Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

I have come to the conclusion that I don't like quite a lot of female writers

109 replies

OrmIrian · 24/01/2009 21:45

Nicole Krauss - History of love. Yaaaaaawnn!
Someobody Niffeneagger? 'Time Travellers Wife' made me so cross I wanted to burn the f*ing book!
Even struggled with Zadie Smith.

OK I've had too much soave and I can't think of any more examples but I have come to the conclusion that I don't want endless analysis of emotions, angsting over love affairs. I want interest, something actually happening, description, intellectual analysis. Not who fed who and who didn't and what is the emotional mess that results. If someone behaves badly and irrationally, I want to kow why*, not just put it down to past traumas and say 'of that's OK then'.

Does that make me a bad sister? Or just a man manque?

I love Terry Prathcett. I suspect that indicates serious emotional embolism. But wtf.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
slayerette · 28/01/2009 17:13

I still love Dorothy Parker. She just came right out and said what everyone else was thinking...

TwoIfBySea · 27/01/2009 19:42

I idolised Dorothy Parker when I was a teen. When asked to used the word "horticulture" in a sentence she said:

"You can lead a whore to culture, but you can't make her think."

Brilliant.

browntrout · 27/01/2009 19:03

what about

Harper Lee (writer of possibly the best book ever written!)
Dorothy Parker
Edith Wharton
Donna Tartt
Muriel Spark
Maya Angelou
Jane Gardam

and my most favourite writer ever (and after whom my daughter takes her middle name)

Carson McCullers

recently tried with Iris Murdoch but I have to say I find her a bit 'wordy'. Im much more a fan of sparse American writing (as may be obvious) but there are certain lots of good female writers.

Buff1 · 27/01/2009 18:30

Kate Atkinson and Jane Yardley (not a hint of chick-lit in either) and good old Iris Murdoch.
I went through an Anita Brookner phase but ended up wanting to slash my wrists so had to stop.
Really wanted to like Brick Lane but just couldn't get through it - don't really know why.

CJCregg · 26/01/2009 23:47

Have to admit, there's a long list of books I'd rather read first. I seem to remember writing utter bullshit in the exam, just frantic and random jottings I'd remembered from the margin, that I'd written when I wasn't actually asleep in the class. Set the tone for my whole career ever since!

janeite · 26/01/2009 20:10

Well, if you revisit her, perhaps you can persuade me, too? I tried The Waves for A level and ended up just blagging an essay without having finished the book.

CJCregg · 26/01/2009 20:08

I love you, Janeite and ggirl. (Mind you, I need persuading on Virginia Woolf. Was forced to do The Waves for A level and have never quite got over it. Maybe time to revisit?)

Jane Austen (for me) is and always will be the standard by which all writers shall be judged ...

apsie · 26/01/2009 18:12

How about The Voyage of the Narwhal by Andrea Barrett or The Siege by Helen Dunmore? I agree, Rose Tremain is fantastic, also love Anne Tyler.

brimfull · 26/01/2009 18:02

I love Virginia Wolf's books

janeite · 26/01/2009 17:28

I liked "The Time Traveller's Wife"!

Then again there are plenty on here that I've hated -

Margaret Atwood - except "The Handmaid's Tale" which is fab.

Sarah Waters - yawn

Kate Mosse - over-written, boring drivel

Claire Morral - yawn

The Icarus Girl - Helen Oyeyemi

However, Jane Austen is female - so if no female (or male) ever wrote another book again, ever, I could live happily just on re-reads!

WinkyWinkola · 26/01/2009 17:22

Sarah Waters is dreadful. That Fingersmith was just laughable. I don't understand why she's so popular. Her writing is crud.

But so many great women writers out there.

I love Antonia Fraser and Kate Atkinson (bit mad at times) too. Marjane Satrapi who wrote Persepolis and Embroderies is fascinating too.

slayerette · 26/01/2009 17:20

You must read the Regeneration trilogy by Pat Barker. Fabulous stuff.

robinia · 26/01/2009 17:12

Also Andrea Levy - Small Island

robinia · 26/01/2009 17:11

Oh, you're badmouthing so many books I love.

The Time Traveller's Wife (Audrey Nifenegger) just mesmerising. We Need to Talk About Kevin (Lionel Shriver) I enjoyed (if enjoyed is the right word)

Siri Hustvedt - What I Loved was a bit contrived for me (sounds strange to say that when compared especially to Time Traveller's Wife - I found it hard to warm to the story whilst still appreciating its literary qualities.
Enjoyed Fingersmith too.

Also like Margaret Attwood (but not the sci-fi ones), Anne Tyler,

HAve you tried Carol Shields, Donna Tartt, Michele Roberts, Helen Dunmore (bit of a long shot the last one but trying to get what you like and dislike)?

voodoothatyoudo · 26/01/2009 16:51

I tried Ann Marie Macdonald after raves on this site and was bitterly disappointed, found Fall on Your Knees contrived and melodramatic

Others obv feel differently

I loved Time Traveller's Wife

And Anne Tyler is a great writer. But I think most contemporary writers of modern fiction write what my husband and I call faux lit - bog standard stuff dressed up to seem important and intellectual.

I am really looking forward to having a good laugh at reading the new Rachel Cusk. She is so mindbogglingly pretentious, I find her unintentionally hilarious. Theearly reviews I've read hint her latest book will be a classic.

brimfull · 26/01/2009 16:50

cjcregg- i love Anne-Marie Macdonald.The way the crow flies was brilliant.

CatIsSleepy · 26/01/2009 14:01

i love zadie smith, though not white teeth-the Autograph man is my fave
Pat Barker's Regeneration Trilogy is fantastic

Hilary Mantel, RoseTremain, Penelope Lively, Kate Atkinson, Helen Dunmore all v. good
agree with whoever mention Scarlett thomas (though i reckon her endings are not always the best...can leave me a bit bemused)

um, Kate Grenville-Blood River was excellent too

ProfRichardDawkins · 26/01/2009 13:46

Anne Tyler is a lovely writer.

CJCregg · 26/01/2009 10:12

Hi all, also haven't read all the thread but wanted to stick up for Time Traveller's Wife.

Love the Literature Map - though it is a bit bonkers.

Anyone read Ann-Marie Macdonald? I think she is mind-blowingly good. Quite hard work to get into but once you're in, you can't let go and it's an incredibly rewarding, moving read. Fall On Your Knees and The Way The Crow Flies.

purpleduck · 26/01/2009 09:50

I LOVED Time Travellers Wife

BTW, I want to like Margaret Atwood, and a few I actually do, but I find them very forgettable, and most just too hard to get into, and not worth the effort.

OrmIrian · 26/01/2009 09:33

Right. Next stop Amazon.

OP posts:
mysterymoniker · 26/01/2009 09:32

(Curtis is a girl, honestly)

mysterymoniker · 26/01/2009 09:31

I worry that I don't like enough stuff written by men!

I'm stuck in a bit of a young adult rut at the moment, so I'm going to suggest Eva Ibbotson, Curtis Sittenfeld and Meg Rosoff.

OrmIrian · 26/01/2009 09:19

You are very lovely people and have made me very happy. I feel quite asamed that so many of the names you mention I have heard of but never got round to reading. Stuck in a rut. I suspect DH goes to Waterstones, sees a likely looking book in the 3 for 2 section and that's what I get in my stocking or as an extra b'day pressie. I shall beg him to stop.

OP posts:
MsG · 26/01/2009 06:36

Pat Barker and Anne Tyler are both great writers.