Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Teacher wins fight over ‘transphobic’ comments

55 replies

flapsDentata · 28/01/2018 01:16

Teacher wins fight over ‘transphobic’ comments

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/edc9d44c-03a3-11e8-825e-96e193a013c1

The fightback starts.

OP posts:
guardianfree · 28/01/2018 08:41

Nuffaluff
You are absolutely right about teachers not knowing. And when they get a gender non conforming child, they google, and see GIRES and Mermaids promoted by the DfE so assume that the advice is safe
.
And of course, people just accept what an 'expert' tells them. It's only when you stand back and apply your safeguarding knowledge that the 'professional dangers' become apparent.

orionlow · 28/01/2018 08:41

It makes a nice change from the shite burbled by that vacuous idiot Natasha Devon that’s splattered all over the TES homepage!

NotALabourMemberImAfraidLads · 28/01/2018 08:40

What is 'transplaining'?

I always thought it was when trans-identified males tell women how to be a woman - similar to mansplaining but with a bit of a twist. Eg The TIMS telling women they should wear high heels, getting catcalled in the street is a compliment and they aren't responding correctly etc

Nuffaluff · 28/01/2018 08:35

guardian
Thing is, I recently had some safeguarding training. The woman was really good, really knew her stuff about how we should protect children. The law, the correct procedures to follow, signs to look for etc.
However, she knew nothing about the issues we speak of here.
We were discussing how even very young children should receive sex education so that they know if someone is doing something that feels wrong.
She said ‘yes, I’ve seen a new resource coming out that says this is what a girl looks like and this is what a boy looks like - it should help children to have more awareness about their bodies’.
I don’t think that resource was what she thought it was. It sounds suspiciously like something I’ve seen on here promoted by Mermaids I think.
Most people are just not well informed about the politics surrounding this. I don’t think any of my colleagues are.
The first time they hear about it will probably when they receive their training in how to know when a child is trans. They won’t be well informed enough to object and will probably accept what the ‘expert’ says (the ‘expert’ who wrote the materials).
Thanks for the link though, I will print it off so I have it ready.

mateysmum · 28/01/2018 08:34

Hopefully this nonsense will peak trans another tranche of people. Unbelievable that the union felt there was a case to answer, but thank God common sense prevailed.
The idea that it's not acceptable for a teacher to state the fact that transwomen are not women has been "really impacting" my levels of sanity!

Mner · 28/01/2018 08:28

This is great newsGrin

2018username · 28/01/2018 08:28

Agree this is perhaps one for education/staffroom.

2018username · 28/01/2018 08:26

Adding Wilkes to my list of heros! What is 'transplaining'? And 'guilty of transplaining possibly mansplaining' makes absolutely no sense whatsoever! Can these people hear themselves?

Another one to watch is twitter descended into total farce last night when David Davies tweeted that no women had a penis, the LGBTQIALPHABETSOUP+ conservative account called him a transphobic cunt and he publicy told them off and said he he was reporting them!

The world has gone mad and I am old.

guardianfree · 28/01/2018 08:26

Datun
It's a good thing he's older and obviously less intimidated. I wonder how many thousands of teachers have been dissuaded from their core safeguarding role by fears of being accused of transphobia?

I'm inclined to think that people should be calling out the NUT about this. I don't do twitter (probably a good thing or I'd just self combust) but that might be the place to go. And of course, the DfE - their online complaints process might be a route for a complaint about pressure groups being allowed to train in schools, resulting in people prioritising political attitudes about TG issues over their safeguarding duties.

This probably ought to go on the education board. Anyone know how to do these Times share tokens?

Datun · 28/01/2018 08:10

guardianfree

A really important case. This shows that teachers are failing to safeguard children if they can't raise questions about grooming and drug use in children below the age of consent. It demonstrates the extent to which TA pressure groups are stopping adults in schools from carrying out their safeguarding responsibilities - and that must concern everyone.

I really wish he had said something like this in his statement. Or just used the word safeguarding.

"They said that when Wilkes wrote that he did not agree that trans women were women “that comment made me feel physically sick and the palpitations that I’ve been suffering from started again”.

Any man who thinks this is any kind of defence of their disgraceful witchhunt is plainly ill.

I've never heard of anything so ridiculous. I've certainly, never heard anyone say something quite so nonsensical and expect to be taken seriously.

He must be walking around in a constant state of nausea every time someone picks up a dictionary.

Five years ago he would have been carted off, and sedated in a darkened room.

Guardian do you think this teacher is going to make another statement? Would it be worth contacting him to give him some bullet points about safeguarding and how it is now actively being undermined?

guardianfree · 28/01/2018 07:59

Nuffaluff
Don't lose your job! Gender non conforming children need adults who can and will safeguard them, not those who call them 'brave and heroes' and ignore them being groomed and medicated

Trangendertrend has some good and balanced school resources - and I think they are currently being updated:
www.transgendertrend.com/schools-resources/

If you do get any training, apart from the inevitable breaches of the Equality guidance and fake suicide statistics, look out for any suggestions that adults should keep disclosures from transgender children confidential - breaking rule 1 of safeguarding!

Nuffaluff · 28/01/2018 07:52

Wow, I hadn’t even heard of this case. I can’t believe it went this far and I’m afraid his views will still be dismissed because he’s older.
It hasn’t come up at my school yet, but when the issue does I will say exactly the same thing as him. Sounds like I might have to be prepared to risk losing my job over it!

guardianfree · 28/01/2018 07:31

A really important case. This shows that teachers are failing to safeguard children if they can't raise questions about grooming and drug use in children below the age of consent. It demonstrates the extent to which TA pressure groups are stopping adults in schools from carrying out their safeguarding responsibilities - and that must concern everyone.

ApacheEchidna · 28/01/2018 06:55

Ooh wow. The world hasn't quite gone completely mad after all. That's nice.

KayaG · 28/01/2018 06:50

Excellent news.

MothQuandary · 28/01/2018 06:43

[A transwoman] said that when Wilkes wrote that he did not agree that trans women were women “that comment made me feel physically sick and the palpitations that I’ve been suffering from started again”.

I get palpitations every time I see “Transwomen are women”. Who do I complain to?

CaptainWarbeck · 28/01/2018 05:58

No comments as yet on that article!

ALittleBitOfButter · 28/01/2018 05:42

It would be great to get a link to the original fb conversation. Anyone got it?

AngryAttackKittens · 28/01/2018 05:38

Thanks, Cunning!

AngryAttackKittens · 28/01/2018 02:33

Does anyone have a share link? Can't read it!

flapsDentata · 28/01/2018 01:55

I knew you would love it. Night x

OP posts:
Beansonapost · 28/01/2018 01:54

Lovely! Smile

BlindYeo · 28/01/2018 01:49

Devilish cunning PERF Grin

Very pleased to read about this outcome. The stress this teacher must have gone through though.

PositivelyPERF · 28/01/2018 01:38

Happy days. It’s a day of miracles, my oldest actually listened to me tonight when I was talking about the vile Lily. I did have to sneak up to the mention of him, under the guise of asking if his uni ever no platformed anyone> Germaine Greer> feminism> Women being suspended from Labour Party Because they’re not permitted to say women can’t have a penis> women’s roles in the party> 19yr old boy being accepted in a role intended for females. Mumsnet vipers would have been proud of my drip drip drip technique. 😁

Swipe left for the next trending thread