Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

HARROGATE

106 replies

MrsClown · 18/01/2012 11:18

Does anyone live near or visit Harrogate. I do not live there but I recently booked some theatre tickets for the theatre in Harrogate and find it is practically next door to a strip club!!!! I contacted Harrogate Council to comment on how rediculous it is and they have informed me that the closing date for objections is 26 January 2012. I wondered if anyone else would be willing to write to the licensing department at Harrogate Council to object. I mean, I did not really want to have to attend the theatre with my family next to part of the sex trade!

Please go on the OBJECT website which gives ideas on wording and further advice regarding objections to these establishments.

OP posts:
VictorGollancz · 23/02/2012 14:37

What on earth is a 'designer' feminist? Is this one of those times whereby people who don't have a leg to stand on invoke elitism in order to smear another person's point of view?

Please explain on this site, as I have no intention of giving your blog traffic - not least because that's clearly why you're here.

TonyN · 23/02/2012 12:20

Yes designer feminists make me shudder too Grin

Vicky2011 · 23/02/2012 11:54

Shudder

TonyN · 23/02/2012 11:12

If I was here to be popular I wouldn't have opened mymouth in the first place would I lol Grin And did you read the blog and find out why I think of you as a designer feminist?

TonyN · 23/02/2012 11:11

Actual I have been to venues over the years in London and I have never seen people shouting out to women, it may be a regional thing but I have seen men calling out from ordinary bars when outside smoking or in the summer. I certainly don't know what is going on in Leeds but in London I know the strip scene very well and over the years I have met a high number of dancers and I have yet to meet one who stayed in the job that didn't want to do it. As performers they have the right to dance or not to dance and the few that don't like it have only to stop there is no such thing as still has to work. And before we go on about me being a customer and girls saying want the customer wants to hear I have been invited to dancers weddings, been to their houses, met their husbands and boyfriends so I would say that I probably know a lot more dancers than you and none of them dislike the job. Yes they will have bad days but you get that in any job.

See the wider picture as I see it is not the same as the wider picture as you see it. Perception is a strange thing but I can only go on my own experiences. The other thing that is different is I prefer the more traditional strip pub rather than the chain LDCs, certainly they need better regulation to provide better standards for the dancers but in London most venues you could walk past without even knowing they are there. I have no issues with the removal of any blatant advertising but to shut them down? Even Object when they started was for better regulation and it was only when they came out as designer feminists they changed their tune.

MrsClown · 23/02/2012 10:40

I am not deciding what other people can do. It is their choice obviously. However, it should be my choice not to be confronted by it around every corner in my home town. It is the normalisation of selling women that is the point. Men dont have to put up with it so why should I. Women in Iceland are not for sale so I dont see why we cant have that over here. I agree with it being boring, I wish it was not something I have to discuss even but unfortunately it is. I know the statement about buying women may be boring for you, it may be because it is true and you dont like to admit it. I could give you lots of other arguments but the buying of women is the basis for the growth of these vile places. Prostitution is linked to these establishments. I KNOW that there are strip joints who hire taxis for the Johns to go to brothels after the strip joint. A stripper (sorry I cant call them dancers it is offensive to dancers) who sadly still has to work in the industry who told me that. By the way she admitted to me that she hates it. When I was on the RECLAIM THE NIGHT march in Leeds there were women coming onto the street who had to work in the viscinity of these places thanking us for daring to speak out.

I am sick and tired of people like you who do not see the wider picture. The effect it has on other women. My friends teenage daughter recently had to endure jeers and catcalls from a group of men who had just come out of a strip club. She is 17 years old and is now scared to walk around in town. That happened during the day by the way. Call the police you may say. Do you actually think they would come rushing out! That is why you have to become offensive and make patronising statements because you cant be bothered to even find out.

My advice to you is to look at the wider picture.

End of discussion. Tony, dont be a troll, you will make yourself unpopular.

OP posts:
TonyN · 23/02/2012 09:37

Read the blog it gives your a good idea of what a designer feminist is.

As for your arguments I have answered the same questions and statements 8 times across 3 threads (one of which was deleted). Become boring hearing the same blame statement about buying women. I go to be entertained the same as a film or theatre or Ballet or concert, the entertainer earns their living from their performance which I pay for the privilage of watching. There is no sex involved it is about making a fantasy for a short period and both parties know that. And remember films/plays/ballet all create a fantasy for a short time. And I guess if the film, play or ballet involves people being naked you are against that but the performer has decided they are willing to perform that way and it is their choice. What right have you to decide what other people can do?

MrsClown · 23/02/2012 09:12

Tony - you are typical of the type of man that I have been dealing with for years and years. You will never change. The difference between you and me (the feminist) is I have not become offensive or patronised you. You just cant help yourelf can you. The old, old male way, if you are losing the argument try to offend the woman. I guess it would be easier for you if I just sat and smiled!

By the way, what is a designer feminist, in your opinion. Can I ask you how old you are.

OP posts:
TonyN · 22/02/2012 17:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet.

KRITIQ · 22/02/2012 16:01

snort

TonyN · 22/02/2012 15:55

Dont worry I understand the designer feminist has no idea of the real world.

MrsClown · 22/02/2012 15:32

I am happier to admit I am a member of OBJECT than admitting that you think it is ok to buy a woman. I actually know some of the other volunteers and board members and I am so proud to be associated with them. Infact, Tony, I said to one of them that I thought I was the only one in the UK who did not want the sex trade on my high street and HIS reply was 'Dont worry you have been shouted down by the loud mouth minority!' and here you are!

Awww Tony!

OP posts:
KRITIQ · 22/02/2012 14:40

You really must assume we are idiots Tony.

It's an easy one for me. I'd far rather associate with the board and volunteers of Object (many of whom believe it or not, I actually know!) than anyone who believes it's a great thing to buy women, let alone those who profit handsomely from trading women.

Funny Mrs Clown, my DH and I manage to have a great time without patronising such establishments as well. Who'd have thunk it, eh?

TonyN · 22/02/2012 13:00

Awww MrsClown having read what some of the volunteers of Object have done in the past you sure you wanted to admit that? Head to stripping the illusion by chasmal and find out a little more about the organisation you rave about.

MrsClown · 22/02/2012 12:04

Tony - I am one of the volunteers who ran for OBJECT. Some of us can see the wood for the trees. You say you wish you had a strip club near you as it is a good night out. Thank God my husband can enjoy a good night out without having to buy a woman.

Kritiq - THANK YOU for your amazing blog. I couldnt put it any better.

OP posts:
TonyN · 22/02/2012 11:44

LMAO sorry about the typo think everyone will know I meant Object.

TonyN · 22/02/2012 11:43

Well considering what is on the stripping illusion blog about Objet think a lot of people will be questioning Grin Been quite a bit added about the glorious Object.

KRITIQ · 22/02/2012 11:37

Well Tony, if you could be bothered, rather than shit stirring, you could have looked on Object's website at their 2009-10 Annual Report to get an idea of funding for that year and what was expected in the year to come.

In that year, they got the following:

£10,000 grant from Allen Lane Foundation for the Demand Change Campaign
£5,000 from Joseph Rowntree Reform Trust for the Joining the Dots project
£2,000 from Unison Women's Committee to produce educational materials
£6,000 in member subscriptions
£14,000 from donations and fundraising activities (e.g. comedy nights, sponsored runs, jumble sales, that sort of thing - including a £1000 donation from Garden Court Chambers Social Fund.)

That adds up to £37,000 - hardly a princely sum when you think if the vast resources available within the for-profit porn, strip clubs, etc. industry!

According to the report, they expected to receive two new grants in 2010-11 that they would receive for a total of two years:

£50,000 from Trust for London for their education and campaigning work related to lap dancing clubs.
£25,000 from Esme Fairbairn towards core and strategic costs.

All this info is available on their site and on the respective funders' websites. Nothing is secret, so stop suggesting it is.

Like most small voluntary organisations, they are only able to do what they do because so many folks volunteer their time and resources to support them. They have few paid staff to co-ordinate the thing and tend to the admin, finance, regulatory, etc. stuff. The fact that they literally operate on a shoestring, yet achieve so much (and frighten people like you so much!) is a testament to the heartfelt commitment of the men and women involved in the organisation. It's hardly surprising they've won do many awards for their work. Amazing stuff.

TonyN · 22/02/2012 08:28

I would have had no problem when I was working.

Just be interested to see exactly where Object gets money apart from the grants. And how those grants match up to the work Object is doing.

KRITIQ · 22/02/2012 08:18

Won't be any skin off Object's collective nose to file accounts, so what's with the Maltese Falcoln stylie 'gonna investigate stance?' They have nothing to hide. I think you'll be surprised how small they are, and how modest their income and outgoings are.

You are of course quite happy to make you're company's accounts available to all who ask as well, right?

TonyN · 22/02/2012 07:08

Parakeet I had written it elsewhere before the whole thread was deleted, I am friends with dancers outside of the industry including being invited to weddings, invited to their houses (and once again no not as a customer) met their boyfriends and husbands. Guess I know nothing then pmsl.

As to the company records Object incorporation date has meant their first figures will be April this year. And as soon as they have been made available there will be people asking for them.

HarrietSchulenberg · 21/02/2012 23:03

I have a vision of Harrogate strippers as being something like the Marcus Brigstock and James Bachman characters from I'm Sorry I've Got No Head.

Sorry, completely irrelevant but had to throw it in. As you were everyone ...

KRITIQ · 21/02/2012 22:51

Tony, you can get a copy of the audited accounts of any Limited Company from Companies House. Just go to their website. It's all perfectly transparent - so no need to suggest they are or are trying to hide anything.

Been a director and company secretary for probably all together about 8 or 10 companies going back well over 15 years. "Managing Director" is just a title, so doesn't really mean anything. But, if you are a director of a company (limited or otherwise,) you need to have a good working knowledge of charity law. If you fall foul of it, pleading ignorance is no excuse and won't prevent you from being fined, imprisoned or your own personal assets being drawn on if an unwise or unlawful decision was taken by the Board of directors that results in financial loss.

Just sayin.

(Not arsed enough to engage on any other issue though with someone who appears to regard the purchase of women as any more unethical than buying a gerbil from Pets at Home.)

(Come to think of it, buying a gerbil from a pet shop isn't terribly ethical, but I digress.)

Nyac · 21/02/2012 22:12

I think you're in a minority Tony. These clubs make their money from erections.

I said you talk about the women you pay for as if they are things. I don't think women are things for men's use which is why I think that strip clubs, lapdancing clubs and the like should be outlawed. The way they have been in Iceland.

parakeet · 21/02/2012 22:03

Dear Tony - do you really think someone working in the sex industry would give an honest account of it to one of her punters? That's not exactly going to be good for business.

Can you imagine it? "Yeah, to be honest, I hate this job, and I'm only doing it to put on the table for my kids, now go on dear, slip a twenty into my knickers and I'll take off my bra."