault??!! Really!!??

LightofaSilveryMoon · 22/05/2018 01:37

If the wanker is not changing his T-shirt or apologising, then he is indeed a wanker of the lowest order.

BeefyCakes · 22/05/2018 01:24

He's obviously a cunt for wearing the t-shirt, did he not look in a mirror at any time between putting the t-shirt on and stepping on to the stage to speak? He could have turned the t-shirt inside out...

Saying that, I've read the Twitter thread from the person who found this t-shirt so offensive that she was shaking and crying, obviously she is entitled to her opinions. However I am also entitled to an opinion, and in my opinion to use the phrase 'victim shaming' in relation to a boob on a t-shirt is just totally out of proportion. I am a rape survivor, and things like this in my opinion just totally minimises what victims of sexual assault go through. Obviously I don't know her history.

Instead of tweeting about it and how she was shaking and crying, surely handling it like an adult and going through official channels to complain would have been better? It's just a disproportionate reaction.

What has it achieved? He hasn't changed his opinion on wearing t-shirts like that in fact judging by his response he's locked down and is not changing the t-shirt or apologising because of this reaction. He's posted the good old Stephen Fry meme about offense.

Rach5l · 22/05/2018 00:38

I just think any bloke in any situation wearing that t-shirt is a dick and I'd disregard anything he had to say 🤷‍♀️

LightofaSilveryMoon · 22/05/2018 00:17

A man wore a sexualised image of a woman on his T-shirt (!WTF!!) when addressing a conference (!!!) involving both men and women. And taking into account women's continuing inequality at work, and sexual harrassment.

The fucker was clearly goading.

I salute the woman who called the pervert out.

MapleSap1 · 21/05/2018 23:50

As a survivor of sexual assault I also really took issue with her later on twitter for using the term 'victim shaming

She actually believes she's a "victim"?
Jesus. Hmm

poopsqueak · 21/05/2018 23:48

What? I called it that so it could be very clear what I was talking about. A bare breast on a t-shirt at a conference. I don't know how I could have made it clearer.

You might have noticed I posted the evening after the conference. After the incident actually, as we were notified by the conference organiser when he apologised before the next speaker. So the incident was kind of over when I realised it had happened.

My colleagues and I did discuss it quite a lot after the conference actually and I put some comments about the t shirt in a feedback mechanism afterwards.

I'm not sure what you are getting at tbh.

OP posts:
sillage · 21/05/2018 23:16

Did poopsqueak ever say why she didn't say anything to anyone at the conference before choosing instead to post about it here online?

"Parts of bodies not a whole person"

Sort of how poopsqueak (aka bullshitter?) titled this thread 'A bare breast on a t-shirt at a conference'?

Tinkletinklelittlebat · 21/05/2018 22:04

Oh Jesus wept I can see why it’s out of order and I’m the fucking MRA....

Grin
metrorider · 21/05/2018 21:53

When musing on this thread, potplant2's earlier post bubbled to my mind's surface: [being objectified and humiliated in public] destroyed my enthusiasm and enjoyment for that talk, but I put on a professional face and got through it. And so your enthusiasm for the subject matter won't have shone through to your audience and got them fired up about it. It would have done if you'd been introduced as a human and not a bit of skirt. This is where everyone in an industry is harmed by sexism: women do not and cannot do their best work when they are constantly navigating a hostile culture, and this impacts everyone around them.

poopsqueak · 21/05/2018 20:56

Ok, that's a fair point. We don't know everyone's history.

OP posts:
metrorider · 21/05/2018 20:53

@poopsqueak Actually metro I'm going to have to correct you. Because the 'crying and shaking' tweet and the 'I've had to run out and hide in the toilets' was during the time he was speaking so she couldn't have confronted him by then.

Fair enough, I stand corrected. We don't know why the tshirt alone was so upsetting to her, but one of the reasons why most workplaces don't allow soft porn tshirts as business attire is because we don't know everyone's past and so we try to make the place safe and comfortable for everyone. I suspect that fear of consequences of speaking out could have been a major driver of her emotional reaction, and given how he treated her and the reactions from some people on here, I would say her fear was justified.

One of my colleagues made a pun about rape a few weeks back and another colleague instantly called him out on it and he apologised. I stiffened and froze at my desk because it reminded me of a prior assault that I don't want to think about other than on my terms, and had to leave and sit in the staff room for a few minutes, and that was with someone instantly calling him out and him reacting well to that. Had no one called him out, I don't know how I would have reacted. I don't think I would have felt OK calling it out.

Because of this experience of my own, I'm sympathetic to the complainant and I really don't think we should police her.

WeAreGerbil · 21/05/2018 20:26

I think it's a big deal because overreactions like that cause people (both men and women) to switch off from the actual problem. They see the reaction, not the action. They roll eyes. They do not pay attention because the person talking about the problem is seen as dramatic.

But you could counter this in the many ways that other posters have by focusing back on the T shirt rather than continually drawing attention to her behaviour, which is utterly irrelevant to the T shirt being sexist. And to be fair without her reaction we probably wouldn't have been aware of it and yet more misogynist behaviour would have gone by unremarked on.

AssassinatedBeauty · 21/05/2018 19:59

So if that's how you feel why make it the issue that you decide to focus on? In your understanding of it, you're drawing people's attention to the reaction you disapprove of and inviting people to discuss it. Thus further distancing people from the actual issue. Which is much much more of a problem than this one woman and her behaviour which you don't like.

And from my experience, people who roll their eyes and dismiss women as hysterical will not take them seriously if they react in a way which is approved of. Because they're sexist.

poopsqueak · 21/05/2018 19:50

*sounding intimidating

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.