Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Transracial vs Transgender (new Rachel Dolezal interview)

28 replies

MamaPuffin · 20/04/2017 04:17

This interview has been shared around my (liberal feminist) Facebook feed like crazy today.

I thought it was a good article, but the thought I can't get out of my head is that if you replace 'white' with 'male' in many sections of the article, it sounds so much like radical feminism (which all the friends who praise this article roundly dismiss as 'bigoted'). I just can't get my head around the mental gymnastics required to not see the similarities, nor have I ever heard a good explanation of why transracialism is different to transgenderism.

"It is white supremacy that told her that any black people who questioned her were obviously uneducated and unmotivated to rise to her level of wokeness.... And if racial justice doesn't center her, she will redefine race itself in order to make that happen. It is a bit extreme, but it is in no way new for white people to take what they want from other cultures in the name of love and respect, while distorting or discarding the remainder of that culture for their comfort. "

I haven't the time or energy to have this conversation on Facebook today, but I needed to share somewhere.

OP posts:
LassWiTheDelicateAir · 20/04/2017 09:22

Does it make any difference in that the passing both ways argument does apply to transgender issues?

If you say the case of Dolezal is no different from a transgender person you will get objections from ftm as well as mtf.

QuentinSummers · 20/04/2017 07:14

It's a good article. A different slant on RD than others I've read, most are more sympathetic to her upbringing. I wonder if that's because the author is black so more able to analyse what she says. I thought the stuff about National Geographic fetishizing black people was interesting.

CatsGoPurrrr · 20/04/2017 06:50

Morning Mama!

I have just read the interview and came here to post, but you best me to it.

I completely agree. Swap colours for sexes and it's the transgender argument.

how can it be so obvious, yet people be so blind?

Swipe left for the next trending thread