Caitlyn Jenner Halloween costume

he has a sign saying call me cayilyn, he is obviously trying to take the piss. Nothing to do with just a corset.

Judging by her popularity: many.

IMHO the real issue is would a costume like this lead to increased attacks on transwomen? I think not, I don't think transwomwn are attacked because of a costume.

But I could be wrong.

So because I would not want to add to anything like a culture of hate for trans women (and because I do not have the legs to pull it off) I would not wear it.

But I seriously resent the fact that a trans celebrity should be considered 'off limits' on a Halloween costume when other female celebrities and other 'regular' women are not off limits.

Could one argue that these types of costumes lead to increased attacks on women... www.partycity.com/category/halloween+costumes/womens+costumes+accessories.do

I initially Googled sexy costumes just to make a point but even when you do not Google sexy costumes if you Google 'halloween costimes for women' that's what you get!

Also, seriously, how can it be OK for Caitlyn to dress in this way and no one else, who knows someone may be trans and buying this costume for that reason. Surely being trans is about not policing what people can wear, or have I got that wrong!

Plus bearing in mind all the violence against trans people, gay people, straight people, males and let's not forget females I wonder why the media doesn't have more important things to complain about!

AFAIK Jenner hasn't commented directly.

I don't like the costume but it's perfectly possibly the kind of thing that Bruce Jenner would have found funny and CJ may feel the same.

"Why it has to be about her her her HER."

Because if you google for the costume, you'll return hits that show it's not just a corset costume, it's a CJ costume complete with sash making the intention unmistakeable.

And yes, she could maintain a dignified silence as some others have done. Or she could make a fuss about others making a profit from her image. And make any other points about her situation whilst she does so.

Not everyone finds a particular thing funny.

Re Jenner wearing that corset. The problem I have with it related to age is that a female woman in her sixties would never appear on the front of vanity fair in her grots. Let alone be lauded for it.

Kim costume is mean, dentists with lion heads are in extremely poor taste. Personal attacks - mocking individuals is mean. This is why there are some comedians I don't enjoy - there is political commentary, there is laughing with someone, and then there is being rude and mocking, and you can tell the difference

Perhaps elasticated skirts in a array of pastel colours would be more appropriate Lass?

Maybe sporting a blue rinse?

What should women in their 60's be wearing?

Yes, as a valid criticism "she's wearing age inappropriate clothes" is pretty poor.

I'm sure most women over the age of 60 could possibly look good if they were also receiving extra female hormones (hrt).
At the moment, most women over the age of 60 are denied HRT.

They possibly would wear a tight white corset - who knows, but most wouldn't expect to look good in it and they wouldn't want the whole world seeing them in it. That's for sure.

To throw an added argument into this already very cloudy mix - I would be interested to know whether a female transgender person is still given female hormones (hrt) after the age of 60, (a typical age at which women who are born female are often denied/refused hrt).

Surely, if they want to truly experience the joys and hardships of being a woman - in all it's glorius stages, then they should also have to accept a decline in their female hormones - which occurs naturally after the age of 50 and definitely after the age of 60!
Why should they have the right (and the medical assistance) to have access to medication which is effectively 'helping to keep them young' when other females are denied this treatment?

Boils my piss.

What should women in their 60's be wearing?

Hmm...

Surely, people should be allowed to make statements about the whole sordid affair of the media circus surrounding the coming out of a 65-year-old in a corset.

You have hit the nail on the head.
People are mocking the choice of outfit, rather than CJ herself.

How many females (who were born females) do you know in their late 60's, who would even dream of wearing an outfit like this? I don't know many.
If CJ wants to be taken seriously, she needs to start acting like a woman of her age and not trying to dress like someone her daughters generation.

No wonder people are taking the piss.

(I'm younger than her and even I wouldn't wear something tarty/tacky like that)

I have recently returned from the states there was plenty of fawning over CJ on the radio, TV and no doubt magazines not that I read any CJ won the Arthur Ashe award for Courage ffs

The media do judge women by their looks, CJ is not a woman she is a transwomen and part of the kasdashian media empire which is all about media image that is what is mainly spoken about how amazing and glamours she looks

Fawning over her? I haven't seen that really but I don't read heat. Where is this fawning happening?
Talking about how good or bad she looks is just what the media do to women. Now comparing her to biological women is just ridiculous.

What are you trying to say anyfucker? You aren't making much sense.

I think Kellie Maloney (when Frank) standing as the UKIP candidate for the 2004 London mayoral election is plenty of reason to dislike her, even without the abhorrent statements (that she hasn't completely retracted, has she?)

I can't find the UK data, but in the US Kelly / Kellie was the 30-35th most popular girls name in the 1960s, so not uncommon amongst that age group particularly with an Irish background (I think it means something like "warrior", so quite apt)

Anyway... In a world where you can buy a dentist outfit covered in blood, complete with a severed lion's head, a CJ outfit is (I completely agree) not kind but almost to be expected. Halloween isn't just about wearing a witch or skeleton costume in the US.

I can choose whatever reason I like to take exception to what Kellie Maloney is trying to tell us.

I don't consider your opinion on what I say to be of any consequence to me at all. If you don't see my point, I shan't waste my time trying to explain it to you.

You are taking exception to it being Kellie as opposed to Kelly? The names sound exactly the same and neither are particularly glamorous.

I can't remember how the ones I was at school with spelt their names but there are woman born in Britain who are in their mid 50s who have names which sound exactly like "Kellie". There's plenty of valid reasons to criticise Maloney but that's not one of them.

The Amy Winehouse costumes were vile. I have already said that.

Some gay friends have a 'whores and vicars' party and the 'whores' costumes are a fantastic celebration of a kind of bawdy femininity (across classes too). There is nothing misogynistic about it at all.

I'm struggling with the idea about there being nothing misogynistic about a tarts and vicars party.

I also don't get Caitlyn Jenner adoration. I think a lot of it is because she's not trying to be a 62yo woman, she's trying to be a 62yo celebrity.

her name is Kellie

I would like to see evidence of a British 62yo woman who was christened Kellie

So, all these people complaining about the costume - where were they several years ago when guys used to dress up in beehive wigs and minidresses and stumble around as Amy Winehouse for Halloween? If that wasn't making fun of a deeply troubled individual who'd been through a lot then I don't know what was.

The costumes aren't of her doing nor as far as I'm aware is the complaining about them.

I agree she doesn't look nearly as fabulous as we're being told and it probably looks very fake close up. Maloney looked better when she was in ordinary clothes but clearly is trying to compete with Jenner in her recent photos.

Re the name she's 6/7 years older than me. I was at school with a couple of"Kellys" and have worked with "Kellys" roughly my age. It's not particularly a young girl's name, nor a particularly attractive name. Criticising her for her history of violence and homophobia is fine but her name?

Apart from when they get mentioned on here I find it as easy to avoid them as I do any other sleb.

Agree the costumes are bringing CJ more attention and that is what she seems to crave

The fawning over CJ is ridiculous and it's all about how fabulous she looks for her age. She does not look fabulous she looks what she is a transwoman who had had far too much plastic surgery and wears far too much make up