Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Has anyone’s view of a favourite book changed on rereading? Just reread Wuthering Heights

102 replies

Duchessofmuchness · 31/05/2026 10:04

I’ve just finished re reading Wuthering Heights. When I read it at 20 i remember I couldn’t put it down. Read long into the night and cried. (proper uncontrollable sobbing) reading the ending. I would always say was one of books had loved reading most.

This time around (reading 40 years later) I dragged myself through it I couldn’t bring myself to like any of the characters- except the loyal Ellen and Hareton. I felt empathy for Catherine and Cathy - young and impulsive.

I suppose I must have been crying because Heathcliff is determined and happy that he will be reunited with Catherine but I didn’t feel it way I felt at 20. This time I felt such strong dislike for Heathcliff and his anger and control and sorry for the lack of agency Catherine and Cathy have.

I’m actually amazed how differently it hit me this time. Be so interested in whether anyone else has experienced this. Was it just age or also that times have changed?

OP posts:
PriscillaQueenoftheKitchen · 31/05/2026 10:09

Yes, I've had similar experiences with once favorite books. William Faulkner's As I Lay Dying really affected me at around the same age, 20 yrs old. I read it at uni and was knocked out by it, fascinated by the twist of a changing narrative voice from chapter to chapter (including the voice of the dead mother in her coffin). But on trying to re-read it very recently I found it overwrought, not naturalistic and frankly, quite boring. I didn't get far. And it wasn't boring because I remembered it too well, it just bored me.

MyOtherProfile · 31/05/2026 10:07

I'm the same about Wuthering Heights. Totally gripped by it at 25, emotional wreck at the end of it. Tried to read it again 30 years later and couldn't believe I had been so taken by it. I gave up on it this time around. Who needs those kind of toxic relationships?