Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

New parent not sure what to think about the endless pinkness.

33 replies

Doodlegoogle · 14/03/2012 23:26

I'm expecting my first child - a girl.

I've started looking for a few clothes naively expecting to find plenty of choice and a range of colours and styles.

Admittedly, I've not looked far, just in the supermarkets, a couple of online places and a nearly new sale. I'm finding myself increasing disturbed by the sea of pink and am leaping on anything that isn't 'girly'.

I'm really struggling to work out what I think about this.

Part of me thinks - its just a colour. I personally quite like pink and wear a fair amount. Its not like I feel its ever affected my views as how could a mere colour do that and I consider myself a feminist. Its my stepson and my nephews favourite colour and as a wider family we've never really given that any thought so why should it matter whether a girl wears it or not. I've not previously had any issue with pink one way or the other before now.

Another part of me is developing a seriously strong aversion to anything pink and I'm somehow finding it all rather sinister. I can't believe that such tiny children are labelled 'blue' or 'pink' from such a young age and what is starting to feel like regimented uniform on the basis of gender. I really don't remember wearing much pink as a child at all and somehow am finding the whole thing sickening.

I can't work out if I'm just completely over reacting to what is simply a colour as really what difference should it make? She can wear pink, blue or rainbow coloured spots and it shouldn't make any difference. Surely, I think, there are more important things to worry about. And yet, somehow it just feels wrong and I can't quite rationalise why.

What do others think? Over-reaction or not? And if I'm reacting like this to the first tiny issue how am I going cope as a parent of a daughter when more serious things come along!?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SmellsLikeTeenStrop · 15/03/2012 21:20

I was chatting to my sister about this a couple of days ago and neither of us remember having much in the way of pink clothing as children. All the photos of me I'm in trousers and dungarees in earthy colours combined with bright primary colours.

This was inspired by a party we'd both been to with our DCs, a couple had brought their baby, just starting to toddle and they'd dressed her in a huge pink meringue of dress. I really hate it when baby girls are treated like dollies. We judged, I am unrepentant.

PenguinArmy · 15/03/2012 21:18

Ninth Was that an open invitation to PM? Have a 5 month DS

GrimmaTheNome · 15/03/2012 21:06

Blackcurrants - Next sometimes has pink (fuschia) stuff for boys. (supposedly - I couldn't find any sensible woolies for girls, got a next v-necked 'boys' one for DD. Her BFF had a similar but pale pink 'boys' wooly from marks. Both girls prefer various shades of green though Grin)

NinthWave · 15/03/2012 21:05

Oh and in case I sounded a bit smug there Blush - DS1's favourite outfit is a Batman costume, and he lives in self-chosen character/superhero t-shirts these days!

InmaculadaConcepcion · 15/03/2012 21:03

That sounds pretty credible to me, PA.
Certainly, from about the age of 2-3 until 6-7 children get very definite about what's appropriate/inappropriate for their gender and will also be the first to tell other children if they think they're "out of line".

Then you get another wave of it in adolescence as puberty makes young people more aware of their gender again and want to delineate themselves as part of their anxiety to appear attractive to the opposite sex. (Doesn't take the form of liking pink at this stage, though!!)

NinthWave · 15/03/2012 21:02

I had very similar feelings to you Doodle, but in the other direction (I have two boys). I make a conscious effort to seek out neutral/bright colours for them, rather than the default navy/brown/camo stuff.

H&M is great for bright colours, and these bodysuits from M&S are gorgeous too - on my wishlist for DS2, who's 17 months.

Charity shops are good for unique bits/cheap 'designer' gear - I've found that Scandinavian brands tend to be gorgeous and non-gender-specific.

If you want to PM me, I'm happy to supply you with a free bag of lovely bits that my sons wore - I regularly get asked if DS2 is a boy or a girl, so I must have cracked this particular nut Grin

CrunchyFrog · 15/03/2012 20:59

The day DD was born, MIL turned up at the hospital with a pale pink babygro emblazoned with a "Born To Shop!" logo, a bottle, a handbag and some shoes.

There was a facepalm.

She did have a pink phase, which (thank fuck) we are now through. DS2 had/ is having a pink/ sparkly tat phase too, but sadly for him the extended family refuse to pander the way they did with DD, so he has to content himself with stealing DD's stuff.

The whole thing drives me bananas.

PenguinArmy · 15/03/2012 20:55

I thought children went towards very pink or very blue once they are aware of their sex but before they realise their sex is fixed. So they latch onto what they are told/think they should like.

or did I make that up or mis-understand it?

InmaculadaConcepcion · 15/03/2012 20:47

Little girls nowadays are herded towards pink from the moment the 20 week scan determines their sex, it's not surprising they self-identify pink as being for girls when they get old enough to make informed choices about what they (have learned to regard as) the most appropriate clothing for their gender.

The fashion for pink=girl is not "child led" IMO - I bet if everyone dressed their girls in green from the second they came out the womb (decorated their rooms in green, bought them prams etc. trimmed in green, gave them mostly green-coloured toys, plates, cups, cutlery, hair-ornaments, towels etc. etc.) then we would say "The little girls love green" when they opted for it once they were old enough to express an opinion on the matter. Because green would be seen as being intricately woven into their gender identity and the way they differentiate themselves from those different to themselves (boys). And you can bet your life that in that particular scenario, most boys (and their parents) wouldn't countenance green for themselves.

I was also indifferent to the colour pink as a young girl, mainly because at that time (not SO long ago!!) pinkification hadn't taken hold in the way it has now. It was just another colour.

Now it's too bound up with over-repressive gender-stereotyping and putting people into boxes.

madwomanintheattic · 15/03/2012 20:38

mine wore pack-of-three white sleepsuits with white onesies underneath, and then were dressed in navy, white and red. all handed down to the next one. it made no difference. the world and his wife bought the girls pink and the boy blue, and they inhabit the same world as disney. Grin by four both girls declared pink and purple were their favourite colours. fortunately, dd1 now favours green, and dd2 blue. they do grow out of it if you encourage individuality and don't force them either way. and ultimately (although thank feck not mine) someone's child really is going to prefer pink.

the pressure really wasn't on from the marketing pov when we were tots, so our parents didn't have to make any political statements wrt colour of clothing. it's just consumerism gawn mad over the last twenty years.

Migsy1 · 15/03/2012 19:59

Apparently this dreadful fashion is child led. The little girls love pink. Flipping awful and very dull. Funnily, when I was a little girl I was indifferent to the colour pink and my favourite was blue. I also loved lime green and cherry red. All this pink is so damned boring!

PenguinArmy · 15/03/2012 19:54

OneHandWavingFree said what I feel with regards to motif's. DD likes dinosaurs, helicopters and diggers atm but it hard to find ones that aren't in dark 'boys' colours. I didn't buy the NEXT top due to the words, I think it was cute-a-saurus or summit, didn't mind the pink bit.

As someone else said when they are not in pink but a gender neutral colour then people assume your baby/toddler is male.

Like lifeissweet I personally prefer nice bright clothes which in the UK is hard to find. Had no problems in the US.

blackcurrants · 15/03/2012 19:51

it is depressing when things that I would have considered 'gender neutral' (blue, green, yellow, red... heck, most things!) are shrunk down into pink for girls and blue for boys. I only have a boy but my experience for him was that the rainbow grew a bit as he got bigger- baby boys had pale blue EVERYTHING, now most colours (except for pink and purple) crop up here and there, though it IS hard getting past the sludgy camo-gear. I've always bought as neutral colours as I can, with one eye on it all being worn by DC2, of whatever gender that child might be. Polarn O Pyraet make gorgeous, great quality, brightly coloured kids clothes. If only they didn't cost a bloody fortune. I tend to scour their sales and grab any stuff I see of theirs on ebay, when needing new stuff for DS.

Do you know, when we decided not to find out the gender of our baby people were absolutely aghast, and the first thing most people said was "but how will people know what colour things to buy?" Shock Seriously. It was so irritating it made me even more determined not to stereotype the poor thing before it was born!

I like pink and I don't think typically feminine-associated behaviours are less important than typically masculine associated ones (For example, why is sport considered 'serious' and fashion considered 'trivial'? Can anyone think or a single reason that doesn't involve institutional sexism?), but I don't like limitations and I loathe exclusion. Everyone can wear every colour. Colours are for everyone!

Pink lego just depresses me. Don't be afraid of the creative, scientifically fascinating toy of infinite possibilities! We'll make it pink so you can see that even girls can use it!

urgh.

Doodlegoogle · 15/03/2012 19:27

Thanks all. Its helping clarify my thoughts. It is definitely something to do with the point OneHand raises about the message that there only one way to be a girl. Equally, I think I'm torn because I can also see the point that there are really more important things to be worrying about than clothes and it is after all just a colour. A balance seems to be what I feel more comfortable with.

