Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Charles Saatchi. Oscar Pistorius, Roman Polanski, John Leslie, Mel Gibson, Charlie Sheen, J Simpson, Jimmy Savile, Chris Brown, Paul Gasgoigne,

169 replies

Greythorne · 18/06/2013 00:52

You know the way whenever we discuss DV, the menz crawl out and start the 'women commit DC just as much as men' routine?

Well, can anyone give me a list of high profile / world famous / Olympian women who have been photographed or found guilty or admitted to DV or sexual abuse?

OP posts:
OddSockMonster · 18/06/2013 11:18

I was going to suggest Samantha Kidd too, though I don't think the trial has happened yet so that's still an 'accused'.

I fully accept that men hitting women is more common and more injurous, but that women hitting men also happens and can also be pretty bad.

However, I think OP that your notion that well known celebrity cases correlates to actual statistics (reported or not) doesn't add up.

A lack of high profile female abusers should not detract from abuse of men, in the same way as the presence of abuse of men should not diminish the abuse of women. It's all bad.

Francagoestohollywood · 18/06/2013 11:17

Joan Crowford

scallopsrgreat · 18/06/2013 11:03

But DV isn't balanced namechangeguy. That is the point. It is gendered. It is mainly perpetrated by men and women and children are mainly the victims.

Greythorne · 18/06/2013 11:01

I accept that Jimmy Savile probably does not fall into the DV category. More serial predator.

OP posts:
namechangeguy · 18/06/2013 11:00

If people are keen to point out that DV is perpetrated by both sexes, then perhaps it is so we can start a discussion from a more balanced perspective. I am no expert, but I managed to find links to surveys that point to high levels of female-on-male DV pretty quickly. You do not have to be a crazed MRA to point this out.

Most of them stress that although women do get violent, the violence towards women is more serious in terms of the physical harm caused, because of men's greater strength. So, even if the ratio was 50:50 (which it isn't), the outcomes are worse for women in terms of physical injury.

Re the celebrity angle, there have been many pointed out already, but I am not sure it helps us examine the causes much. And surely, isn't that the point of any DV discussion? Why does it happen, and what can we do about it?

Mugofteaforme · 18/06/2013 10:50

Samantha Kidd (Eddie Kidds wife)

but then again you won't get anything close to a full disclosure on Female on Male DV as the supports virtually non existant, although improving.

Greythorne · 18/06/2013 10:48

No, namechangeguy sadly, it is all too well established that DV occurs Hmm. But the MRAs on here are all too quick to point out that DV is perpertrated by women as well as men. Which I am sure it is, on some level.

In the past few days there has been much talk about DV happening in wealthy, celebrity households, ones whose public image are very much predicated on domestic bliss. So, we've got a real life example that male on female DV happens in places where one might not expect it.

I personally am not aware of masses of female on male DV in celebrity circles - which should be happening if DV is as common by women as men.

I would not have thought it was too hard to understand the point of the thread.

OP posts:
namechangeguy · 18/06/2013 10:42

Yes I can. I can also read the OP. Did you mean only sexual abuse within a close relationship? Because that isn't how it reads.

I think the whole thread is a bit odd, to be honest, and deliberately designed to provoke an argument. What are you trying to establish? That DV occurs? That men do it? That they do it more than women? That there are simple reasons for it? That all cases are the same? That you have a solution?

Greythorne · 18/06/2013 10:36

namechangeguy

Can't see the difference between being attacked / sexually abused by the individual you are married to and the crimes of serial psychopaths?
Both crimes are horrific but really apples and pears.

OP posts:
namechangeguy · 18/06/2013 10:33

Greythorne, the OP said DV or sexual abuse. I think they both qualify under that heading.

Greythorne · 18/06/2013 10:30

eccelesvet

Oh, I had never read that. She does sound like a lunatic.

OP posts:
Greythorne · 18/06/2013 10:30

namechangeguy

hmmmm, psychopaths both but not known for attacking their spouses. We're discussing DV.

OP posts:
namechangeguy · 18/06/2013 10:09

Rose West and Myra Hindley.

Greythorne · 18/06/2013 09:55

Bubbles

I agree with every word.

such a cop out...."there are probably loads of men being abused but they don't come forward because it is so humiliating / embarrassing for them"

Whereas women who are thumped, strangled, threatened by their partners are not at all huliliated or embarrassed?

Useful to note here that Nigella did not come forward after the throttling at Scott's restaurant to denounce her sad excuse for a husband. Only once the pics were published and the facts were public did she leave the house. And even now she has not made a public statement.

Could it be that she feels shame, humiliation, worthless that this man strangles her? But now she is being expected to stand up against domestic violence and make a stand because she is wealthy.

Whereas the putative men who are subjected to assault by their wives can't possibly be expected to make a stand.

OP posts:
SabrinaMulhollandJjones · 18/06/2013 09:54

Geoffrey Boycott

I'm quite shocked to see John Lennon & Sean Connery on the list Shock Wasn't aware of that at all.

The whole thing just makes me so thoroughly depressed.

scallopsrgreat · 18/06/2013 09:52

This is a great blog post about the gendered nature of DV. Debunks a lot of these so called stats quoted by MREs. She does a lot of work in this area and is very knowledgeable. Her blog is worth reading in general.

scallopsrgreat · 18/06/2013 09:42

"I have to disagree with this idea that women feel okay to be open about DV" Agreed. It is not insignificant that it was Charles Saatchi who has made a statement as to what happened in the restaurant and not Nigella.

BubblesOfBliss · 18/06/2013 09:40

I have to disagree with this idea that women feel okay to be open about DV. It is humiliating and awful to be victimised in whatever way it occurs. There is a myth that victimisation is worse and more shameful or humiliating for men than women in any situation- therefore men are less likely to speak about it.

Most victims of rape/CSA/DV/etc don't tell anyone about it ever - because they feel ashamed, afraid, guilty and humiliated by it. Women don't have any less of these feelings of shame than men. This myth persists because women's social status and perceived value is lower than men, so it is assumed they deserve victimisation/violation as a result and don't suffer as much because of it.

The prevalent misogynist assumption is present in rape conviction rates - male rape victims are far more likely to be viewed favourably by a jury and see their attackers behind bars than women.

And another thing. Men do speak about being victims of DV - frequently when women are arrested for DV it comes to light that the man has been abusive in the past and called the police immediately at a relatively minor infraction perpetrated by the woman compared to his own misdeeds. Also, how about the so-called MRAs who make a point of misrepresenting the prevalence of female on male DV to claim that men as a sex are victimised by women? That bullshit is swallowed whole by people who believe that men are more hurt by victimisation than women.

scallopsrgreat · 18/06/2013 09:37

John Wayne wasn't shy at flying his fists around either

Greythorne · 18/06/2013 09:37

cross post scallop

OP posts:
Greythorne · 18/06/2013 09:36

And a quick google serach throws up:

Edward Furlong (Terminator 2 actor): jailed for attacking his wife in LAX airport

Ike Turner

Phil Spector

Nicolas Cage

And for those citing Pistorius's ongoing court case:

In 2009, the 26-year-old paralympian, who was the first double amputee to ever compete in the Olympics, was arrested and spent a night in jail after allegedly physically assaulting a 19-year-old girl at his house.

The girl had been asked to leave a party Oscar was hosting, and when she refused, he slammed the front door on her, incidentally catching the girl?s leg with it. The door-slamming inflicted bruises on the girl, and Oscar was initially charged with assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm. The next day, the charge was reduced to common assault, and a month later prosecutors dropped the charges.

OP posts:
scallopsrgreat · 18/06/2013 09:34

Nicholas Cage

scallopsrgreat · 18/06/2013 09:32

Bing Crosby

namechangeguy · 18/06/2013 09:20

John Wayne and Humphrey Bogart were both knocked about by their wives. Who'd have thought it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread