Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Talk
What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Original poster

Is it wrong to fall in love with a fictional character??!!

159 replies

EdwardCullencanhavemysoul · 24/09/2008 16:38

And one who is a fictional teenage vampire at that?!
I really am old enough to know better

OP posts:
HarryAndRon · 24/09/2008 19:27

well, if you look at how much they cut out of harry potter, I can understand your fear!!!

DrHorrible · 24/09/2008 19:26

it most likely will be. you have to do as i did with northern lights and harry potter.

It is a film of a Good Story, and NOT a live version of the books you love.

EnchantedWithEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 19:23

I'm actually not convinced they will do a good job ... not the actors, Hollywood I mean.

The amount of time in Twilight thats dedicated to Edward and Bella getting to know each other, falling in love and the intense descripitions of how when Edward even just looks at Bella for a second makes her forget to breathe... I just don't see how they will transfer that to the screen.

Im worried that the film will just be 90% about James and 'the hunt' Rather than Edward and Bella IYWWIM?

DrHorrible · 24/09/2008 19:13

I think Jacob'll grow just fine - he is at that age

EnchantedWithEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 19:05

They will have to feed him steroids!

OriginalMrsEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 19:03

he is lovely, but needs feeding up to be the jacob of the end books!!!!

he will have a few fans tho

EnchantedWithEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 18:59

He looks too small to be jacob, then again hes supposed to small and young in Twilight isn't he?

I suppose they'll bulk him up when they start filming the next film!

Miyazaki · 24/09/2008 18:56

I was in a pretty major mood with my dh when I finished a time travellers wife.

I was all... Henry... sigh.

EnchantedWithEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 18:55

have you seen Jacob? I tried to find one with a shirt on but theres not that many, lol

EnchantedWithEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 18:52

''I just think 'he is not edward' would suffice.

and if the divorce judge asks who edward is, hit him with twilight.''

PMSL!

OriginalMrsEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 18:47

I just think 'he is not edward' would suffice.

and if the divorce judge asks who edward is, hit him with twilight.

Original poster
EdwardCullenCanHaveMySoul · 24/09/2008 18:31

I'll try that one!

OP posts:
JacobImprintedOnMe · 24/09/2008 18:29

I think "He just has no charisma dammit" is perfectly acceptable for divorce papers

Original poster
EdwardCullenCanHaveMySoul · 24/09/2008 18:28

I think if I do see the movie that maybe I should take the divorce papers with me to the cinema, I could fill them in as I watched.
Is 'Failure to be a smooth talking, sexy, protective vampire' a reason for divorce?

OP posts:
OriginalMrsEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 18:27

I am still not completely convinced about the movie edward I have to admit.

might be different once I see the film proper tho, rather than just clips.

JacobImprintedOnMe · 24/09/2008 18:26

Nyeh

Original poster
EdwardCullenCanHaveMySoul · 24/09/2008 18:23

Sorry Bella, but my air of mystery becomes me

OP posts:
Original poster
EdwardCullenCanHaveMySoul · 24/09/2008 18:22

Movie Edward is the Edward of my imagination in a freaky coincidence - I love him, but he is 21 and I am so not.
I want my youth back!

OP posts:
BellaSwan · 24/09/2008 18:22

Not impressed with movie one.

Original poster
EdwardCullenCanHaveMySoul · 24/09/2008 18:21

Nope
I don't think I've ever been controversial enough to be hated Bella

OP posts:
EnchantedWithEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 18:21
EnchantedWithEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 18:21

so what do we think of movie Edward?

I swoon

Though hes nowhere near as good as my 'imagination Edward'

BellaSwan · 24/09/2008 18:20

But I could secretly hate you with a passion at the moment and need to rethink my opinion of you

OriginalMrsEdwardCullen · 24/09/2008 18:20

awwww......but we all revealed.

go on, you know you want to

Original poster
EdwardCullenCanHaveMySoul · 24/09/2008 18:18

I will never cringe over my Edward, how could anyone be so perfect (apart from the living dead thing obviously!)
Nope, my identity shall remain a mystery (and you'd all be disappointed if you knew anyway!)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread