Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Is there another word for oppression ?

34 replies

Blistory · 06/07/2012 14:50

In the context of the patriarchy oppresses women ? I know what I mean by it, I know that most posters in this section understand what is meant by it but it seems to be a term that causes some women to automatically rebel against feminism.

Most the of the circular arguments on MN seem to go along the lines of
'but it's my choice therefore I'm a feminist exercising my choice'
'no you're not, you have no choice'
'I am a strong indepedent woman, feminisim has achieved its aims and I can do what I want'
'no, you think you have choice but you don't really because you are oppressed'
'I am not oppressed, sod off, you nutcase feminist'

Obviously that's not a serious example.....

How the hell do we get around this everyday thinking without attacking, without patronising ? There must be a better way to have these discussions but damned if I can think of it.

Is oppression as a word too emotive and if so, how better could this be phrased ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EclecticShock · 08/07/2012 20:15

Garlic, I agree with using the appropriate word for the situation or context.

garlicbutter · 08/07/2012 15:57

Actually, it's very like grooming. Only, then, wouldn't you get into disagreements about whether grooming was the consequence of grooming? Grin

Sexism. What's wrong with it.

I do try to use the appropriate word: sexism; patronisation; gendercide; violence against women; belittling; dismissing; discounting; assault; harassment; objectification; pornification (if that even is a word); abuse; bullying ... Grandiose or quasi-technical terms make me feel alienated, so I really understand why others get pissed off by them.

Wrt patriarchy, I don't know. It's only a concept so, whatever you call it, it's easy to discount. My immensely long, explanatory post on the "stupid" thread was roundly ignored, even by those who would trash my take on it.

Whatmeworry · 08/07/2012 11:56

There is always "grooming"....

HmmThinkingAboutIt · 08/07/2012 00:04

I so believe that you can be trapped by the word 'can't' as much as trapped by any outside force.

In order to build self confidence on a personal level, people are taught to do positive affirmations; and yet as soon as you start talking about the word 'oppression' you do quite the reverse for women as a group.

There has to be shifts in attitude from within as much as changes in attitude from without.

I'd live to do a really positively minded thread in this section to that end. I'm still trying to think of a good way to do that...

EclecticShock · 07/07/2012 20:18

So true sometimes :)

Himalaya · 07/07/2012 20:17

Eclectic - shaping is what we think we do when we bring up children, coping is what we really do Grin

EclecticShock · 07/07/2012 20:15

Oppression implies unnecessary and wrong. Shaping can be a positive process.

EclecticShock · 07/07/2012 20:14

Don't want to cause a problem but "shaping" to me is what we do with children when we being them up so can be either good or bad for them. In terms of feminist are we not saying that "shaping" is bad or is that dependent on the paricular discussion?

Blistory · 07/07/2012 07:34

Shaping it is then. Thank you for all your thoughts on this.

OP posts:
yellowraincoat · 07/07/2012 00:01

shape is good.

WilsonFrickett · 06/07/2012 23:23

Yy what and also in the sense that we are shaping a lot of this ourselves, IYSWIM. I don't oppress myself, but I do shape my own choices, opportunities, actions, etc.

24HourPARDyPerson · 06/07/2012 23:20

yes it was my own greenhouse analogy that's shit - I did say I really liked the birdcage one.

Whatmeworry · 06/07/2012 23:15

I like the sense of "shaped" - I think there is a lot of shaping - diverting, seductive whispering, financial bribery - going on, rather than hard visible barriers.

WilsonFrickett · 06/07/2012 23:11

I use constrained and shaped a lot. I don't think I am oppressed - not when I put it in the context of women who can't get an education, birth control, abortions etc etc. that's maybe me kidding myself a little bit, but I do think I am constrained, not oppressed. Now, you could argue, in my personal context, that's just as bad. And I would agree. But I do have fundamentally more choice than many women in the world today.

Himalaya · 06/07/2012 22:58

I don't think she was....it was about her own greenhouse analogy (?)

LostinaPaperCup · 06/07/2012 22:41

I would read the whole book before dismissing the birdcage analogy as 'shit'.

Himalaya · 06/07/2012 22:37

I'd go with constrain.

I know everyone is constrained in some way, but still you can think about ways in which women's choices are particularly constrained.

24HourPARDyPerson · 06/07/2012 22:20

i wouldn't dream of eating the damn thing, the state its in at the moment Yellow. Looks like a clogged storm drain.

That'd probably be the overwatering

Whatmeworry · 06/07/2012 22:19

Agree totally the term kyriarchy, if it were to become well-known, would get the same level of shit that patriarchy currently gets

Yup, its called the euphemism treadmill.

But I don't think "Patriarchy" or Oppression are accurate terms any more, which is why they don't resonate.

The "patriarchy" is shafting non-alpha males as much if not harder than women in many respects, and I think most women sense this. It is more of an Oligarchy IMO

"Oppression" also doesn't - IMO - describe the situation in the OECD now - it is much more subtle, more invisible. You are not "barred" any more, but it is a world of invisible glass ceilings and softly closed doors. I don't know what the best word is, but IMO a lot of it is now within the mind, enchained by celebrity culture and a dumbing down of mass media rather than outside bars.

yellowraincoat · 06/07/2012 22:08

Ooh don't overwater the basil, it takes away the flavour.

Apparently.

yellowraincoat · 06/07/2012 22:08

Agree totally the term kyriarchy, if it were to become well-known, would get the same level of shit that patriarchy currently gets.

If people aren't willing to admit that male oppression exists, why would they want to admit that it exists alongside homophobia, racism etc.

24HourPARDyPerson · 06/07/2012 22:04

...but am oppressed by societies' expectation that analogies not be shit

24HourPARDyPerson · 06/07/2012 22:01

I'd say pretty soon Kyriarchy as a term would start getting loaded and - what a surprise - you're a professionally offended nutcase for even bringing it up.

love the birdcage analogy.

was going to share my brand new greenhouse analogy which I invented only moments ago while watering the limp basil pot on windowsill herb garden

yellowraincoat · 06/07/2012 21:56

I teach kids from other countries at the moment.

I noticed that the 15 year old Russian girl I was teaching didn't shave her legs. I wonder what the norm is there.

LostinaPaperCup · 06/07/2012 21:55

Of course not. The last time I went on a beach holiday abroad (bloody yonks ago) I did notice that all the women had hairless legs. It's not like beards which would carry on growing. Leg hair is like arm hair: it stops. No need to remove it, yet all women had removed it. Choice my arse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread