Woman attacked by transactivists at speakers corner - part deux

Did you get a backlash as well @Sunkisses?

I've 'come out' on facebook about my feelings about all this, as last week's violence was a line in the sand for me. Silent no more! There were over 200 comments on one post alone. Loads of people also 'coming out' as privately and deeply uneasy about all this trans stuff, but worried they will be called transphobe etc. It felt really liberating!

I'd love to post on fb. Trouble is I have several friends who post regularly about transphobia and I think they'd just assume I was backwards and ignorant. Then there are my friends who are probably completely unaware of all of the debate surrounding this issue. They'd most likely shrug their shoulders and think 'why is she posting? Why does it matter that some men wear dresses?'

It feels depressingly hard to voice an opinion about this but if we don't....

I'm not very active on FB so I haven't so far. Although I did like "nerds with vaginas" the other day since they're getting agro for being haters.

So has anyone been brave enough to link any of this stuff on fb? If so any backlash to date? I really want to do this but am a HCP and worry a little about big brother watching...

I've started a thread on FWR re what we might be able to do activism wise regarding recent events and the fact that the TRA's are now showing their true colours. This isn't just about the gender recognition act but about a range of issues re trans

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/a3036613-Activism-Around-Last-Weeks-Trans-Violence?msgid=72003213#72003213

I did consider GenocidalManiac but figured some folk might not get the joke :D

Most amusing thing so far today is the person who identifies as a lesbian TW claiming they will get sent to conversion therapy for their sexual attraction and that their gender is butch, but they're not a man.

Confused, you will be!

I've name changed too but mines not as good as yours @FactsAreNotMean

Just testing a name change given earlier chat...

@Natsku you literally woke. Deep.

I dreamt last night that I was explaining why gender is a social construct and is used to oppress women to someone and just as they were starting to understand I woke up - frustrating!

So I've just gone for a run and during my run I started thinking about dicks (as you do).
Well not dicks themselves but more the phallus and its role in modern power structures and gender. There cannot ever be such thing as a female penis, a penis HAS to be male. The image of the penis is so intrinsically linked with male power it would be impossible to remove it.
The penis is often used as something to control women, think of rapes. I'm not saying everyone who has a penis is a rapist but men's power doesn't just come from their gender it comes from their biology too, and by that I mean their wee wee's.

I can't imagine men who do not want to transition ever accepting that penises can be anything other than male whether you're wearing a dress or not.

So I posted the sky clip on fb... deafening silence. Well one person did a shocked face! I think this is partly as people don't want to watch clips - often browsing the net whilst watching tv etc. But I wanted to use that clip as it was such a good summary & also sky is a source people have heard of & don't have loyalty to it or otherwise like they do with papers so much.

So my problem is not so much I'll be branded transphobic. It's that people think what is going on is trendy nonsense that isn't worth acknowledging & will think I'm alarmist for caring. I might think the same if it wasn't for the transing of children & the self id law.

Chats in person bit by bit instead I think...

www.google.co.uk/search?ie=UTF-8&client=ms-android-samsung&source=android-browser&q=does+gender+still+matter+in+2017&gfe_rd=cr&dcr=0&ei=oLG_WebMMdTc8Afx2LjgBg

I asked Google the question and it appears it still does.

What this discussion is about, I have no idea.

Gingernaut

Thanks for that. Too far from me. If anyone goes, firstly be careful, and secondly report back.

Ot seems anything with the word gender in the title, could be tricky.

I would go to that as it's not far from me Gingernaut but I can't work out exactly what the discussion is about.......

I'd already dumped the Guardian and have now pretty much dumped the Beeb over this tbh - I got sick of the constant proselytising. I welcome different points of view but they are like fundamentalists, they just bang this one drum on and on. I get the fucking message, sheesh.

We don't watch loads of telly anyway and have pretty much completely switched to Netflix. I might just cancel the TV license and pick up the LRB again. In fact yes I will, fuck it. I have subbed to the Times as well, and ordered the Morning Star and the New Statesman at the newsagents.

I don't know who commissioned it - it's written by Mark Davies Markham. This is the 3rd series. It's followed Amy all the way through the transition process which started when Amy was in primary school

Try these screen captures

No questioning, no challenging is allowed.

Who wrote and commissioned it?

^ I can't see any personal detals?

Ironically this week's women's hour 15 minute drama is 'Just A Girl' about a girl who was 'born in the wrong body'.

On the home page, it says: "Thanks to Susie Green and the parents at Mermaids and the Tavistock Clinic."

In today's episode, Amy (formerly Ben, and incidentally played by a female actor) is chosen for a part in West Side Story over her friend. Someone at school has questioned what toilets and changing rooms Amy used and Amy's parents are furious at their bigotry.

No questioning, no challenging is allowed.