Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

No more girls and boys; can our children go gender free? BBC 2 tonight

343 replies

Ekphrasis · 16/08/2017 18:19

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09202lp

I heard PM in radio 4 discussing this research, it seems to hugely benefit girls in terms of their views on their own achievements and the achievements of women in general.

Will listen with interest.

What surprised me (as we have had this language banned in my place of work, with children) is that the teacher, pre experiment, called girls sweetie and petal, and boys buddy etc.

OP posts:
Frecklemcspeckles · 17/08/2017 08:23

@rhinestonecowgirl yes I can't think of anything that would be inappropriate for an 8 year old to watch in it.

Whatshouldmyusernamebe · 17/08/2017 08:23

Fine to watch with your child.

Frecklemcspeckles · 17/08/2017 08:22

I thought it was an excellent programme last night. I stumbled across it and initially was very Confused by the title but the themes in the programme were fascinating.
I actually think the teacher was pretty brave to allow them to film and critique him. I hope he felt it was worthwhile.
Re the books, yes it's only one small step in the right direction that the "princess" is now the hero but I have a 7yo girl who absolutely loves the Princess in Black series because she's the first "superhero" (her words) she's come across in books that's a girl.

We still have so far to go though. School is an important part of it but wider society has major issues with forcing stereotypes. The usual pink/blue toys etc that didn't exist years ago. And the clothes. I was in Mothercare a couple of weeks ago and they had a space & science range of clothes in the boys section. Nothing remotely comparable in the girls.
Then you go into m&s and try and find something fun and bright for a 5-6 boy and can only find mini versions of what their dads wear and all dark and drab.

Anyhow... I'm waffling. The programme was very interesting, I'm looking forward to seeing the end result.

Datun · 17/08/2017 08:21

Ekphrasis

I read Steve Biddulph when my son was born. However, I have since read on here that many feminists don't rate him, at all.

I'll read your link.

RhinestoneCowgirl · 17/08/2017 08:18

Planning to watch this on catch up - would it be suitable to watch with my 8 yr old DD? In our house we have tried our best to challenge gender stereotypes, but I know both DD and her older brother have struggled a bit at school as they don't 'fit' with other girls/boys.

Ekphrasis · 17/08/2017 08:16

Some of these books are good, not specifically about boys and feelings. There is a list somewhere but I think they did swing pro girl rather than boys and feelings.

selfsufficientkids.com/growth-mindset-childrens-books/

OP posts:
Ekphrasis · 17/08/2017 08:13

Australia seem to have been making good head way, partly due to Steve Biddulph's work.

manup.org.au/tv-series/

OP posts:
Ekphrasis · 17/08/2017 08:10

^^this.

These last few posts are why this is so important.

I really hope this doesn't just sink and fade away.

I've noticed a thread in telly addicts where the poster doesn't totally 'get' it. I think the majority of people won't, I've tried talking to friends about this and they just don't get it, as in the bigger picture, how does this affect everyone?

I sounded like a loon pointing out that the pink and blue fairy doors in the woodland walk was a 'bit of an issue' as that was 'where the boy fairies lived and that was where the girl fairies lived' (to be fair, it wasn't the time or the place!)

OP posts:
orlantina · 17/08/2017 08:02

He has touched on the boys being very competitive and that they had far more words to describe anger than love. He also mentioned that 95% of the prison population is male

I know he's touched on it. I wonder if there'll be any discussion about why and to see if that behaviour can also be changed.

drspouse · 17/08/2017 07:56

Important to have books where girls save the day, but also important to have books where boys deal with friendship issues
We had a thread about this a little while ago and (while it was on preschool books about caring men and boys) the latter are like hens teeth.

QueenLaBeefah · 17/08/2017 07:50

He has touched on the boys being very competitive and that they had far more words to describe anger than love. He also mentioned that 95% of the prison population is male.

Just to add my own anecdata- when my boys started nursery at the age of 3 all of them (within a week) learnt that "boys don't cry". So disappointed as DH and I had tried so hard to move away from that type of guff.

Ekphrasis · 17/08/2017 07:46

Hi hothead,

Do you mean negative comments here or elsewhere? I knew it was about unequal treatment from the outset, but maybe as I heard about the research as a 'trailer'.

