Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Sci-fi book club selections

37 replies

Perroquet · 16/03/2024 18:40

I joined a local science fiction book club last year, hoping to get a chance to read and discuss "classic" scifi books that are on my list (Isaac Asimov, Arthur C Clarke, Jules Verne, Philip K Dick, etc.)

But so far all the selections chosen by popular vote have been very modern books written only in the last decade, like the Imperial Radch series (starting with Ancillary Justice) and the Terra Ignota series (starting with Too like the Lightning). I tried reading these but didn't find them engaging or their style pleasant and ended up not finishing them. Despite a small number of club members having suggested classics, we always get outvoted. I feel really disappointed at the lack of chronological diversity of book selections, and at this point have stopped reading their selections and attending book discussions. For context, most of the members of the club are in their mid-20s to early 30s, I believe.

If you enjoy classic scifi books, do you also enjoy the modern series like those the club selected? Or do you find them annoying, contrived, and a little too "woke" like I do? Are there any good modern scifi books that you would recommend for fans of classics?

I know people will tell me "just start your own club if you don't like the books they choose". I don't have the energy/resources to start a new club but will just read the classics on my list on my own (and maybe discuss them privately with a few others who might be interested).

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 18/03/2024 08:59

A year or so ago I read 'Breakfast of Champions' by Kurt Vonnegurt as some friends mentioned it. I doubt it would be published these days, I was surprised at the amount of racist language.

Many of these books were products of their time and do come across as a bit cringeworthy.

Sadik · 18/03/2024 08:08

Perroquet · 17/03/2024 16:58

Making things unnecessarily complicated with gender (or the lack thereof), "misgendering", switching pronouns for the same character in a confusing way, etc.

I guess for me, classic SFF would include Le Guin (Left Hand of Darkness plus others) & Marge Piercy (Woman on the Edge of Time) both of whom would be counted as 'woke' in your definition.

EllieQ · 17/03/2024 18:22

LenaLamont · 16/03/2024 23:42

They have dated very much, and in many cases would be a very hard sell to a modern readership.

I loved Asimov when I read him in the 80s. I re-read a few quite recently and wow, the text is clunky. Philip K Dick has wonderful concepts but again, quite heavy going for readers used to the more character-led and faster paced novels of today.

Stylistically, novels have changed significantly in the past 60 years. As with television and films, the pacing is completely different.

If you want a SF Classics book group, online is far more likely to be your friend than face to face groups.

If you’re looking resigned to leaving the classics behind, Adrian Tchaikovsky, Claire North and Becky Chambers are all modern science fiction writers I’d recommend, if you’ve not tried them, OP

I agree with this - I read a few of the classics when I was in my teens/ twenties (1990s-2000s) and found them slow and clunky compared to the new SF being published then, so I imagine they’d seem even more so now.

In terms of modern SF, I’d suggest the Old Man’s War by John Scalzi, which is very straightforward SF with a feel of the 50s-60s classics.

Second the Lois McMaster Bujold suggestion - her first books were published in the 80s and she’s continued writing since then. The Vorkosigan series is SF, but her others are fantasy.

The Murderbot series by Martha Wells is great, and I suspect the younger club members would enjoy it.

I was going to suggest easing the other members in gently by suggesting books from the 80s-90s and see how they react, but I see that you’ve stopped going. Maybe something to think about if you go back to it. Another idea would be to suggest reading the winners/ nominees for the Hugo and Nebula awards over the past 20-30 years - lots of interesting stuff there.

BigFatLiar · 17/03/2024 17:36

We both were/are into sci-fi. When we were younger the classics were fairly new. A recent collection we've both been enjoying is Backyard Starship series (on kindle unlimited). Old fashioned space adventure with a fair bit of humour.

Perroquet · 17/03/2024 16:58

SableGrape · 17/03/2024 16:55

Define woke for me.

Making things unnecessarily complicated with gender (or the lack thereof), "misgendering", switching pronouns for the same character in a confusing way, etc.

OP posts:
SableGrape · 17/03/2024 16:55

Define woke for me.

Sadik · 17/03/2024 16:55

I guess the problem with reading classics in a specifically SFF bookclub, is that it's likely that most of the members would already have read them.

I'm mid-50s, I read a lot of classic sci-fi in my teens / early twenties, but these days mostly read more modern novels. I'd say with recently published SFF, there's good and bad, just as there was back in the day.

Of the two you mentioned, I quite enjoyed the Imperial Radch books, and absolutely loved the Terra Ignota series. Other modern authors - like the pp, I also rate Adrian Tchaikovsky, though some are better than others (fair enough, he writes a lot!). Dogs of War is my favourite. You might also find the Three Body Problem & sequels worth trying if hard SF is more your thing. Becky Chambers is fine as an entertaining read but pretty lightweight IMO.

Perroquet · 17/03/2024 16:54

Thank you for these suggestions. I've heard good things about Andy Weir's books so will probably give those a try. I also enjoy fantasy by Terry Pratchett (Discworld) and Neil Gaiman.

I considered joining online reading groups but it just doesn't have the same feeling as interacting with people in the local community in person, where you can make friends that you might see outside of the book club if you share other interests.

OP posts:
Ellmau · 16/03/2024 23:50

Have you tried Lois McMaster Bujold?

LenaLamont · 16/03/2024 23:42

They have dated very much, and in many cases would be a very hard sell to a modern readership.

I loved Asimov when I read him in the 80s. I re-read a few quite recently and wow, the text is clunky. Philip K Dick has wonderful concepts but again, quite heavy going for readers used to the more character-led and faster paced novels of today.

Stylistically, novels have changed significantly in the past 60 years. As with television and films, the pacing is completely different.

If you want a SF Classics book group, online is far more likely to be your friend than face to face groups.

If you’re looking resigned to leaving the classics behind, Adrian Tchaikovsky, Claire North and Becky Chambers are all modern science fiction writers I’d recommend, if you’ve not tried them, OP

Mothership4two · 16/03/2024 23:32

I tend to like the older stuff too. I enjoy Andy Weir and Blake Couch books.

pinkgown · 16/03/2024 19:58

I used to read a lot of science fiction, but haven't been tempted to read modern sf - I've graduated towards fantasy these days. Of the little I've read I enjoyed Terry Pratchett and Stephen Baxter's Long Earth series and Stephen Donaldson's The Gap Cycle (though this is a bit older, and I prefer his fantasy!)

Also love Kate Elliott's books - mostly they are fantasy but her Jaran series is sf. I haven't read her latest yet (The Sun Chronicles) - that's sf too.