Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

My year with Stella...

220 replies

Waawo · 30/12/2025 22:52

...has begun!

I plan to spend my fifty somethingth year - and that surely is some kind of mistake - reading all of Stella Gibbons' novels. There are 26, of which I've previously read less than half, and own less than a quarter.

Since I want to read other things too, I'll try to squeeze each novel into a week, leaving a week in between for some variety. Some are not quite novels that can be read "while you eat an apple" though, so this may not work out.

Yesterday I wandered down to Waterstones to treat myself to a nice new reading copy of Cold Comfort Farm - the first novel, published in 1932. I've read this before, a few times in fact. It's a tale of our heroine Flora's attempts to tame her somewhat wild Sussex-based distant relations, as an alternative course to just getting a job.

I'm a few chapters in now, and the familiarity makes it a bit like slipping on comfortable pyjamas or slippers. I'm amazed how amongst the, honestly, slightly obvious seeming rural parody, Stella shows herself as sharp as a tack. For instance, she clearly knew what more recently we might call a 'crazymaker', since this is one the best descriptions of such a person I have read, by any author:

"If she intended to tidy up life at Cold Comfort, she would find herself opposed at every turn by the influence of Aunt Ada. Flora was sure that this would be so. Persons of Aunt Ada's temperament were not fond of a tidy life. Storms were what they liked; plenty of rows, and doors being slammed, and jaws sticking out, and faces white with fury, and faces brooding in corners, and faces making unnecessary fuss at breakfast, and plenty of opportunities for gorgeous emotional wallowings, and partings for ever, and misunderstandings, and interferings, and spyings, and, above all, managing and intriguing. Oh, they did enjoy themselves! They were the sort that went trampling all over your pet stamp collection, or whatever it was, and then spent the rest of their lives atoning for it. But you would rather have had your stamp collection."

Really looking forward to discovering the rest of her oeuvre. Enbury Heath is one of my favourite books ever - if there's anything else as good as that, this will have been time well spent!

I know there are a few here who like to see covers, so I've added a picture :)

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
Thread gallery
151
cheapskatemum · 29/07/2026 21:16

I’m so glad you liked it!

Waawo · 28/07/2026 22:18

cheapskatemum · 27/07/2026 23:10

I remember reading my aunt’s copy of “Here Be Dragons” and loving it. I’m glad it’s back in print as I recommended it to a friend a few months ago. Looking forward to hearing what you think of it.

Finished novel #16, Here be Dragons, today. Wow! Utterly brilliant!

I realise I am probably a bit gushing where Stella is concerned. I have read lots of opinion that can be summed up as "Stella's novels are up and down." And I kind of agree, after reading this straight after Shadow of a Sorcerer and especially Fort of the Bear. This is right back to the good stuff, up there with Westwood and Enbury Heath for me.

Maybe the fact that the action barely leaves Hampstead helps. No need for exotic locations. Mostly I think it's Nell, who is a proper Stella hero, and John Gaunt, the boy who would be King, who makes such a great anti-hero. It's always hard to write without giving away spoilers, which I never want to do, but Nell's 'journey' as we would call it today, made me so angry, and so happy when the penny finally drops and she sees John for what he really is.

The supporting cast of characters is just as good, and now, by the 1950s, TV and the BBC are starting to replace Bloomsbury as the "set" that Stella appears to want no part of.

What's been so great so far about reading the novels in chronological order is seeing how the journey is nothing like linear; almost like there are wrong turns, quieter periods, and then suddenly, BAM, a novel like this appears.

[Doing a bit of searching, I came across this 1956 film which gives a flavour of the Hampstead milieu of the story, including at about 9 minutes, the annual art exhibition with its canopy that is described in the book: https://www.londonsscreenarchives.org.uk/title/139/ - no tea rooms in the film though, closest is this coffee shop which looks more like the "espresso bar" that Nell and Elizabeth may have ended up opening!]

Next up: White Sand and Grey Sand

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
cheapskatemum · 27/07/2026 23:10

I remember reading my aunt’s copy of “Here Be Dragons” and loving it. I’m glad it’s back in print as I recommended it to a friend a few months ago. Looking forward to hearing what you think of it.

Waawo · 27/07/2026 06:20

And for today, a lovely new Stella novel to begin 😀

Love the feel of opening a new book for the very first time lol, even if it is just a fairly mass market paperback!

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
Waawo · 25/07/2026 11:08

Finished novel #15, "The Shadow of a Sorcerer."

I was kind of expecting this to be a little like Fort of the Bear: it's long out of print, it's set outside of the UK, and the original hardcover jacket features a similarly gaudy cover (although not AS gaudy, to be fair). This is another I read on archive.org / OpenLibrary, although I have now found a copy on Oxfam reduced to £10 so have ordered that, it hasn't arrived yet though.

We're back in the Alps for this one, in Austria specifically (and a little in Venice). The story seems to be standard Stella fare at first: Meg and her mother leave their middle class life behind for six months at a language school in the Alps in order for Meg to learn German in order to get a "top notch" job. So far so normal.

But at this point, Stella decides to throw in a little supernatural element: whether Esmé Carron is an actual sorcerer, or merely a tremendous influencer of people, it's hard to tell. The strange, other worldly effects he has, especially on Meg, are very well written though, and it's certainly a page turner. Obviously there are other Austenian subplots involving engagements and break offs and so on - the supernatural is only a small part of the whole!

Where this differs especially from Fort of the Bear is the descriptive writing about place. I don't know, but I would say from reading that Stella had at least been to Venice and the Alps, unlike North Western Canada!

There is a very funny bit of, I suppose it's called meta-fiction, late on in the book, when one of the characters is describing what happened earlier in the day:

Don't ask her what happened, because she won't talk. Perhaps she saw something nasty in the gondola-shed

It's not the first time Stella references CCF in a later novel; but a couple of paragraphs on, it gets even funnier:

The way [the previous character] had broken it was increasing Humphrey's feeling of dour withdrawal...with some rubbish out of that book about a farm that he was always quoting from...

It's like Stella is simultaneously reusing her most famous joke, mocking the fact that people endless repeated it, and pre-emptively mocking herself for reusing it. It's a commonly expressed view that in later life she was annoyed about the fact that she could never get away from CCF, and it seems to have some basis.

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
Waawo · 25/07/2026 10:53

FruAashild · 20/07/2026 09:54

Bloggers are now moving to substack and getting paid by subscription fees.

I know literally nothing about substack, except hearing a lot about it as a potential replacement a couple of years ago in the Twitter/X debacle. In my area at least, a lot of people seem to have moved their more "serious" output to medium.com...

OP posts:
FruAashild · 20/07/2026 09:54

Bloggers are now moving to substack and getting paid by subscription fees.

Terpsichore · 19/07/2026 19:06

I daren't fully go down the blogging rabbit-hole in earnest; I fear I'd never emerge….

Waawo · 19/07/2026 17:29

Terpsichore · 19/07/2026 16:41

Oh yes, I've enthused about that site on other threads. Isn’t it wonderful?

Yes, proper rabbit hole material!

Also surprising: the post that took me there was this one: https://clothesinbooks.blogspot.com/2016/02/dress-down-sunday-cat-among-pigeons-by.html from 2016, and there are posts from this year! Conventional wisdom is that blogging is all but dead, but presumably there are in fact hundreds of thousands of blogs quietly doing their thing 😀

Dress Down Sunday: Cat Among the Pigeons by Agatha Christie

published 1959 LOOKING AT WHAT GOES ON UNDER THE CLOTHES ‘ Can I speak to you, Miss Bulstrode?’ Miss Bulstrode laid her pen asi...

https://clothesinbooks.blogspot.com/2016/02/dress-down-sunday-cat-among-pigeons-by.html

OP posts:
Terpsichore · 19/07/2026 16:41

Waawo · 19/07/2026 16:14

After reading a thread here about the acronym "BBs" I did a bit of seaching earlier and came across this quirky but rather wonderful site, loosely based around "Clothes in Books", which also has a couple of things to say about Stella!

clothesinbooks.blogspot.com/2026/01/the-matchmaker-by-stella-gibbons.html

Oh yes, I've enthused about that site on other threads. Isn’t it wonderful?

Waawo · 19/07/2026 16:14

After reading a thread here about the acronym "BBs" I did a bit of seaching earlier and came across this quirky but rather wonderful site, loosely based around "Clothes in Books", which also has a couple of things to say about Stella!

clothesinbooks.blogspot.com/2026/01/the-matchmaker-by-stella-gibbons.html

OP posts:
Terpsichore · 11/07/2026 18:49

Glad the Open Library mention tipped you off, @Waawo. It can be incredibly useful. Though Fort of the Bear really does sound one for the super-fans….I commend your commitment to the project! 👏👏

Waawo · 11/07/2026 14:12

Finished novel #14, "Fort of the Bear."

I haven't found a physical copy yet, so read it on archive.org https://archive.org/details/bwb_KU-681-546] - I don't really know how this works in terms of copyright and so on. You have to create an account, and have to "borrow" the book, there's no printing or downloading, so it doesn't seem like a blatant copyright violation anyway! Hat tip to @Terpsichore who pointed my in this direction albeit obliquely but referencing Open Library way back in the thread. As an aside, I really don't like reading books only on the laptop screen, but hey ho, needs must and all that ;)

The story itself is very different from everything else by Stella that I've read so far. On one level it seems almost absurd: a British aristocrat takes his wife and three year old daughter, along with some of his servants, away from Sussex or wherever their country seat is, and into the wilds of North West Canada, in order to "get away from" cities. Hm, okay then.

However, as the story goes on, it gets much darker. Cristina (the wife) is ultimately trapped by her husband's uncompromising approach to life, and I think in reality it's not really about Canada at all: more, that one can be trapped anywhere, unable to extricate oneself from a situation, whether that be geographical or relational.

Plus, there are some extremely sad (and shocking!) moments. In summary, a very strange departure from the norm. I wonder how it went down on publication? I'm sure there must have been many who took this at face value, and in those terms it probably wasn't brilliantly reviewed.

Here's an alternative modern view, from one of the people behind Furrowed Middlebrow / DSP: https://furrowedmiddlebrow.blogspot.com/2018/04/a-slew-of-stella-gibbons-novels.html (at the bottom of the page).

There's no picture of the "book" this time of course; instead, the last page of the scan is the inside of the jacket, which has a picture of Stella I hadn't seen before.

Next up: The Shadow of a Sorcerer, which is also out of print.

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
Waawo · 08/07/2026 05:23

Finished my fourth Barbara Pym of the year: Less than Angels. I have to say, I didn't like it quite as much as the other three. It does have some very funny moments (of course), but is more overtly sad as well. Thank heavens for Catherine, who at least seems to have her head screwed on when it comes to narcissistic and ultimately doomed Tom.

I so often read books like this with a kind of AIBU vibe going on the background. AIBU to think my boyfriend should not be going to talk to his most recent ex about his struggles to get over his first love?!? ;)

[Waves at @MyyearwithBarbara - how are you doing? I'm assuming you've read this one?]

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
cheapskatemum · 04/07/2026 16:54

I’m envious you’ve got Enbury Heath on the shelf! I have to order it at my local library.

Waawo · 04/07/2026 16:52

Popped in to my local library today. This pic just about sums up Stella’s public image lol

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
Waawo · 02/07/2026 22:01

Waawo · 02/07/2026 22:00

Fort of the Bear is clearly not going to be totally straightforward - it may end up being another trip to the BL. I have found a scan of the cover at least.

Edited

Forgot you can't just add images inline. Attached now.

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
Waawo · 02/07/2026 22:00

Fort of the Bear is clearly not going to be totally straightforward - it may end up being another trip to the BL. I have found a scan of the cover at least.

OP posts:
cheapskatemum · 02/07/2026 11:44

Thanks @WaawoI’m going to my favourite bookshop on Saturday, I’ll see if they’ve got either or both of the other 2. I might be able to swap Westwood for one of them, although the condition of the copy World of Books sent me was not good.

Waawo · 02/07/2026 10:13

cheapskatemum · 02/07/2026 08:17

Which is your favourite so far?

