Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

So, are you attracted to 'feminist nightmare' blokes? If so, does it annoy or amuse you?

64 replies

LoudRowdyDuck · 12/11/2010 23:18

I hope this is ok, I fancied a light-hearted thread for saturday night, and with luck some of you will still be aware to help me ponder.

DH has just introduced me to Ashes to Ashes and obviously (er ... for a MNer ...), I went and searched out the Telly thread on here. I discover that masses of apparently sane women have huge crushes on Gene Hunt, who (in case you don't know), plays a sort of caricature 1970s misogynist/sex pest.

And I sort of know what they mean. Blush

I wondered how many of us who are feminists, do feel attracted to the very 'wrong' men? Is it excusable because it's a fantasy or should we be having strong words with ourselves?

Discuss.

OP posts:
ElephantsAndMiasmas · 13/11/2010 01:54

Ohhh isn't JRM the one who was the coach in Bend it Like Beckham? Slightly dodgy teeth?

ElephantsAndMiasmas · 13/11/2010 01:54

I do admire your separation of shagging and lurve SGB. I would behave much more like that, in an ideal world.

I don't think PG is good-looking either, he is handsomeish but warty and a little like an acne-pocked dumpling.

SparklingExplosionGoldBrass · 13/11/2010 01:47

Right everybody go watch Velvet Goldmine and have a wibble over Jonathan Rhys Myers...

And I letched over Gene Hunt too. Partly because, just as the whole Gene Genie thing started to take off, Philip Glenister was doing the bedtime stories for the week on CBeebies, which made this total 'Bastard with a tender streak' fantasy possible. (Have no idea if Glenister had in fact recorded the bedtime stories before Life On Mars and some mischevious scheduler thought, 'Oh give the bored housewives a treat' or what).
And I have had a few great shags with men who have not exactly been feminist friendly and indeed exaggerated their sexism as a kind of pulling ritual - but I wouldn't have lived with any of them.

BitOfPom · 13/11/2010 01:43

While much of what you say is true, Sakura, Gene Hunt is no George Clooney, so I'm not sure that stands up.

Sakura · 13/11/2010 01:40

their

Sakura · 13/11/2010 01:40

I like men in eyeliner too...
I also think arguing and sexual attraction go together...

I think women so rarely get to see really good looking men on TV that when one does pop up (in whatever role) they're going to start drooling over him.

Compare that to the constant stream of images of sexy young women that men get.

I mean women get sacked from the BBC if they look too old but they keep the old male codgers on until they're in they're dotage

LoudRowdyDuck · 13/11/2010 01:32

Ewww. Russell Brand.

I do like men in eyeliner, but as you say he is beyond the pale. My dear DH is very patient with the fact that I like brunettes, as he's blond - and sadly, I don't think he'd take to eyeliner

OP posts:
ElephantsAndMiasmas · 13/11/2010 01:24

Dobbin is about as wishy washy as you can get.

I like promiscuous and androgynous as well. Russell Brand certainly doesn't count as he talks about his knob far too much to be adrogynous. I like men in eyeliner. In fact, if someone can find me a sarcastic, dark haired, blue eyed, man in eyeliner I will throw DP over like a shot

LoudRowdyDuck · 13/11/2010 01:18

Elephants, that is a very good point! (And, Dobbin? Wow, nice way to put me off! [grin[)

OP posts:
LadyFnarFnar · 13/11/2010 01:04

Oh yes I agree on the politics thing. I asked my dp about the details of the American mid-terms. He actually bullshitted for about 5 minutes before he admitted he had no clue. That is such a Man thing to do, bullshit on topics you have no clue about. If dp asked me a question and I didn't know the answer, I would say so and direct him to google.

I am perfectly capable of googling my own answers, when dp doesn't pretend to have them for some bizarre reason.

Joolyjoolyjoo · 13/11/2010 00:57

I like a challenge Grin My DH is definitely not a bastard- he does housework, he does childcare...but he has definite ideas that are Hmm For example, he doesn't like books where women are the main character, but he owns Ellen MacArthur's book about her sailing round the world, and he has a (grudging!) respect for her. He completely consents to the fact that I am more intelligent than him (well, goes without saying Wink), but still will argue with me about politics/ current affairs etc and think he is right, even though his argument doesn't stand up.

My last BF before DH was lovely, but a bit...wishy-washy. I am a strong women, and need a strong man to be my template. I felt my last BF allowed me to be in charge of everything, which was wearing, tbh. I ended up feeling more like his mother than his partner.

