Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Peak Guardian - Guardian employs transperson to say 'white feminism is just too racist and misogynistic'

35 replies

TerfinUSA · 19/04/2018 05:59

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/19/as-a-trans-woman-of-colour-my-words-are-met-with-silence

'Comments are pre-moderated', naturally, to ensure those nasty white feminists don't say anything misogynist.

OP posts:
NotTerfNorCis · 19/04/2018 07:36

It's strange how #Metoo has become so warped it's now associated with criticism of 'privileged' women by men.

hackmum · 19/04/2018 07:20

"Because of white supremacy, white women are more likely to be believed, validated, supported and make worthier victims when disclosing abuse and oppression."

Try telling that to the young woman in the Ulster rugby case.

TerfinUSA · 19/04/2018 06:32

So basically the precis of the article is that this bloke junkee.com/kirin-j-callinan-dickhead/137317 behaves like a dickhead, and the author complained, and this act of complaining about something that happened when you weren't there or even in the same city is somehow a metoo moment.

There is nothing they can't appropriate.

OP posts:
TerfinUSA · 19/04/2018 06:28

excerpt:

"It’s now been three months since my statement regarding a fellow musicians’ removal from a festival lineup. I spoke out about the licence we give men to act without reprisal, and how it reinforces the behaviours that lead to the stories of #MeToo. It’s not about any specific action, but when we cannot question the intent, or validate the emotions resultant of any man’s actions, it truly shows how much power men have over us. I was chastised, threatened, told I was overreacting; I learned that words leave a trauma of their own.

Since then, I have read more about some incredible activists. One that stuck with me was Tarana Burke (founder of #MeToo movement) "

"When I needed my industry’s support, I was met with “closed door conversations” – people who would be happy to privately support me but publicly sit silent and be complicit. "

"#MeToo stories of cisgender white women have been the most amplified so far. Because of white supremacy, white women are more likely to be believed, "

"When we talk about #MeToo, we must always remember to honour the true origins of the campaign. Like many other social justice movements, it rose from the struggles of black women and was co-opted by white women."

". Some cis white women such as Rose McGowan currently and publicly “leading” this movement have been criticised for making transphobic comments. How are all women including trans women meant to come forward when these views are still held by people, whether openly or as an unconscious bias?"

OP posts:
ICJump · 19/04/2018 06:26

That article is bonkers

Trumpdump · 19/04/2018 06:24

I refuse to click on Guardian links... can you copy paste? Smile

TerfinUSA · 19/04/2018 06:22

the comments are being ruthlessly censored, I posted a innocuous request for clarification, nope, not let through. the only comments approved are full-on kool-aid drinking nonsense. Presumably they just deleted everything that didn't concur with the (ridiculous) narrative

OP posts:
DamnDeDoubtanceIsSpartacus · 19/04/2018 06:20

The comments, dear god the comments. The guardian is a joke now, an absolute joke.

TerfinUSA · 19/04/2018 06:16

In the article, miss_blanks calls out Rose McGowan, who was heckled by trans-identified child molester Andi Dier.

The entire basis for the article seems to be that some pervey bloke was removed from a festival line-up for dodgy behaviour, and missblanks seized this to 'call him out' on Instagram, not, apparently, on the basis of any personal experience, but just publicly reported incidents recorded in the media www.abc.net.au/triplej/programs/hack/why-kirin-j-callinan-was-removed-from-the-laneway-lineup/9340800 So another case of metoo appropriation.

"It’s not about any specific action, "

translation: this has fuck all to do with me

"but when we cannot question the intent, or validate the emotions resultant of any man’s actions, it truly shows how much power men have over us. I was chastised, threatened, told I was overreacting; I learned that words leave a trauma of their own."

translation: this had literally nothing to do with me, but I am going to pretend it did.

I mean it's a GOOD thing that this pervey bloke was kicked out, but miss_blanks' focus is only on self-publicity, how this becomes an article about 'trans women of colour' is a complete mystery.

OP posts:
TerfinUSA · 19/04/2018 06:11

I had a look at @miss_blanks on Twitter twitter.com/miss_blanks and it's full of internalised homophobia.

twitter.com/miss_blanks/status/945129119167029249

"Haha I love making fun of my in the closet uncle who is married to his new wife hahaha I see u sis"

TRA logic: 'misgendering is murder but it's ok to refer to a perceived gay man as "sis" (aside: miss_blanks, per Twitter, has sex with men)

Second aside, miss_blanks seems to be doing quite well as 'face of Levis', etc., and 'goddess', one has to wonder if not presenting as female would attract so much attention.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread