Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Been out. It's not pretty out there. My feminist views are challenged tonight.

345 replies

dummad · 27/01/2013 01:22

Hello, just a quickie coz I'm a bit drunk.

I've been out tonight in a bar in town - a trendy bar. Getting to the point, I'm disappointed ladies. I'm disappointed in what I've seen. Why do young women stand around dressed up like a dog's dinners looking bored out of their minds out of choice? I'm trying very hard not to think it, but I'm on the slippery slope of thinking women don't help themselves be taken seriously when they portray themselves the way they do. I know it's about choice and whatnot, but why CHOOSE to look like little fuck toys if you don't have to? Sorry. I just find it difficult to fly the feminist flag after what I've seen tonight. It's like young women don't give a flying toss about being empowered. They all look the same - tarty, vacuous and vacant. ALL of them. Hundreds of them. There wasn't one young lady in the place tonight without a horrendously short skirt on and killer heals. One group got out of the taxi and had garters tattood around her upper thigh. The men in the queue outside hardly batted an eyelid but one was there making sort of animal gestures to them like he was in a zoo. Maybe that's the sort of reaction these girls wanted.

In the bar guys couldn't even be bothered to approach the women by the looks of it. For two hours we were in there and I didn't see any notable, interaction between the sexes. Of course you'll never get a guy complaining about the way the girls look - they just lap it all up from a distance - it's all just laid out for them and saves the entry fee into the local lap dancing club I guess. They don't give a shit. Sluttier the better in their view. Why the hell don't women today backlash against it? I'd understand if it were a few of them like that but it was all of them. I'm sure they're intelligent, well bought up girls as well. So can't blame it on ignorance/ upbringing or whatever. They are a fucking disgrace.

You know what - I want you to put me right. I want you to tell me I'm wrong and there is hope and that women are aspiring for empowerment and campaign that they are respected as equals. It's up to them isn't it? They are the next generation after all. Don't they honestly care about their place in society? Don't they want to improve things like misrepresentation in the media and violence against women and lower wages etc? Don't they want to be taken seriously? Is this what has happened when women are contented? Is this what we choose to be by default? If so, it's no wonder men look down on us.

OP posts:
Xenia · 30/01/2013 09:22

SGB raises good points. The women may not want to bother with all that dull marriage stuff and house cleaning and just want some good sex and they dress in a way that is most likely to obtain them that and which they enjoy.

I am more concerned about UK Muslim areas which are requiring women to cover up on the streets and not be public sexual beings whereas many women want sexual freedom (and may not all be out there in rich husband catching mode although that also remains a choice of women which men tend not to have.. mind you there are not that many men around who earn much more than most women so plenty of them fail to hook the meal ticket for life)

MrsHelsBels74 · 30/01/2013 08:22

If I had a better figure I'd wear short skirts & killer heels once in a while but I'm happily married so it certainly wouldn't be to pull. I love high heels, they just make me feel the same height as everyone else so glamorous.

TheDoctrineOfSciAndNatureClub · 30/01/2013 07:39

You could be onto something there, Abi Grin

AbigailAdams · 30/01/2013 07:27

I think it really means "I have a right to be agreed with", Doctrrine Grin

TheDoctrineOfSciAndNatureClub · 30/01/2013 07:10

I have never understood what the phrase "I have a right to my opinion" means in the context of lots of people talking about their opinions.

garlicblocks · 30/01/2013 01:17

Females seeking attention through blatant sexual exhibitionism

Oooh, were they stripping off and giving lap dances?

And is it OK for males to seek attention through blatant sexual exhibitionism?

.

I do think there are conversations to be had about sexual objectification and, in particular, pornification. But this isn't it. You are talking about fashion.

garlicblocks · 30/01/2013 01:06

I've skipped from page 2 to page 12 to see if anyone had posted the obvious remark that some of those women probably are on the pull, and good luck to them Grin SGB, I hope your post above wasn't the first to say so. The worryingly judgemental timbre of many posts makes me fear it might be, though.

Dummad, I find it easy to believe in your good intentions but you come over as misogynistic. You are conflating a girl's choice of going-out clothes with her morals, intelligence, politics and professional abilities. This is a little bit odd, if you think about it. If one could buy an entire personality, brain, political outlook and moral compass from Net-a-Porter, life would be fun! Seriously, clothes say all that to you? Don't be daft.

What if you saw the same crowd of youngsters at a funeral? I somehow doubt you'd have rushed on here to complain about the glum condition of Young People Today, all wearing black and looking solemn, not even flirting much Shock

People wear whatever convention dictates they wear to a particular event. That's all. See them next year, they'll be dressed a bit differently. See them at a different pub; different again.

Actually, on re-reading you, you sound a bit like a frustrated prude. Oops, I nearly said dirty old man, sorry!

Have you already told the thread what you and your companion/s were wearing? I'd like to complete my mental picture of the gathering.

FreyaSnow · 29/01/2013 23:54

Dummad, of course you have a right to an opinion; nobody here has a gun to your head. I do think it is judgmental to make assumptions about people based on their clothes, but I'm not judging you or making assumptions about you based on your opinion. You could be running a dog foster service for victims of domestic violence for all I know.

You're also drawing massive assumptions about people's wider views based on statements they've made about clothes. I don't believe in individualism in terms of political action; concern for all women is what is required, but I don't think what you wear or don't wear really constitutes much of a political action. It is just surface clutter.

Booyhoo · 29/01/2013 23:48
  1. what is thsi bloody obsession you have with teh non existent connection between what a woman wears out with friends on a saturday night and whether she is any good at her job?

2)does anyone look at men out on a saturday night an dthink " ?Oh, how refreshing to see young men acting all liberated. I reckon he?s on for a raise come Monday morning?."? no they dont because the two situations are not connected and no-one would ever think to loof for taht connection where men are concerned so why make it an issue for women?

Booyhoo · 29/01/2013 23:42
Grin

it was an obvious one, i couldn't let it slide!

dummad · 29/01/2013 23:38

I can understand why the OP caused controversy and caused a bit of a back lash, but I also think it's a shame not everyone is as prepared as I am to listen to an alternative view. I have since thought quite a lot about the consequences of criticising individual choice and felt pretty bad that I was acting all ?judgey?. But at least I was willing to have the debate in the first place. I guess it?s just turned out as a case of ?well I?m offended because you?re offended? and ?you?re a horrible person for judging?, even though that?s just judging me ? proving we?re all doing the same and no one can ever be right.
So, am I a feminist? Well, the word feminist means different things to different people. One the one hand a feminist may support closing lap dancing clubs on the basis they objectify women, on the other they may agree with the woman?s choice to work in the sex industry. Both have women?s issues at heart, both of them coming at the same subject from opposing angles. Both can class themselves as feminists.

I am not a misogynist. Only because I think the choices of some women are objectionable, it doesn?t mean I hate women in general. Being a feminist doesn?t mean you have to see eye to eye with every female and agree with what they do.
I still believe that by regularly wearing overly provocative clothing out in public as part of the status quo only serves to keep women shackled by the notion we are primarily sex objects. Where it has been suggested young women are just trying to be fashionable, it?s worth pointing out that by slavishly following fads and trends they are still playing into the hands of men as the fashion industry is male dominated. One way or another they are being dictated to by men.
I favour the view that women should take control of their own destinies independently of men and that if we haven?t yet got to where we want to then that is largely down to us. It?s a right wing view that is probably not one shared by the more liberal minded MNers who tend to believe glass ceilings and sexist politicians are the ones to blame for repressing us - both of which I think would be easy to smash and break if we all pulled together for a common cause. This liberal view also tends to support the sort of individualism that is evident from the ?don?t give a toss what anyone thinks about me' people contributing to this thread.
And should we care what men think? Absolutely. Because if we don?t care about what they think ? why on earth should they care about what we think? Men continue to own a privileged position in society and so it does matter how we come across to them so that we can eventually win their confidence and their vote!
Everyone should think about how they come across when they are out in public ? it?s just practicing basic self-respect. It?s just how civilisation has evolved. And I can assure you there won?t be many people ? male or female - that would see what I saw on Saturday night and think ?Oh, how refreshing to see young women acting all liberated. I reckon she?s on for a raise come Monday morning?. No way. Females seeking attention through blatant sexual exhibitionism in public is to me counterproductive behaviour to being taken seriously as women. Everyone has the right to pick what they wear. I have a right to my opinion. Simple as that.

OP posts:
BegoniaBampot · 29/01/2013 23:36

Hardehaar! took a few seconds to work that one out! Don't we all look worse naked!

Booyhoo · 29/01/2013 23:21

what, you mean naked?

BegoniaBampot · 29/01/2013 23:17

And then after going to all that effort, many of them actually look awful and a lot worse than their more natural state.

BegoniaBampot · 29/01/2013 23:15

Whatever the men wear they are more likely to be practical, comfortable and warm and have spent less time and perhaps money on their appearance. Women seem to go to extremes to do the opposite. Isn't a surprise men might think some women come across as more frivolous, different priorities, not to be taken as serious and out to attract attention.

Agree the look of the moment tends to veer towards transvestite (ha, like that one), glamour model, porn star rather then prostitute.

Booyhoo · 29/01/2013 22:19

kim from experience i can tell you that men have as much variation in their dress style than women whether they are on the pull or not.

different men have different styles. some wil wear a shirt and trousers. some jeans and a t-shirt, some shorts and a muscle vest. depends again, what type of place you're in.

kim147 · 29/01/2013 22:14

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

FreyaSnow · 29/01/2013 22:11

I agree with SGB that women may be out looking for casual sex, and some will want male sexual attention and to pay sexual attention to men, and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that whatsoever. But I also think you usually can't tell that from somebody's clothing.

Booyhoo · 29/01/2013 22:07

exactly lapsed

SBG i agree. all these posters hoiking judgy pants up in horror at a women dressed as if she is only after one thing might like to consider the idea that she is indeed after only one thing and there is nothing at all wrong with a woman going out with the intention of finding someone to have a ONS with.

SolidGoldBrass · 29/01/2013 21:47

But most of the women who wear revealing clothes in bars and clubs at the weekend don't wear clothes like that to go round the supermarket, walk their dogs or go to work. Dressing in clothes that are 'sexy' according to current mainstream culture may be actively saying 'I want some NSA sex tonight.'
I see some posters fainting with horror at the idea of casual sex and implying that this is the terrible fate that awaits women who dress in revealing clothes - but they are missing the point that sometimes a woman wants casual sex. And this is a good thing (though not, obviously, something people should do when they really don't like the idea). The more young women engage in casual sex because they are horny, and too busy with their lives to want to 'settle down' with a man, the better: the insistence that women have to have 'love' to enjoy sex means too many women put up with men who are crap in bed and crap at being partners, because they believe that having 'let' the man have sex with them, they now have to maintain a relationship with him even though he's not up to much.

LapsedPacifist · 29/01/2013 21:27

I would say the hyper-feminine Towie/Geordie Shore look owes far more to conventions of transvestite entertainment than actual (as opposed to fantasy) prostitution. It's an absurd exaggeration of what women are 'supposed' to look like and is 99% fake - hair, skin (dyed) lashes, nails, tits etc etc. Working girls on the street dress for comfort and have to be able to scarper/defend themselves at short notice.

LineRunner · 29/01/2013 20:26

I think a lot of posters on MN do not understand the most common sexual 'services' performed by prostitues that they are likely to fail to see on the streets.

FreyaSnow · 29/01/2013 19:55

SSS, some women who dress in that highly groomed but covered up 'classy' way do it for male approval or attention and others do not. You simply cannot assume all women have the same intentions as yourself in life. Is it really that difficult to talk to other women rather than make assumptions about them?

As for biological urges, it's fairly easy to get them met whatever you're wearing. Prostitutes tend to wear casual clothes - jeans, tshirts etc, so I've no idea how you think that spills over into clubwear.

Booyhoo · 29/01/2013 19:13

"And for posters who get all prickly when prostitutes are mentioned, the way a sex worker dresses hasn't changed all that remarkably over the decades."

did you see my earlier post? have you met any prostitutes in RL?

Xenia · 29/01/2013 15:55

Obviously they dress within their class and group in a way that attracts men. Now that may be with more or less covered depending on your grouping (and if it's your Alpha bible class in London it may be a skirt to the floor) but whatever your grouping young girls that age choose to play the game to attract a man in the main. I would rather mumsnet campaigned to support one proposed legal change - public nudity than repression and censorship which tends to be its usual supported cause.