Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Anyone know of any stats on name changing after marriage?

155 replies

anotheronebitthedust · 30/10/2016 17:26

I'm at the age (28) when facebook suddenly makes the change from photos of nights out to endless wedding albums Smile - but scrolling through it today I suddenly realised that pretty much every single woman close to my age I have as a 'friend' on fb has changed their name after their wedding. Not most, not even almost all - every single one!

Most of these friends are from school/uni/work/travelling so are within 2-3 years of my age, some left school at 16 but majority have at least a degree, lots with masters, post grads, etc. They come from, and now live, all over the UK, so some still in the smallish town I grew up in but many others from all over the place. Several either have previously, or currently do, live abroad. So a fairly wide spectrum of my age group.

It really surprised me. When I was in my late teens I thought it was getting more and more common a) not to marry at all in a ltr and b) not to take the husband's name. However in the last few years it seems like both trends have completely reversed and I wondered if anyone knew of any stats that back up if my personal experience is/isn't reflective of the UK generally.

I'm not necessarily bothered by it - although some of the reasons I had from the friends I asked about it did make me Hmm) I would imagine most of them have made reasoned decisions why they name changed and are happy with it. It just struck me that if it was a true choice, then the likelihood would be that not everybody would happen to make the same choice and that therefore, for whatever reason, perhaps it isn't as much of an actual choice... - I know this is incredibly badly expressed but hope you get the gist of what I mean!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
prettygirlincrimsonrose · 11/11/2016 18:06

OP if you're still interested in some research on the topic discoversociety.org/2013/11/05/whats-in-a-name-gendered-naming-practices-and-identity-in-britain/

YonicProbe · 09/11/2016 23:02

"for reasons grounded in sexism and the man insisting"

I agree that the reasons are grounded in sexism, but I'm not sure how many men insist, vs it being more of a societal expectation/norm.

I wouldn't want to change my name because it's mine and has been all my life, I wouldn't change it to yours to make a political point, though I see your logic.

IAmAmy · 09/11/2016 22:56

Maybe insisting is the wrong way of putting it. Marriage doesn't particularly appeal to me (easy to say I know, maybe in years to come I may feel differently), but if it were to happen I'd like my potential husband to change his name. I'd like to think the kind of man I'd be with would be happy to. I don't think it's the same as men have been insisting women change their surnames for generations, and still do.

If there was complete equality then I'd agree no-one should change, but as women overwhelmingly still do, for reasons grounded in sexism and the man insisting, I think more men need to change their surnames upon marriage. Also if I ever have children then no matter what I would absolutely insist they had my surname, I'd be the one who'd given birth to them after all, why on Earth should a woman go through all that only for the father's surname to automatically be given?

YonicProbe · 09/11/2016 22:44

Amy

You could ask, but I doubt you insisting would go any better than him insisting you did it would!

I also think we are all known as our names for 20-30 years, why should anyone change?

IAmAmy · 09/11/2016 22:39

The name changing thing really annoys me because there is absolutely no reason why men shouldn't change their surnames upon marriage at the same rate women change theirs, but they barely ever do. It is so clearly completely sexist and not a free choice - if it was a free choice then the numbers would be equal, not nearly always women doing it. If it's purely about what people want to do then why do women always apparently want to lose their surnames and men nearly always want women to take theirs?

IAmAmy · 09/11/2016 22:33

IamNotDarling whilst I agree the woman and the man each keeping their surname is ideal, I'd insist on the man taking my surname if I ever marry as I'd want to go some small way to redressing the balance of so many women changing their surnames, often being pressured into doing so by their fiancés (as some even on this thread have alluded to). I think it's about time men started taking women's names if having the same surname upon marriage is so important!

Pooky77 · 09/11/2016 21:46

Sad when people can't comprehend that doing something because it's what you want to do it is pretty much the best, if not only reason to do something. If others choices aren't for you that's ok you don't need to agree but to pass judgement on decisions that are not yours to make is narrow minded imho.

Myrobalanna · 09/11/2016 13:47

I like the fact that there are so many points of view on this. (I wish people weren't so defensive and outraged, though. It's a big deal but you catch more flies with honey...)

Around the world there are many different naming systems. Once you realise it's a arbitrary thing that has been co-opted and shaped in our culture by the patriarchy, that's quite liberating. Do as you please! The 'husband's father's name' model is toxic to some and just as liberating to others. I think we can all live with that?

The main thing I'd say, on the experience of friends, is don't publish in your name if you want to be known otherwise at a later point. It aint worf the hassle of a double life.

IamNotDarling · 09/11/2016 13:24

Hi IamAmy why not just both keep your surnames? No changing required by anyone!

IAmAmy · 08/11/2016 23:30

Not one reason given on this thread for changing name upon marriage is legitimate until there are equivalent conversations amongst men about why they changed their surnames to their wives' upon marriage. Any reason given would only be valid if as many men as women changed their surnames when marrying. There is absolutely no reason why men shouldn't change theirs other than patriarchy and entrenched sexist attitudes. My mum changed her name when she married and I've pressed her on it a few times, her reasons are the usual ones, not one of them doesn't stem from sexism.

I'm 16, but if I ever marry my hypothetical future husband would definitely take my surname.

BertrandRussell · 03/11/2016 14:26

"Ah, the sheer bliss of not having to spell my name phonetically down the phone three or four times every time I speak to anyone has to be experienced to be believed."

Could we have that on hard repeat on the Baby Names board, please?

Pooky77 · 03/11/2016 11:18

I changed my name because i wanted to, i didn't even consider not changing it.

Of my social group i'd say the same as OP the majority have changed their names to their husbands, i also have one friend who retained her surname but refers to herself as Mrs.

I don't see an issue in whatever choice people make as long as it's made freely.

Zebra999 · 03/11/2016 10:55

I changed my name because it is virtually impossible to travel with the children if we all have different names (to the country I come from). I can't change the government systems at force here so to make it painless for everyone, I changed my name.

I divorced exh and haven't changed my name back to my maiden name for the same reason. I will wait till the dcs are 18 (only a few years off). Even though I am divorced, I am supposed to get an affidavit and a court order saying I can take the children abroad without exh but I don't bother as no-one questions it as our surnames are the same.

That's my reason :)

maggiethemagpie · 03/11/2016 10:51

Funny that Doinit mourns her unusual maiden name whereas I couldn't wait to exchange it for a more common one.

Ah, the sheer bliss of not having to spell my name phonetically down the phone three or four times every time I speak to anyone has to be experienced to be believed.

maggiethemagpie · 03/11/2016 10:49

Doinitfine, his name is actually much easier to spell than mine so I was happy to change. Couldn't wait in fact. If mine had been easier then maybe he'd have changed to mine.

We are quite a feminist/gender-reversed family, I work, he's a SAHD, I make a lot of the family decisions, so I hardly think if i wanted to keep my name he'd have stood in my way (don't think he even knows how to stand in my way).

TeiTetua · 02/11/2016 23:10

I know a couple who got married in their 50s, where she'd been married before and was still going around with her married name. Neither of them thought that was right if they were married, but they didn't think Mrs Hisname was right either. So as of the wedding day, she went back to her original name, and apparently everyone's happy.

DoinItFine · 02/11/2016 22:27

Why hey ho?

Why didn't you give your daughter the better surname?

A distinctive name has a significant advantage these days.

You had two names to pick from and you picked the worse one.

Why?

Warl · 02/11/2016 20:58

Interesting thread this one!! I see where you're coming from OP as there does seem to be more women taking their husbands name. However I do know 3 couples where both him & her have double barrelled & are both 'The X-Y's'

I'm recently married & have taken a DH's name. I was previously divorced & kept my maiden name as a middle name after that marriage as at the time as I felt I didn't want to let go of my name.

This time I took DH's name purely because I wanted to, we have a DD who is 3 & I like that we all have the same surname. There was no 'bollocks' that we would have problems having different names - we've managed fine for 3 years with different ones - I just like that now we are 'The X's'

I still kind of in mourning of my unusual maiden name though & have ended up with a downright common surname but hey ho!

DoinItFine · 02/11/2016 20:04

It's a problem because it was selfish of you to just ehat you pleased when presumably he wanted tontake your name just as much?

Why did you deny him that pleasure and keep it all for yourself?

maggiethemagpie · 02/11/2016 19:07

I took my husband's name on marriage, I wanted to, why is that a problem?

RufusTheSpartacusReindeer · 31/10/2016 21:09

I was going to keep mine

And then dh said we could change to a brand new one

Then his dad went mental

And then dh changed his mind

And then i thought that if he died i would want our future children to have something of his

So i changed my name

For what its worth i was 19 when i decided all this and it was 26 years ago so keeping your name wasn't as common ( and yes i know that women still kept their name...it just wasn't as common)

If i got divorced i would probably take my old name back, if i was remarried i would probably keep my old name. I would not mind if any of my children changed their names although it is not suited to double barreled (otherwise i would have done it when we got married)

Not an excuse, not rational but the question was asked and thats my answer

scoobydooagain · 31/10/2016 20:57

My ex husband changed his name to mine and our son has my (our ) name, it was very simple. I would say I am a feminist however I use Miss if I have to use a title (I really would prefer to not use a title) possibly Miss is not the correct title but I do not like Ms and I really dislike Mrs and wish titles were made away with. I have had surprisingly little negative comments about this.

MsMermaid · 31/10/2016 20:40

I didn't change my name when I got married. This caused a very small issue on my actual wedding day when I pointed out (very, very politely) that I was still Ms myName not Mrs hisName. Mil had as much of an argument as she could with me about it over the wedding dinner. Her dh thought it was hilarious that I turned every argument back on her so in the end she almost agreed that it was disgusting that dh wasn't taking my name.

I've had all sorts of people asking what my "real" name is and wanting to know if i use my married name for personal things even though they know I haven't changed it at all.

I actually don't mind getting cards addressed to Mr and Mrs hisName, because we get a fairly equal number of cards addressed to Ms and Mr myName (because my extended family can't remember his name)

anotheronebitthedust · 31/10/2016 20:19

I don't judge any of my friends (or anyone) individually - how could I when I have no idea of the reasons why they decided to name change, and even if I did, who am I to decide how valid their personal feelings are?

What I was interested in was the collective uniformity of the name changing - as WhoKnowsWhereTheTimeG0es expressed more coherently than me, if it was truly a free, unhindered, choice with no social or cultural weight or background then realistically you would expect at least half of women not to change their names, if not more - as 'changing' is the active choice that involves making quite a bit of effort, whereas just keeping the same name is passive, and easier!

Thanks to Hilary for providing some stats - they support what I thought was the case, so perhaps my group of acquaintances do buck the trend, for whatever reason. Although the only 54% name-changers in the most recent survey seems very low - having a closer look at it it seems the answers are based on only just over 1000 participants, all of whom decided to respond to the question on the Discourses of Marriage Research Group blog - so perhaps a self-selecting, not full representative demograph? Still very interesting though, and I did like that quote by Elizabeth Cady Stanton.

OP posts:
BertrandRussell · 31/10/2016 17:56

"I always consider myself to be a feminist, everywhere apart from on MN, where I am a sheep who makes non/anti-feminist choices."

Nope.nyou are a feminist who on occasion makes non/anti feminist choices. Like most of us.