Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

New left project: Is porn hijacking our sexuality?

88 replies

WidowWadman · 05/04/2012 21:34

3 part debate between Sarah Ditum and Gail Dines on the topic, very interesting reading.

Must say that I tend to agree more with Ditum than with Dines. And also found Petra Boyton's quote very interesting:

?The evidence base on the effects of pornography is not particularly clear, given that many studies are limited by small samples; riddled with experimenter expectancy effects and demand characteristics; poorly designed and poorly reported lab-based research that often features male undergraduates who?re not representative of the wider population.?

Boynton continues: ?It?s not to say all porn research is bad, but because the majority of studies are so flawed it?s very difficult to draw any clear conclusions from them ? particularly around direct causal links between images and actions. Unfortunately this confusion leads to both pro and anti pornography groups cherry-picking particular studies to suit their respective agendas.?

It supports my view that, whilst porn admittedly is very problematic, the world isn't simply black and white, and neither the pro nor the anti porn argument is without flaws.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AliceHurled · 18/04/2012 08:37

Thing is, if you do n't want to do something, don't do it. But don't insist that anyone who does do it can't possibly be enjoying it coerced. And let's not blur the lines between ignore the wider context of a person woman being coerced into performing a sexual activity for a porn film and a person woman performing a sexual activity for a porn film which that person woman doesn't gain any immediate pleasure from, but is happy paid to act out as a performance.

oilfilledlamp · 17/04/2012 23:03

Thank you for the links Widow and it made excellent reading (now in four parts, sorry for the pedantry).

I'm on Dines's side. LRD asked what is feminist porn? It's a ruse set up by the pornographic industry to distract from all the gonzo porn that is the mainstay. The industry/hegemony makes billions of the oiled backs of naked people pretending to enjoy sex. When it's just a job. You couldn't make it up.

Like we'd all watch a fly on the wall documentary about someone flipping burgers in a greasy spoon. They smile a lot and tell you in the toilet that it's just a job. Yeah! Real w*nking material that is.

solidgoldbrass · 17/04/2012 22:57

Thing is, if you don't want to do something, don't do it. But don't insist that anyone who does do it can't possibly be enjoying it. And let's not blur the lines between a person being coerced into performing a sexual activity for a porn film and a person performing a sexual activity for a porn film which that person doesn't gain any immediate pleasure from, but is happy to act out as a performance.

Molasses · 17/04/2012 21:10

I know that a lot of sex involves mental turn-ons as much as physical ones, but when there is NO physical enjoyment for any participant, it is ONLY psychological.
Taking the physical pleasure out of a blow-job (or the knowledge of giving physical pleasure) leaves just the dominant/submissive aspect. I find it quite disturbing to say the least.

thechairmanmeow · 17/04/2012 18:26

if you get no pleasure from sucking a plastic phallus, heres an idea...dont!
but if you think all porn is patriachal or no women enjoy porn your simply dreaming.
maybe make a complaint to the masterbatory regulator (OFFTOSS).

as for worshiping the mighty god-cock, i think most porn actresses will laugh in your face.

LRDtheFeministDragon · 17/04/2012 14:13

I think Gail Dines is very shrewd and very thorough. She knows her stuff and she analyzes it well.

I just wanted to ask:

'Anyway, it's so obvious that porn is hijacking our sexuality. You only have to check out the relationships section. Porn is increasingly violent, feminist porn barely exists and is not hit upon, lesbian porn is a niche serving men mostly. Gay sex is a niche that is becoming increasingly marginalised. Mostly porn is about double penetration, double anal, multiple facials, and the obvious hurting of females.'

What is 'feminist porn'? I think that is an oxymoron.

And no, I'd rather no-one link to porn on this thread, if that's ok.

InAnyOtherSoil · 17/04/2012 14:00

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AliceHurled · 17/04/2012 11:38

I love the idea that there is some reason that a women would enjoy sucking on a plastic dick that is nothing to do with patriarchy. Wonderful Grin There must be nothing that can't be claimed left.

Beachcomber · 17/04/2012 10:36

Sucking a strap on is awesomely pleasurable for a woman cos it is symbolic of penis worshipping, obviously.

And everyone knows laydeez just worship the mighty penis (especially lesbian feminist laydeez).

There is nothing patriarchal about porn depicting women sucking plastic penises. At all. No siree.

solidgoldbrass · 17/04/2012 00:36

Crackedceiling: well, a (heterosexual)woman might want to suck a penis because doing so gives the man whos penis it is pleasure - many particular sexual activies are engaged in, not because they bring physical pleasure to the person doing them but because there is psychological sexual pleasure to be gained from giving a partner pleasure. This isn't to say that a sexual encounter should be 'all one way' but there's nothing wrong with taking turns to give and receive. And sucking a strap on, while there is no physical pleasure involved, can be fun to do as performance, roleplay, feeling transgressive, fantasy enactment, all that sort of thing.

Molasses · 17/04/2012 00:07

Another Anna Span scene description (couldn't bring myself to watch another clip) was all about a man telling two 'barmaids' that he knew what women REALLY wanted in bed.

It's truly progressive stuff, this 'feminist' porn.

crackedceiling · 17/04/2012 00:00

@widow "whilst porn admittedly is very problematic," You don't say why porn is problematic. Can you elucidate?

crackedceiling · 16/04/2012 23:56

Why would women want to suck anything? We did that at our mother's breast or on our dummies. And that gave us pleasure but we gave it up before we went to school, though apologies to those who did this later?

Why would sucking anything in adulthood give us pleasure?

InAnyOtherSoil · 16/04/2012 23:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Molasses · 16/04/2012 23:19

^ Was to SGB

Molasses · 16/04/2012 23:18

Just looked at a trailer for one of Anna Span's films and there was a woman sucking another woman's strap-on.

Which woman is getting the pleasure here, and why?

InAnyOtherSoil · 16/04/2012 22:07

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

solidgoldbrass · 16/04/2012 22:05

Well at the moment (fecking dongle content lock) I can't post links to adult websites. I can advise you to look up the work of Anna Span and Petra Joy, if you want.

crackedceiling · 16/04/2012 21:07

SGB said: "I've watched a lot of porn DVDs over the past 5 years and I have seen a variety of stuff, very very little of which featured 'the obvious hurting of females' as its main selling point. Most of what I watched showed people having fun and sometimes women having what looked like genuine orgasms. Some of the performers looked a bit bored sometimes, and some of the dialogue was unpleasant (and in all my reviewing I always made the case for stuff that looked like fun and sent the message that this is all about fun not hurting people in a non-consensual way), but most of it was just about all-round enjoyment."

Why don't you post links to this porn that brings you so much 'enjoyment'?

InAnyOtherSoil · 16/04/2012 20:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

thechairmanmeow · 16/04/2012 17:41

i thought it was relevent to the debate ...is it inappropriate?

AliceHurled · 16/04/2012 17:30

What makes you think people are in the least bit interested in hearing about your porn habits? How on earth do you think that is appropriate? Hmm

thechairmanmeow · 16/04/2012 17:27

I disagree totaly , but, i cannot speak for all men but i find double penitration, bukake etc not attall sexy i can honestly say it does nothing for me ,probobly like most men i find i click on the same couple of catagories of porn , for me it;s 'milfs' and 'hairy' ( hairy , like i have the fetish! it should be called 'normal') but the poster that said women over 30 are not prevelent and over 40 are defunct is totaly wrong, i think she would be very suprised.

as for califonia made porn by professionals with pneumatic silicone breasts, i can honestly say i would rather watch grass grow. i think that pornographers have no clue as to what constitutes erotica.

BDSM, well you either get it or you dont, it isnt for everyone, but let me say this, the submissive has the kink, tourture , you would assume is detrimental to the individual being tourturd, except within BDSM where the sub activily wants the pain or humiliation or whatever, you should not assume too many things about some of the violent types of porn out there , safe sane and consentual is there rule ( SSC )

crackedceiling · 16/04/2012 01:37

@ Widow, seeing how you started this thread and all.

Facial 78,800,000
Feminist sex 38,300,000
Teen porn 205,000,000
MILTF 2,400,000
Elder sex 70,400,000"

You excluded this from your scientific paltry look at the google search I'd done.

Teen porn is pretty specific don't you think? Why did you exclude this? Facial I put in there because that's exactly a word that includes have your facial at this beauty salon. I didn't go for bukkake on that search deliberately. Big fail at the science Hmm. You bring to this thread your own preconceptions with nothing to back them up. Just to deliberately wind people up.

Huge fail.

crackedceiling · 16/04/2012 01:30

rageagainstthemanchine.com/2012/03/15/porn-part-11-the-difference-between-huffing-dong-and-flipping-burgers/

Hi SGB and Widow. Thank you for responding. But I feel that's all you do. Respond. Please show me figures that suggest that porn is wonderful, helpful to sexuality and all empowering. I'd like to see those figures. What did you make of elder sex, as opposed to MILTF? I was quite taken aback about that.

Take a look at the video on this post. I tried to put a link direct to youtube but you need to sign in before you do it.

Love hurts. As someone a man, once sang.