Thanks also for the book and website recommendations. I realise now how hard my mother worked when I was a child to avoid sterotyping me and and my brother. We both ended up with all sorts of toys including dolls for him and toy cars for me and clothes of all colours. I guess we will end up doing the same. If she is anything like me and DP, she'll be happiest digging up stones in the garden or building something anyway and any pink will rapidly become black.

I'm certainly going to buy some boys clothes and unisex. I was intending to buy most things second hand and somehow the first nearly new sale I went to appeared particularly pink. There was even hideous pink lego which seemed particularly unnecessary. Whatever happens I will NEVER buy that.

OP posts:
Xenia · 15/03/2012 15:38

It's easy to avoid. All our baby gros were white or yellow. We had lots of children and they all wore the same ones passed down. The first baby got stuff from jumble sales. Only people into being a consumer and with money to burn really fuss about clothing for chidlren. It is morally deficient to be too bothered about that kind of thing.

We did buy some feminist books when they were little - mother the plumber, mother a doctor etc etc I think that helps. Both my girls have picked pretty good careers.

Lifeissweet · 15/03/2012 14:36

I was adamant that I wasn't going to dress my DD in pink. I decorated her nursery in a brightly coloured jungle theme.

However, since she was born we've received gifts and hand-me downs which are all pink. She is in pink most of the time. She looks sweet in it, but I prefer her in bright colours. I just won't spend money on clothes for her while we have so many perfectly wearable clothes that happen to be pink. I am considering cracking out some fabric dye. What do we think? Does that work?

wigglesrock · 15/03/2012 14:30

I have 3dds, at the minute Next, Sainsburys and Asda are doing a lot of non pink babygros, bottoms, tops etc. I was in M&S yesterday and they have a lot of greens, reds and yellows.

To be honest, pink clothes do not bother me in the slightest neither do pink toys, nor "character" clothes. Pink really suits my daughters as does navy, I am of the just a colour brigade but I know a lot of people aren't.

Harecare · 15/03/2012 14:27

My DDs wore a lot of pink as I am too tight to buy things myself so hand me downs and gifts tended to be pink.
I don't like pink.
My DDs look better in blue. When I have bought anything I have considered it's reuse, so a navy/red/green coat will do for a boy or girl - little did I know that DD1 would be the eldest of 3 DDs! I hate toys that could be unisex turned into "girls" toys by colouring them pink.

NicknameTaken · 15/03/2012 14:22

Sorry, that last sentence sounded particularly sanctimonious. It's basically just how I justify my laissez faire attitude to myself.

NicknameTaken · 15/03/2012 14:21

I have a four-year-old who just may be a reincarnation of Barbara Cartland. She went to nursery this morning in head-to-toe pink, clutching a pink toy dog with a diamante collar and a diamante handbag (accessories acquired by her father).

As a baby, I rarely dressed her in pink (she looked so lovely in cream colours, sigh) but I didn't purge pink garments bought by family and friends. Nowe she mostly wants to chose for herself, and it's almost always pink or purple. I don't want to make it into an issue, I don't want to send messages of girly stuff = undesirable, and I respect her autonomy.

GrimmaTheNome · 15/03/2012 14:20

There is a lot of pink - but relative to what was available when I was a child there is also a lot more of everything else too.

I often buy 'boys' clothes for DD - T shirts are usually thicker, nicer cotton than flimsy 'girls' ones. She refused pale pink after the age of about 5 and I've never had to send her out naked yet Wink

I seem to remember getting nice non-pink clothes from JoJoMamanBebe when DD was small (they did pinks but blues etc too).

As to toys - if there's a 'normal' one and a pink one, just buy the normal one unless it looks better in pink.

Congratulations Smile

InmaculadaConcepcion · 15/03/2012 14:08

OP and others with pink-aversion (I'm one too - DD has some pink things, but mostly I go for other colours if I can) you may find the Pink Stinks website of interest....

And impending congratulations, by the way!

StewieGriffinsMom · 15/03/2012 14:06

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Archemedes · 15/03/2012 09:36

I think girls generall y have much more choice than boys

perhaps white and yellow clothes even purple red etc.

TerraNotSoFirma · 15/03/2012 08:22

Buying boys clothes is the way to go, Not least because I have a son 21 months younger than DD. I buy as many primary coloured t-shirts and sweatshirts as possible and avoid 'princesses and monkeys'.

We still get them as gifts and do put the children in them, But they wouldn't be my first choice. (esp. matalans sparkly sequinned PINK evertything)

Swipe left for the next trending thread