LadyFnarFnar · 13/11/2010 00:55

Thats a good quote eam, I'd give anything to be bossed about(well for a bit). I'm sick of being the one responsible, surely I'm still a child Grin.

Actually could well tie in to certain proclivities lol.

ElephantsAndMiasmas · 13/11/2010 00:51

Nah he seems good now, when presumably in the show he is rushing around beating up criminals and wotnot. But if he was sitting on the sofa farting, watching snooker and clicking his fingers when he needed more beer, you'd soon wish him back in the past.

I can't see him in that light anyway, I remember him as Dobbin in Vanity Fair where he was about as far from Gene Hunt as it's possible to get.

duchesse · 13/11/2010 00:47

Nope. Growing up had ample opportunity to observe how very downtrodden my mother was with her own feminist nightmare (oh yes, my delightful father, now moaning that he should be pitied for no longer being the bee's knees) and decided aged 12 never, ever to fall into same trap. Thank god for reinforcement from compulsory literature reading list in French school system at the time- Therese Raquin, Une Vie, Mme Bovary, that convinced that I'd rather be alone and single for ever than end up with a bastard.

ForMashGetSmash · 13/11/2010 00:42

Grin EAM!

Restful! That's it...if Gene would just be here for a few hours of an evening and chuck his weight about a bit, I could face each new day with a fresh perspective!

ElephantsAndMiasmas · 13/11/2010 00:40

FMGS - jyaby posted this quote from Cold Comfort Farm the older day, yours reminded me:

Like all really strong-minded women, on whom everybody flops, she adored being bossed about. It was so restful.

LadyFnarFnar · 13/11/2010 00:28

God knows why he would say that btw Lady he's a very buttoned up type, doesn't do sharing feelings. I often feel I don't know him, but they say you should take notice of actions, not feelings/words. He has rarely been less than kind tbh, he acts in a non misogynistic way, so god knows.

ForMashGetSmash · 13/11/2010 00:27

God Gene Hunt....droooooooool.

I think personally...that I am a bolshy woman who doesn't let anyone boss her around...man or woman...and so it's necassary for me to fancy men like Gene in order to have some relief from the effort of being constantly rock about things which women are traditionally...not rock about.

LadyFnarFnar · 13/11/2010 00:22

Yes that's true loud, actually in my revised history, should time travel be invented, without negating the creation of my children (very specific daydream there) I would be a spinster with many books and cats. I doubt I will live to retirement age, this is all I have Grin.

LoudRowdyDuck · 13/11/2010 00:18

Crikey, Lady. Sad

I wonder why he thinks he should say he's a misogynist?

I just have to say though, being a lesbian doesn't entirely protect you from sexism - a female friend of mine has a wife who sometimes comes out with gobsmackingly sexist statements.

OP posts:
LoudRowdyDuck · 13/11/2010 00:16

BOF - I would love it if this were true (for me), and I think you and Jooly are saying similar things. I am just not quite certain my own subconscious is as admirable as yours!

I wouldn't want to tolerate a genuinely sexist man in RL, that I know. But I am not sure that the attraction for me springs from the desire to redeem someone!

OP posts:
LadyFnarFnar · 13/11/2010 00:15

JoolyJoo my dp actually said to me once that he was a misogynist Hmm. Honestly I wish this section had been around at that time, I would have flamed him to kingdom come.

Thing is though, in his thoughts and actions he is not a misogynist at all. Maybe it's ingrained in boys at a certain age that Women are the enemy Hmm.

I honestly truly widh I was a Lesbian.

LoudRowdyDuck · 13/11/2010 00:14

Jooly - what a great justification! I do think that is part of the appeal for me ... you want to convince them. But then again, I don't know what it would be like to actually live with a non-feminist bloke. I suppose I am curious as my lovely DH is as far from sexist as you can get.

My dad is quite sexist but sadly, I have no ability and little patience when it comes to trying to change his ideas. Sad

OP posts:
BitOfPom · 13/11/2010 00:13

I love the Gene Hunt character, but wouldn't stand for sexism in my own partner (beyond a tongue-in-cheek jokiness).

I think the reason that the Gene Hunt archetype is appealing is that it chimes with the understandable fantasy that sexist men are at core big softies who will actually act with integrity. We know that in reality this is not the case, but we would love to dream that it could all turn around with the love of a good woman.

If any real life man uttered that kind of shite, it would merely be the tip of a very ugly iceberg, but the television character fits with our desire to believe that people can be redeemed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread