Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Books Challenge 2022 Part Seven

782 replies

Southeastdweller · 30/11/2022 10:19

Welcome to the seventh and (and probably) final thread of the 50 Books Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2022, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, and even though it's late in the year, it’s not too late to join. Please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

How have you got on this year?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Terpsichore · 20/12/2022 08:17

92: Young Mrs Burton - Margaret Penn

Third and final volume of the trilogy that started with Manchester Fourteen Miles. Hilda had become engaged to the older but charming army captain Frank Burton at the end of the previous volume; now he’s home from WW1, minus an arm, and showing worrying signs of carelessness when it comes to money. Hilda, though, wrapped in a blissful romantic dream and soon to have her first baby, is too dim to notice anything, and it takes a more worldly friend to alert her that Frank is drinking heavily.

The narrative takes a dark and distressing turn as Frank fails to find work and repeatedly disappears on epic binges, often leaving Hilda and their children (two of them now) literally starving, borrowing money from everyone within sight and failing to pay rent time and time again. I’m afraid my patience with Hilda evaporated as she kept forgiving her scumbag husband, and had to remind myself that her options in the 1920s were limited - and indeed the terrible point was reached where both her beloved children were given up for adoption to a well-off childless couple who adored them, while Hilda - unbelievably - reunited with Frank even after he’d yet again stolen her savings to go and get obliterated. The trilogy ends here but 'Hilda'/Margaret Penn lived until 1982 and I long to know what happened to her subsequently - it’s frustrating that there doesn’t seem to be anything online about her later life.

93: The Clothes They Stood Up In - Alan Bennett

Novella/short story. A middle-aged couple come home from the opera one night to find that literally all their possessions have been stolen from their flat. Amusing but, as always with Bennett, layers are gradually revealed to leave a much sadder and more thought-provoking story at the end.

GrannieMainland · 20/12/2022 07:22

Agree @Stokey I thought People Person was such a disappointment compared with Queenie.

I read Fleischman when it came out and absolutely loved it, I thought it was vivid and witty and insightful! Feel like I must have been reading a different book now...

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 19/12/2022 22:50

I loved Queenie (did that not come across?)

@Stokey and Fleischman is awful but it's very compelling in its awfulness

Stokey · 19/12/2022 22:43

Like @PepeLePew I'm going to have read a lot less this year. I blame the news. I spent a good few months unable to stop refreshing Twitter while various governments imploded. I did also make an active effort to read less thrashy thrillers which I have on the whole achieved.

Stokey · 19/12/2022 22:40

Just catching up and feel slightly out of vogue as I liked Hammer, Queenie and even Fleischman although agree both members of the couple were annoying. And the weird author/narrator/breaking 4th wall really didn't work.

After loving The Seven Moons of Maali Almeida, I've come sharply down to Earth.

  1. Ponti - Sharlene Teo. This is a debut novel set in Singapore. It's about two girls Szu and Circe, who are school friends. The story is divided into Szu's tale when they're 16 in 2003, Circe's tale when they're estranged adults in 2020 and Szu's mother Amisa, who was a beautiful actress in the 1970s. The descriptions of Singapore are great, oppressive clammy heat and weird food, but the plot is virtually non-existent, and the characters are all miserable and rather flat. I really didn't enjoy this.

  2. People Person - Candice Carty- Williams. The writer of Queenie's second novel is about 5 half siblings. They all have the same father and 4 different mothers and don't really know each other, but come together when the middle girl accidentally harms her boyfriend. I found the writing pedestrian, the story predictable and the main character particularly annoying. I think I may have liked this if I was in my 20s but just felt like the wrong audience, unlike Queenie which I felt just jumped off the page regardless of my age.

MaudOfTheMarches · 19/12/2022 18:47

I think that's a good approach with the diaries, @MegBusset, although I'm not sure Stalin would be my alternate book. SSM was on Laura Kuenssberg last week and I was surprised to hear he goes by the name Sebag, rather than Simon. I thought Laura K had it wrong, at first, but she used it throughout.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 19/12/2022 17:49

@MegBusset Wishing you luck with the Stalin. It took me forever. In fact, there might be a version of me in a parallel universe still reading the damned thing.

MegBusset · 19/12/2022 17:41

I'm reading it in parallel with Simon Sebag Montefiore's epic Stalin biog, so enjoying dipping into it when the body count gets too much and I just want to read about lovely suppers with Ian McKellen and bitching about theatre critics.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 19/12/2022 17:18

I did feel with the Rickman diaries that anything good ended up in The Guardian, so that the excerpt both wasn't indicative of the whole piece and implied it was all of a similar vein, which is naughty. I did enjoy it, however.

MegBusset · 19/12/2022 16:25

Don't panic, @BestIsWest - I'm currently reading the Rickman diaries and thoroughly enjoying them, so you might too!

BestIsWest · 19/12/2022 14:52

Oh dear. Gazing at what I think is in all probability Alan Rickman’s diaries under the Christmas tree.

Bill Bryson - Down Under My all time favourite of his and my no 1 comfort read.

Southeastdweller · 19/12/2022 13:56

Madly, Deeply; the Alan Rickman Diaries - edited by Alan Taylor.

The most disappointing book I've read for a long, long time, very poorly edited. For every insightful or entertaining entry published in here, there's a hundred more that simply state where he went for dinner, what he ate for dinner, who he had dinner with, what airport he flew from etc. The editor says the original material totalled over a million words, and it's clear he has omitted lots of content (probably not wanting to offend some of A.R's friends and colleagues) and included far too many mundane entries. Generally, this book is as dull as ditchwater and it pains me to say it as I usually love reading diaries and was a huge fan of A.R. I can't imagine he would have wanted these diaries published (more a selection of notes, as he himself wrote).

OP posts:
PepeLePew · 19/12/2022 13:50

I don't think I will get to 100 this year - it will be the first time in several years. Too much time trying to distract myself from various problems by scrolling social media. That needs to change.

Eine I laughed at your review of Fleischmann Is In Trouble. That was more or less my view. Such tedious people with tedious problems.

83 Names for the Sea by Sarah Moss
I think I have read this before but couldn’t remember most of it. Family relocates to Iceland for a year just after the 2007 crash and attempt to navigate its oddities (lack of a second-hand market for furniture, food is expensive and not great, terrible driving conditions, awful weather – think that sums it up). I don’t want to be mean. I love Moss’s novels and this was very well done. I got a bit bored by the forays into history or her encounters with quirky locals but on the whole would recommend this.

84 The Ministry for the Future by Kim Stanley Robinson
I believe this is from the genre now known as “cli-fi”. Essentially, using science to make sense of what a future affected by climate change would look like. Only about 50% of this was a novel – the rest was a series of musings or short essays on a really wide range of topics from blockchain as a tool for delivering carbon reduction and social equality to wildlife corridors and glaciation, although they were all placed in ways that made sense of the narrative and built upon each other. There was a lot going on and it wasn’t entirely successful in holding my attention as a novel but as a somewhat hopeful vision of the future it was gripping. In fact, there’s at least one idea in there that we’ve often kicked around at work as a possible solution to one dimension of the climate crisis so it’s not particularly farfetched in many places. And it is a brilliant exploration of systems and contributing factors to climate change – from the role of the financial markets to environmental tipping points. I think this will probably go down as one of my books of the year. I’d absolutely recommend for anyone who wants to learn more about climate change in a digestible non-academic way and who wants to believe there is a scrap of hope for our future as humans (which I have to say, most of the time I find hard to locate).

85 The Silent Corner by Dean Koontz
I thought Dean Koontz wrote Stephen King-style horror. For the first 75% of this book, I thought I must be wrong and he was actually a slightly more creative Lee Child type writer (don’t get me wrong, I love a Jack Reacher novel but they are on the formulaic end of the spectrum). Then by the final stretch, I realised there was more of a Stephen King element then I had appreciated at the start and that the plot wasn’t all going to wrapped up neatly in this book and I’d have to read at least the next one in the series if not a few more. So that was a lot of readjustment needed in the course of a relatively short book.

It is hard not to compare the protagonist (Jane Hawk, FBI agent on leave from the Bureau following her husband’s suicide) with Jack Reacher because they are both smart, focused on taking down baddies, stunningly attractive to the opposite sex and able to flit across the US without leaving much of a trace. Hawk has a slightly more developed emotional hinterland than Reacher though I felt that only came forward when the plot demanded it – it didn’t seem to affect her day to day decisions much.

Hawk is on the trail of a bunch of VERY BAD people who are doing VERY BAD things to VERY GOOD people. She makes extraordinary leaps of deduction and is lucky enough to come into contact with some VERY HELPFUL people who are the difference between success and failure on her quest, plus a lock picking device which is mentioned so many times I assume Koontz gets commission from the manufacturers. This is all a bit odd and I have lots of unanswered questions but it was sufficiently diverting from my general angst and woes that I will certainly read the next one, if not the ones after that.

RomanMum · 19/12/2022 06:57

Catching up with the chat after dropping off for a while. My reading has really slowed down in the pre-Christmas madness.

Sadik - interesting thoughts re YA fiction, I think you're right. I read The Dark is Rising for the first time last year and was slightly underwhelmed. Waiting for the radio adaptation to see if that inspires instead. Over Sea, Under Stone however... I read as a child and reread last year and it was just as good as I remember.

I think the "italics=poor" is useful though as we've seen with Hamnet one person's italics is another person's bold... Anyway.

63. Shepperton Studios: a Visual Celebration - Morris Bright

Literally the heaviest book I have ever read, a two handed lift.

A coffee table history of the famous film studios, with short chapters from behind the camera aspects of film making, and longer sections tracing the different phases and personalities involved in the life of the studios up till 2005 when it was published. Interesting stuff about the business and technical side of film making as well as some anecdotes about the actors associated with the studios, from Peter Sellers and Richard Attenborough to Kenneth Branagh. Stuffed full of great photos too. Recommended reading for film buffs.

Palegreenstars · 18/12/2022 22:14

@RazorstormUnicorn just finished it - the moment you were talking about was very odd!

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 18/12/2022 22:10
  1. Fleischman Is In Trouble by Taffy Brodesser-Akner

Two exhausting members of the New York 1% become The First People To Ever Get A Divorce

OH MY LIFE IS SO HARD BECAUSE I'M SUCH A SUCCESS THAT I SPEND ALL MY TIME BEING WEIRDLY SUPERIOR TO MY HUSBAND ABOUT MONEY WHILST STAGE MANAGING MY CHILDREN'S EVERY MOVE

MY LIFE IS SO HARD BECAUSE I HAVE TO LOOK AFTER MY CHILDREN FOR A CHANGE AND STOP FUCKING EVERY WOMAN WHO REMOTELY BREATHES IN MY DIRECTION

I think in the final third we are supposed to empathise with Rachel, but as she's so shallow and narcissistic it's basically impossible to feel anything for a woman who disappears herself for weeks :

MY SMALL CHILDREN HAVE NO IDEA WHERE I AM, BUT I AM TOO BUSY SHAGGING MY FRIENDS HUSBAND AND HAVING SCREAMING THERAPY AT AN ELITE YOGA RETREAT WHILST MY HUSBAND WONDERS IF I MIGHT BE DEAD.

The narration is occasionally taken over by a friend of the couple, and this proves confusing.

It's a real toss up as to whether or not the author intends genuine resonance for the reader or whether it's written to provoke reactions like mine. Sadly, I actually think it's the former and it's a comment on How Everything Is So Hard If You Are Rich And Live In New York, Isn't It?

Nauseating.

TimeforaGandT · 18/12/2022 22:01

@EineReiseDurchDieZeit - thank you, that’s useful to know!

I am getting in some short, easy reads but maybe I will pick up Book 3 as an early read for 2023.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 18/12/2022 21:51

@TimeforaGandT

I started on ASOIAF just as the series was about to begin. This meant that every twist and turn of A Storm Of Swords was a complete surprise. It's the best of the series definitely, much better than ACOK it may feel like you need a break, but my advice is take that break after Book 3, Book 4 wasn't that great

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 18/12/2022 21:21

Greenwitch by Susan Cooper
I thought I hadn't read this before, but I recognised lots of it so I must have!
I liked it.

RazorstormUnicorn · 18/12/2022 20:53

That was in reply to @Palegreenstars !

RazorstormUnicorn · 18/12/2022 20:53

I would agree with that. And there is a bit at the end where he's either talking about tans or being very racist. I gave him benefit of the doubt but who knows.

Palegreenstars · 18/12/2022 17:56

@RazorstormUnicorn im rereading skipping Christmas for the first time since it came out. Gentle is the word. It’s also so dated now I’m finding - Luther is a bit of a creep.

RazorstormUnicorn · 18/12/2022 17:31

49. Skipping Christmas by John Grisham

After really liking listening to Bill Bryson Christmas book I thought I'd pick another on audible and this was a good choice. Gentle and fairly predictable, funny in places.

Just one more book to go to hit 50. This means seems to be a number that works quite well for me. About one a week.

Hoping to find some more books that grab me next year, as I am struggling to recall highlights and don't think there were many where I felt 'I can't put this down'

I think next year I am going to read less non fiction. I get a bit bogged down in them and whilst I do like exploring issues and broadening my knowledge, I don't think I'm retaining much of it and it's not always fun or relaxing....

TimeforaGandT · 18/12/2022 15:29

I enjoyed both Hamnet and The Marriage Portrait…..

Adding my latest reads:

81. A Clash of Kings - George RR Martin

The second in the GoT series. Very long! The television series has stuck faithfully to the story (which pleases me!). As the title suggests, nearly everyone’s a King (Robb Stark, Joffrey Baratheon/Lannister, Stannis Baratheon, Renly Baratheon and whilst she hasn’t declared herself, Daenerys Targaryen believes herself to be rightful ruler too). Lots of fighting and military strategy. My favourite narrators are Tyrion and Arya. I find Bran and Daenerys quite dull and am ambivalent about Jon Snow and life north of the Wall. Maybe a while before I get to Book 3.

82. The Paris Apartment - Lucy Foley

Jess arrives to stay with her journalist brother in Paris and finds he has disappeared without trace from a very smart apartment building (seemingly out of his budget) populated by a strange collection of people. She searches for her brother convinced the answer lies in the apartments. A real page-turner with some twists (some more unexpected than others).

ChessieFL · 18/12/2022 13:31

287 A Snow Garden And Other Stories by Rachel Joyce

A lovely collection of Christmas stories that I always like to reread at this time of year.

288 Do They Know It’s Christmas Yet? by James Crookes

This is really good fun, although despite the name it’s not actually very Christmassy! Brother and sister Tash and Jamie end up time travelling back to 1984 where they cause chaos, including preventing Bob Geldof from watching the news so he never saw the report about Ethiopia and never created Band Aid. Can Tash and Jamie put this right and get back to 2020?