Gender identify has not (so far) been mentioned, I doubt it will, and is really a logical next step conclusion that I doubt many will quite make unless they have some prior understanding. However, as you say, it's not really the point and what the programme achieves is fantastic and very important for girls and boys.

Amazing could be a part of this! I'd be interested to know if that teacher really spoke like that prior to the experiment?! I guess you all had to give permission too? Has it had the designed impact on the children?

The biggest and most serious thing for me was confidence and emotional intelligence; low self esteem for the girls and the explosive anger from the boys (one in particular) and the assumption by all that this is normal - these things are deeply ingrained by that age. And the association of looks with girls. Lipstick?!

OP posts:
orlantina · 17/08/2017 07:32

I wonder if he'll address issues about violence, competitiveness, always wanting to win and aggressiveness with boys - and how that's also learned. That's such a massive issue - and it's ok to not always win and that you don't have to use violence to get your own way.

AlternativeTentacle · 17/08/2017 07:27

It was about height and physical strength lifting heavy fencing posts 8 feet high. It would be very few girls who could manage that.

Probably because your girls have had no practice at doing strong things. It is effect not cause.

I left civil engineering because of bollocks that you are spouting. I once went out to take about 10 clay samples which involved banging a metal ring the same size as a large can of soup, into the ground and digging it out filled with soil, and the client wouldn't let me do it! He took the rammer off me and did it all himself. I was about 23, strong, and that was my - you know - actual job.

IndominusRex · 17/08/2017 07:13

I didn't watch this but think I'm going to on catch up. Just thinkng back to my primary school days, we wiukd get changed together in the classroom and did the same sports for PE but had seperate loos. I never noticed any pushing of gender roles at that age. Secondary school it was very different. I'm mid 30s btw. I also know that the same primary school now has e.g. Pirate and princess days, so something has definitely changed for the worse!

Seeingadistance · 17/08/2017 02:14

Like Datun, I didn't watch this because I feared for my blood pressure.

I'll check it out on catch up. Smile

GardenGeek · 17/08/2017 00:56

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

andintothefire · 17/08/2017 00:39

It was a great programme. It seemed as though the children enjoyed it as well.

I found the point about brain training really interesting, and not something I had really thought about before. Now it seems so completely obvious that differences in achievement in various subjects can be explained largely by the push towards children doing different activities in their early years depending on gender.

It's depressing as well though - how can we overcome these issues when children are exposed to so many gender stereotypes? When I think back on my childhood, it was fairly gender neutral in some ways in my early years. Then the lack of confidence crept in, and it has taken me many years as an adult to become brave enough to ignore much of the stereotyping again.

VestalVirgin · 17/08/2017 00:34

For example in the swedish school they had signs on the wall saying 'girls are strong' and 'boys are sensitive'. Whereas in the UK school they had signs which said 'girls are strong' and 'boys are strong' which is more equal.

You are missing the point so completely it is almost funny. Confused

Hotheadedredhead37 · 17/08/2017 00:27

Glad some of you actually watched it before commenting as being a parent of one of the real stars of the show,it was so disappointing to read negative comments before it had even aired!bet those of you thinking it was about gender identity, were surprised when its about unequalness between sexes!I am so proud my child was part of something so cool!

Datun · 17/08/2017 00:21

With luck, this may make the transing of children frowned upon.

Many people already think it's ridiculous transing a child purely because they play with the toys of the opposite sex.

Hopefully, 'toys of the opposite sex' well cease to exist.

GardenGeek · 17/08/2017 00:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Ekphrasis · 17/08/2017 00:00

It will hopefully give parents whose children are trans, ideas on how to handle it.

I agree, I think this programme is what we need, but, I don't think it's been specific enough about this yet. I sadly don't think it'll dare to be.

OP posts:
Morphene · 16/08/2017 23:59

Widening of the life experiences of boys is hugely important. It shouldn't make the national news when boys chose to wear skirts to school in exactly the same way it fails to hit the national news when girls wear trousers to school.

Ekphrasis · 16/08/2017 23:59

Yes the book thing got to me, but, I do know there's book lists out there for all this and they're much better than that. They could have had a clip of boys reading about friendships and emotions. I think girl power has been around for a while.

Let's face it, it's all condensed into a hours program. Hopefully it can spin off more debate.

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread