Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

BBC QT - had to complain before I could go to bed

34 replies

Alternativefacts · 23/03/2018 00:57

www.bbc.co.uk/complaints/complain-online/

Had to be done ......hope they get lots of complaints!

Dear BBC
My complaint relates to the handling of the question on tonight’s Question Time programme regarding whether trans women should have access to all women shortlists. I am concerned at the lack of balance and one-sidedness of the views expressed. It was really disturbing that there was not one dissenting voice heard - either from the panel or the audience- on the underlying question around trans women and access to women only ‘ spaces’ - in this case all women shortlists.

Is the BBC aware that this- and the closely related and topical issue of gender self id are highly controversial at the moment and that many gender critical feminists have been calling for an open and reasonable debate on these issues including all women shortlist’s?
E.g see petition.parliament.uk/petitions/214118 and fairplayforwomen.com - (‘We are a group of ordinary women who are concerned that in the rush to reform transgender laws that women’s voices will not be listened to.Women get called transphobic for simply asking questions. Women are afraid to speak out and fear for their jobs and reputation if they do. ‘ )

Were there no requests to speak from a single person with a different view on the question of trans rights and women only spaces ? - either on the panel or from the audience?

What were the conditions on the basis of which Paris Lees agreed to speak - were there any conditions related to a) panel membership? b) what issues and questions would be allowed?

Why did David Dimbleby not invite Peter Hitchins to respond to direct criticisms of his previous comments by Paris Lees ?

Why was there only one woman on a panel of 5 ? ( plus 3 men, one trans woman. )

Please understand that there are real concerns about people trying to raise issues of women’s rights being silenced and threatened, no platformed and censured - and this edition of Question time sadly seemed to continue this trend.

OP posts:
TerfyTheCuntingTerf · 23/03/2018 22:34

Oh crap, I wish I'd kept mine. Mine was along similar lines to AlternativeFacts, and I also referenced the woman attacked on a picket line recently in relation to the silencing of dissenting voices. Said that there were references made to feminists and 'bullying', whilst giving the feminists no right to reply, and all of this going on while women are being doxxed and harassed with threats of rape and violence, so who's really being bullied here?

Also mentioned that the mention of trans rights having no effect on women's rights was nonsense, with reference to refuges and women with PTSD... I said the decision to have an under 30 audience seemed like a deliberate attempt to silence gender critical voices, and that if Paris Lees was unwilling to debate with GC people then perhaps they weren't the best choice for a program like Question Time. And I also questioned why we never hear from detransitioners or GC trans people like Miranda Yardley, Kristina Harrison or Debbie Hayton.

MrsFogi · 23/03/2018 21:31

I am still gutted at how this was covered on the BBC yesterday. I will lodge a complaint tomorrow. If anyone other than OP is willing to post the wording of their complaints so that I can -copy the best bits- take inspiration from them I should be grateful. Flowers that are identifying as Cake emoticon

LastGirlOnTheLeft · 23/03/2018 21:23

That is a brilliant letter!! I'm going to write mine now! I'm going to use yours as inspiration OP but won't copy I promise.

My DH watched it with me and he was utterly disgusted at the BBC and he has always defended them until now! So much for the neutral, impartial BBC!! Hmm

HomeTerf · 23/03/2018 20:07

Just done my complaint. Thanks for the link Alternativefacts and your very well-written letter. (Mine was considerably less articulate, especially after I'd chopped bits out to fit the stupid character limit!)

RosemaryHoight · 23/03/2018 02:12

I made a complaint. Its not just about being caring and sharing. Or being a so called feminist. Like I've done feminism wrong.

CircleSquareCircleSquare · 23/03/2018 01:59

I actually think their firmness in calling feminists “transphobic” could lead to reprisals.

Mouthtrousersafrocknowandthen · 23/03/2018 01:46

In fact all they really did was talk about how rude women are.

CircleSquareCircleSquare · 23/03/2018 01:30

I have also submitted a complaint.

GretchenFranklin · 23/03/2018 01:06

Yes. Well done. It's late and I'm still up and fucking furious with QT tonight. I will join you in complaining.

How rude and dismissive of women they were.

Swipe left for the next trending thread