Tricky one. Mostly the answer is “whichever one I’ve just finished” 😂

But if pushed, I love Enbury Heath. My American and Westwood run it close though.

OP posts:
cheapskatemum · 02/07/2026 08:17

Which is your favourite so far?

Waawo · 01/07/2026 23:02

Half time report!

As it's the start of July, I thought I'd just do a quick progress update:

Novels: 13 of 26 read
Short stories: 0 of 3 volumes read
Poetry: 3 of 4 volumes read
Childrens: 1 of 1 read

So pretty much "on target" to finish the entire oeuvre by the end of the year 😀

(Attached image shows a clip from my tracking sheet. Dark Green - read this year and owned; light green - read this year but not owned; yellow - not read this year but owned; white - neither read this year nor owned)

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
cheapskatemum · 01/07/2026 22:48

@Waawoyes, I found myself looking forward to it as the inevitability of it unfolded & it didn’t disappoint. It was so well written. Hilda certainly has her head screwed on!

Waawo · 01/07/2026 22:45

Finished novel #13, The Swiss Summer. I loved this, just pure joy from start to finish.

We're not in London now (apart from a couple of very short sections), but rather, in a chalet in the Swiss Alps. By now the characters are recognisable enough: Lucy, nominally at least our hero, who is the voice of reason and sanity, who can keep her head while all around are losing theirs; Freda, the baddie of the piece, who seemingly can't open her mouth without uttering something inappropriate; an old-money widow, back in London, casually pulling strings; and an assorted cast of "young people" all of whom have their own foibles.

The story itself is simple enough, but that's the point for me: it's another perfectly formed world, even within the very tight confines of a chalet and the surrounding little bit of mountainous Switzerland. The "twist" such as it is is obvious to everyone except the characters, and that doesn't spoil it at all, as the reveal and reactions to it are delicious.

Just a couple of the notes that I made while reading - both ironically enough about London:

"...travelling down the claustrophobic steeps of the moving staircases on the Underground..." - what a lovely phrase, and so right for the older stations, where the escalators were built in tunnels running diagonally up and down, rather than the giant halls of newer stations like most of the Jubilee Line and Elizabeth Line. And, I might start a campaign to start calling them "moving staircases" again, escalator is such a technical, non-feeling word ;)

And this, very modern sequence of thoughts: "London, she thought. The problem of food. The headlines in the papers. The problem of drink. The nine o'clock news and the one o'clock news that took away your appetite if you were fool enough to turn it on. The problem of cigarettes. What will Russia do now or next? The Government. A hidden airplane throbbing through the low London clouds. Dammit those people are coming in tonight and we're out of gin. Bevin flies to, or at, Paris or Churchill or both. Or is it Bevan? The problem of Western Germany. The problem of Mass Emigration. Darling, I feel like seeing some people. The problem of Atomic energy. One of that new kind, screaming like a damned soul down the sky and out of sight in five seconds. The problem of imports. The problem. Hullo, Lu, my ducky, John's in town just for the night and we want to see you. Yes, she thought, living in London is like living in Hell."

[I should add that neither Lucy, nor me, nor Stella herself, ever actually leave London for long though (so far in my case at least).]

How wonderful that Dean Street Press has kept this one alive! I can't find anything about how DSP came to be so named; but their website has a fair bit of Soho/Theatreland vibe, so I assume it's taken from the Soho street. Somewhat randomly, I unexpectedly changed jobs a few weeks ago, and now work in an office in a lane just off... Dean Street!

Next up: Fort of the Bear, one that is still out of print, so I need to find a nice second hand copy.

My year with Stella...
OP posts:
Waawo · 01/07/2026 22:16

cheapskatemum · 26/06/2026 20:36

Thanks @FruAashildtheir books are similar aren’t they?

I’ve finished Westwood, despite wondering whether I could as I found Gerard such a creep. Still he got his come uppance in the end. The description of Linda made me glad that attitudes to disability have come a long way since it was written.

Gerard is so awful isn't he! But, I'm in awe of Hilda, she seems to know exactly what she's doing throughout, despite his supposed superiority! And the scene where everybody meets, despite being visible a mile off, really is very funny :)

OP posts: