Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women's hobbies

32 replies

GoshAnneGorilla · 28/10/2013 01:03

Apologies if this has been done already and is a bit muddled, but I've been thinking...

One of the things that bothers me about "anti-pinkification" is that boys toys or gender neutral toys are positioned as being better then girls toys, which are often viewed as having no value at all.

Then we get into adult hobbies, chick-lit is disparaged in a way that pulpy crime fiction or those endless SAS books never are.

Cooking has become a respected hobby, but only it seems, because men are on the telly doing it. Any activity that is mainly done by women, seems to be fair game for mockery and disparagement.

This is reflected in endless threads on Relationships, where men's hobbies are sacrosanct and women are expected to not have any need for leisure activities.

Has anyone got any thoughts on this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fay144 · 07/11/2013 16:06

This is an interesting discussion, and something I've been thinking about lately.

I have a lot of hobbies. Some things I do with OH (cycling, snowboarding) and some on my own (scuba diving, silver-smithing, running). I also am trying to teach myself various things in my spare time (e.g. 3D CAD design, Android app development). OH also has a lot of hobbies that he does without me. We are lucky to live in an area where things a lot of people might do once a year on holiday are available on our doorstep for a large part of the year.

I'm currently pregnant with my first, and things are going to change a lot!

Obviously, I'm not going to be able to carry on as I was before - and the pregnancy has meant a lot of changes already. But both OH and myself have been assuming that we are both going to be able to have some leisure time, split fairly evenly, with a bit of give and take to allow each other to have time to ourselves. Maybe a night or 2 per week off each, and the occasional weekend day. But I've been surprised at how many other people are just assuming I'll be giving everything up. Maybe I'm just being unrealistic... but I'll still be me.... surely?

DixonBainbridge · 07/11/2013 15:45

So true that women's hobbies are disparaged

I think you'll find that it's the case with any hobby that isn't "mainstream" to be honest.

Wargaming & RPG's get a lot of stick as do many "geeky" hobbies like astronomy, metal detecting etc. Anything that "manly footy types" can't understand is routinely ridiculed.

I started a wargames club when I was in the Army & we'd regularly get p*ssed up idiots coming in & trying to break stuff or knock it around because it didn't fit in with their perception of what was an acceptable use of their spare time.

The shelves at WH Smiths are full of magazines devoted to some fantastic hobbies so people must be doing them - maybe they keep quiet so as to avoid all the denigration?

alexpolistigers · 07/11/2013 14:31

Hmm. This is an interesting topic.

I hadn't considered the idea of having a bath as leisure time, to be honest. But the point seems so obvious now!

So true that women's hobbies are disparaged. I make latch-hook rugs, I design them myself, and I really enjoy it, but I have found that people can be very patronising about it. I also belong to a folk dancing club, and I have had people ask me if my dh minds the fact that I go there, especially as it's not terribly useful! No thought that I might want to do it because it's fun!

vtechjazz · 07/11/2013 13:18

I sometimes think women are their own worst enemies, I can knit beautifully and would like to sell my work at the local WI......but the other (older generation) women sell their knitted work so cheaply I can't and wont compete. My time is worth something. They must spend many hours on some items, often intricate baby clothes, to then sell them for a pittance.

KaseyM · 05/11/2013 20:09

This was the philosophy behind the book "Stitch'nBitch" book, that women's hobbies were undervalued and that celebrating women's contributions was actually a very feminist thing to do.

I remember going to a quilting exhibition at the V&A. It was a fascinating look at history because women's stories and stories of the time are bound up in the quilts. But amongst the hundreds of women visiting there were about 1 or 2 men. Yet women go to exhibitions to celebrate men's scientific achievements all the time.

I think crafts are fantastic - to be able to make something from scratch is a wonderful skill - but unfortunately there is always the issue of cost. The prices places like Hobbycraft charge is ridiculous sometimes.

BetterDrownedThanDuffers · 05/11/2013 19:21

This is really interesting. Since dd was born I having been doing the Family Tree. I find it fascinating, but I suspect DH lumps it in with my MN/FB internet time. I read a lot. DH claims to be quite literary but I have never seem him read a whole book. He watches(not plays) Football. This has a REAL effect on logistics in the house, re bedtimes, weekends, holidays etc
I used to like walking - no-one else in the house is interested. Hmm Food for thought.

GoshAnneGorilla · 05/11/2013 19:08

"I don't tell men that I know a lot about Nick Drake. He's a musician that men like to tell women about as a reflection of their intensely melancholic souls."

Smile
OP posts:
Phineyj · 05/11/2013 18:36

I play in an orchestra and sing, and got Shock from a few people (mostly mums but one dad too) that I continued to do this during maternity leave (DH was quite happy for me to do so as he knew I would really enjoy the time out of the house). Music is not a very gendered hobby but I was surprised that people were surprised, if you see what I mean - the women said 'you must be very organised' and the man said 'but who's looking after the baby?' Hmm

My mother is a successful artist but does not need to earn much income from it as my DF has always earned well - I was rather angry to hear him dismiss it as a hobby recently - she has spent the last 35 years getting good at it amd very well respected by other artists!

freyasnow · 05/11/2013 18:26

I entirely agree with the OP.

I think there is a difference between children's hobbies and adult hobbies. DD dances and acts, but these are not considered appropriate hobbies for adult women a lot of the time, particularly not dancing. Dancing as an adult woman is perceived as something you do in a night club for purposes of sexual allurement (is that even a word?), or otherwise you are seen as making an exhibition of yourself if you dare to do it on amateur level on a stage. A woman who had a daughter in dance classes with DD said if her daughter still wanted to do dance classes as a teenager she would be embarrassed for her.

Stereotypical boys' hobbies, football and so on, are seen as a valuable pursuit in adult life.

I've gone back to acting as a hobby after a 20 year break, and I really enjoy it. I regret giving it up for twenty years, and there is a huge lack of women in their twenties doing drama as a hobby. I have the part of a woman in a play, and the man playing my husband is fifteen years younger than me, but there are no women his age to play the part. I don't know if that is local to me or a general trend. My much younger sister won't act as she feels she should no longer be doing it, and she has a drama degree and really misses acting. So I suppose I have got to the age where I am prepared to make a massive exhibition of myself.

I also RP with other women. I don't tell anyone in real life about that, given how unacceptable people seem to find it. I suppose as it a leisure activity that is purely for enjoyment it is a hobby.

Some male hobbies seem to be about buying stuff. I know a lot about Nick Drake and own all his records, but not on original vinyl. If I was a man and had spent thousands of pounds on the originals then it would be considered a hobby. I don't tell men that I know a lot about Nick Drake. He's a musician that men like to tell women about as a reflection of their intensely melancholic souls. It kind of ruins it for them if I actually confess to knowing more about his music than they do. Comic books probably also fall into this area for men; they see it as their domain, although staff in comic book shops are great with DD.

FairPhyllis · 05/11/2013 12:20

I have been irritated for quite a long time with how women's traditional crafts aren't valued, but I hadn't made the connection with how women's hobbies are either productive or everyday activities. Very interesting.

A lot of women do do drama and singing as hobbies, especially church choirs. More women do bell ringing now too. And there's walking and riding, which lots of the women I know do. Walking is a massive leisure sport and there are always loads of women in every hiking group.

But I don't think that sewing/crocheting type craft has always been the exclusive preserve of women. A lot of men in my family historically did crocheting and sewing and knitting because they were in the Navy and that's what lots of sailors did to pass the time.

WoTmania · 05/11/2013 08:17

Beaker - that sounds really annoying. I get a similar thing with rugby. My DSs play (DD wil once she's a bit older) everyone asks DH who he played for and which position and are then surprised to find out I was the rugby player not him. It never occurs to then that maybe it's the short slim female not the 6ft+ male.

beaker25 · 04/11/2013 21:28

Agree on the chick Lit thing. One Day is essentially chick lit, it's good but no better than a lot of other books out there by women. I know loads of people, men and women, who would have dismissed it had it been by a woman, as they don't like chick lit. Only they do like it, when it's by a man.

On the hobby thing, dh and I both do long distance cycling. We both do the same type of rides/ distances, but I've noticed lots of people will ask dh questions about it, but not me, or even acknowledge that i do it. When ride london was on tv, my mother said she had been looking out for dh in the coverage. I asked her why she didn't look for me, she said she assumed only dh would be able to do it! I've been quite surprised by quite how strange people are about it!

Takver · 29/10/2013 16:43

Forgot singing and drama - DH is very into singing / musical theatre, but he is always in a minority, mostly it is women.

Takver · 29/10/2013 16:42

"Perhaps some women still have hobbies - but which women? "

I have to say, I know lots of women who have hobbies - tri-athlon & long distance cycling (ie 100 mile races) seems to be very popular (men & women probably evenly), evening classes in various things (metalwork / furniture restoration / jewellery making / life drawing that I can think of). And in particular riding - if you see two people out on horses for a leisure ride, you can assume maybe 90% of the time if not more they will be women.

But, I live in a very rural area - a lot of people here whether originally from this area or incomers have made a choice of lifestyle over career IYSWIM (ie, those that valued career either left or didn't come here!). And of course it is only the women with disposable income that can do all this stuff (and also, on the whole I know either women without dc or women with older dc).

EBearhug · 29/10/2013 08:48

I do evening classes, currently yoga & Welsh. But funding for them has been massively cut in recent years.

I am single and childless, so I have the time for it, but when I was a child, we had babysitters on the nights both my parents were at classes. My mother was secretary for the local WEA, so I grew up thinking evening classes were something sll adults did. Except they don't.

I don't think of it as a luxury - it's something to use other parts of my brain that work doesn't and is important for my mental balance.

DixonBainbridge · 29/10/2013 08:24

Does it depend on what your perception of a Hobby is?

Surely if you do something you like doing - it's a hobby. If you're only focusing on hobbies that are covered in the mainstream media then you're limiting yourself hugely.

It doesn't have to involve evening classes, being in a group etc - many people have photography as a hobby & never join a club, stamp collecting is a hobby, gardening is a hobby....

I kayak & do photography & there are lots of women involved in those hobbies - kayaking especially! I also do RPGs and miniature wargaming - not so many there!

While I have a couple of hobbies, my DW says she has none - she loves the gardening & does it all, so that's a hobby right? It's time to relax doing something you enjoy.....

We've chatted about it in the past, but I can't really help as I'm a bit of a geek & nothing I do appeals - plus I think a hobby should be for her to have time & space away from the rest of us.

GoshAnneGorilla · 29/10/2013 00:45

"Perhaps some women still have hobbies - but which women? And perhaps the nature of hobbies has changed? How? And is it connected to other things (a longer working day; both parents working; the decline of subsidised adult learning and night-time adult education???)"

Good point. You don't hear of people going to evening classes as much as you once did.

If any Women's Studies types are reading, there's a PhD waiting to be done in this topic which I would love to read Smile.

OP posts:
thecatfromjapan · 28/10/2013 23:12

That's great, Tea. And it's given me a bit more of a push to take up a hobby myself. I want to but I feel guilty about the time.

I think of the gym as a female thing - too much "Cosmopolitan" too young, I think. Grin Gym is almost a woman's duty in many parts. And if not gym, then something cheap, like running - to lose weight, perhaps??

I keep thinking of a children's reading book from the 1970s I used with the children. It was a Teach-the-Time book. It had a picture of Mummy leaving the house at 7 to go to a painting class with her pal. I find that the idea of that kind of hobby - a "learning", class-based sort of thing, that one presumably paid for, at a reasonable hour (7), that isn't linked to some kind of economic return - really luxurious.

Perhaps some women still have hobbies - but which women? And perhaps the nature of hobbies has changed? How? And is it connected to other things (a longer working day; both parents working; the decline of subsidised adult learning and night-time adult education???)

There's been a conscious re-appropriation and re-evaluation of traditional female hobbies/crafts, too, hasn't there? I remember reading essays by people like Elaine Showalter on knitting and quilting and feminism back when I was a student. The tone of those essays were that these crafts were largely history, and the re-assessment was historical and conceptual, rather than actually doing them. Grin

EBearhug · 28/10/2013 22:58

The gym, sports clubs, etc are still seen as 'men's' domains, even though I've seen plenty of women in gyms who could run rings round some men!

Women are allowed to go to gyms. How else are you going to make sure you look good for your man? (No, I'm not serious.)

I do agree though that generally, women's hobbies don't have the same status as men's.

TeaMakesItAllPossible · 28/10/2013 22:55

This is an interesting topic.

I turned 40 last year and consciously took up 2 hobbies. Baking and returned to play hockey. I parent four wonderful boys. I wanted them to see that I enjoyed myself, was independent and could do the things they did (my baking is more akin to doing science and they play club sport too). I wanted to expand their expectations of the girls and women they meet. For me my hobbies were me making a feminist statement in my family.

Interestingly, I'm slightly baulking at the description 'hobbies' - I have found I need them to feel whole and content.

I have had some really interesting reactions to the fact I leave my family a couple of nights a week and half a day at the weekend. It's like I shouldn't because I work full time. My DH never gets the same reaction to his rugby playing and the boys are practically pushed out of the door my society expectations on them.

Why?

I have found my little feminist stand with my family has generated a wider impact I hadn't anticipated but I'm enjoying pushing hobby time for women is a right that should be taken to role model for the next generation.

Sorry if this is very lowbrow. I'm a lurker and learner from this topic - this is my first post.

GoshAnneGorilla · 28/10/2013 22:29

The cat - virtually all women's hobbies are productive in some way, or gussied up versions of everyday activities - grooming, eating, shopping.

It is pants.

OP posts:
thecatfromjapan · 28/10/2013 14:14

There's an overlap between the issue of women's (craft) activities, women's labour and women's right to non-productive time, isn't there? And that notion of "productive" is quite slippery, too, isn't it? (Am thinking now about whatdoesittake48 having produced Christmas presents from her leisure activity.)

It's a really interesting topic ...

GoshAnneGorilla · 28/10/2013 14:11

Ahh, but you see not only are crafty hobbies associated with women, they're associated with old women, so thus can't be truly valuable.

OP posts:
thecatfromjapan · 28/10/2013 12:30

Have we reached the point where we discuss women's jobs being considered "leisure time"? That still happens in my household. Which pisses me off.

whatdoesittake48 · 28/10/2013 12:26

I knit and crochet - in fact, I teach crocheting. I absolutely hate this stereotype of twee women/grannies with their knitting needles. it really winds me up. it is such a statement on our hobby and skill - that is is for old women with nothing better to do.

Strangely, my hobby has created nearly all our christmas presents this year, but is still regarded with amusement in our household...