Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Disappointing article on transgender in TES

28 replies

FreiasBathtub · 30/01/2018 10:04

Urgh. It's like transgender bingo:

  • Questioning the way things are going == being a horrible homophobe, section 28 etc etc etc (bonus point for linking to Owen Jones article)
  • Why are feminists so obsessed with genitalia?
  • Nobody is cutting bits of children or pumping them full of chemotherapy drugs, promise!
  • 'history will judge you...'
  • Transitioning is always a long, painful, difficult process (with the implication that it involves surgery, drugs and a significant change to lifestyle)
  • Women are worried about men pretending to be women in order to take over their safe spaces which would never happen because see above

Plus some exciting new angles I haven't seen before, including:

  • Feminists, it's YOUR attachment to gender roles that means boys can't wear dresses
  • Transgender people 'are the last people who would encourage gender reassignment on a whim'

I mean, even a very cursory glance on Twitter would show how completely batshit most of these assertions are.

A fact free, evidence free, comprehension free essay which unfortunately has been published in a 'reputable' trade journal for teachers who are already being told they should break fundamental safeguarding rules when a child discloses that they think they might be trans.

Does TES have a right of reply? Letters page? I'm too close to this sector to write anything myself as it would, unfortunately, be professionally damaging.

www.tes.com/news/school-news/breaking-views/transphobes-are-driving-childrens-confusion-about-gender-not-trans

OP posts:
Ekphrasis · 30/01/2018 10:15

I'm sure Kiri Tunks would have a good response to that.

'Feminists attaches to gender roles' - eh?!

jellyfrizz · 30/01/2018 10:12

TES has a forum with an 'educational news' section: community.tes.com/forums/education-news.2128/

2018username · 30/01/2018 10:06

Are you on twitter? It's certainly been 'replied' to on there!